UPDATED ON:
Wednesday, January 28, 2009
11:37 Mecca time, 08:37 GMT
 
FOCUS: MIDDLE EAST
The Arab Peace Initiative

The Saudi-brokered peace plan was given renewed support by Washington [GALLO/GETTY]

George Mitchell, the newly-appointed US Middle East envoy, is likely to use the Arab Peace Initiative as a starting point for negotiations when he meets with Israeli and Arab leaders on January 28.

Mitchell is scheduled to stop in Egypt followed by visits to Israel, the Palestinian West Bank, Jordan, Turkey and Saudi Arabia before heading to Europe.

The Saudi-brokered plan, which was endorsed by the Arab League's 22 members during the March 2002 Beirut summit, outlined comprehensive steps to ending the Palestinian-Israeli conflict.

Arab leaders collectively offered Israel recognition of its right to exist and a normalisation of diplomatic ties in exchange for its complete withdrawal from Arab lands captured since 1967.

The plan, first floated by King Abdullah, then crown prince of Saudi Arabia, called for the restoration of a Palestinian state with east Jerusalem as its capital and a "fair solution" for the 3.8 million Palestinian refugees, including but not limited to the Syrian Golan Heights and Israeli-occupied territory in southern Lebanon.

Barack Obama, the US president, said in an interview to the Al Arabiya news station on January 26, that he appreciates the Saudi peace plan.

He said the US remained committed to protecting its long-time ally Israel, but also believed that there were Israelis who recognised the need for regional peace and would be willing to make the necessary sacrifices to achieve that.

Opposition

The Saudi plan received further backing at an Arab League summit in 2007 [AFP]
The Saudi plan is based on UN resolutions 242 and 338 which collectively called for Israeli withdrawal in exchange for peaceful ties with its Arab neighbours and the "respect for the right of every state in the area to live in peace within secure and recognised boundaries".

It also reaffirmed an Arab League resolution taken in June 1996 at the Cairo Extraordinary Arab Summit that "a just and comprehensive peace in the Middle East is the strategic option of the Arab countries, to be achieved in accordance with international legality, and which would require a comparable commitment on the part of the Israeli government".

The Arab League proposed the Arab Peace Initiative at the height of the second intifada in 2002.

Though the plan was supported by George Bush, the then US president, and Tony Blair, the then British prime minister, it was opposed by factions in both the Arab and Israeli camps.

Syria opposed the use of the term "normalisation", while Palestinian factions such as the armed wing of Hamas, Islamic Jihad and the al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigade rejected the Saudi plan outright.

The plan also did not receive full diplomatic backing as only 10 of the 22 heads of state were able to attend the Beirut summit.

Israeli authorities also barred Yasser Arafat, the late Palestinian president, from travelling to Lebanon to attend the sessions when it said it would not guarantee his return to Ramallah, the Palestinian administrative capital.

On the same day the plan was announced in Beirut, a Palestinian suicide bomber killed 20 people and injured more than 160 others at the Park Hotel in Netanya, Israel.

On March 29, Israel launched Operation Defensive Shield, a massive Israeli military operation in the West Bank, in response to the Netanya attack. Israeli military forces briefly occupied Ramallah, Jenin, and Nablus.

More than 500 Palestinians and 29 Israeli soldiers were killed in the four-week military operation.

Plan re-endorsed

The Saudi-initiated peace plan did not resurface as a viable deal until the Arab League summit in Riyadh in March 2007. This time, 21 heads of state attended the summit (Libya did not send a delegation) and fully re-endorsed the pleace plan.

Though Mahmoud Abbas, the Palestinian president, endorsed the plan, Ismail Haniya, the then Palestinian prime minister, abstained.

The European Union, the US and the UN fully backed the plan as the only means forward.

Ban Ki-Moon, the UN secretary-general, said: "The Arab peace initiative is one of the pillars of the peace process ... it sends a signal that the Arabs are serious about achieving peace."

Israeli reaction

Though Ehud Olmert, the Israeli prime minister, supported the plan, the official Israeli response says there are several items in the Saudi-brokered plan which are unacceptable.

Israeli peace negotiators have objected to the repatriation of some 3.8 million Palestinian refugees.

Shimon Peres, the Israeli president, said in October that Israel would not rule out negotiations with Arab countries on the basis of the Saudi plan.

"We accept the Arab peace initiative in order to bring peace to the entire region," Peres said in the Egyptian resort of Sharm el-Sheikh, after talks with Mubarak.

He said that while he does not accept all of the Saudi plan and it "needs to be negotiated" further, its spirit is "correct". 

 Source: Al Jazeera
Feedback Number of comments : 19
 
ALEX
Belarus
28/01/2009
its not israel fault
(part 2) look at Gorden Turkey and Egypt this countries prosper since they chose the way of peace and if arab make a joke from them selves its only there own fault

Wondering
United States
28/01/2009
If the Arab States wanted Peace with Israel
If the Arab League states wanted peace with Israel they would have long since recognized it's "right to exist", and the most rudimentary obviousness of the incompatability between "repatriation" of refugees and the continuation of the State of Isreal. The fact that the Arab League puts a time limit on acceptance of their plan (will withdraw it) is testament to how serious they are about it. What did they do? Decide to change their minds?

susan trevelyan-syke
United Kingdom
28/01/2009
The Arab Peace Initiative
The Arab Peace Initiative is as good as it gets and I am happy our US envoy is using it. Palestinians need to understand that many of their international frustrations stem from lacking a legal status: statehood. Once they have recognized borders, Israel's Lebensraum can be prevented. Abbas, Barghouti and Meshaal understand this. Israel does NOT want peace or borders. Arabs need to be smart and work with Mitchell, the EU and UN to achieve justice and a legal homeland.

Robert
Afghanistan
28/01/2009
Gaza
Many Arabs seem to stupidly not even want peace. When large groups of Arabs refuse to even accept the concept of accepting Israel's right to exist what is Israel's choice but to keep doing what it has been doing. Politically, those in Gaza are being led by people who do not really care for them, because if they did they would stop firing rockets and planting roadside bombs because then they would be able to win the political battle.

abdul
Afghanistan
27/01/2009
sometimes is hard to know in whose interest the arab elite in saudi, egypt and the tiny gulf states are working for, it seems they care more about israel than the arabs...what is the point of normalising relationship with israel when the israelis see the arabs as joke! the key is to squeeze israeli by not having any kind of relations directly and indirectly and take measures aganist her stunchest supporters...that's only how israel will b responsible and treat the region with respect

Munir Mian
Canada
27/01/2009
Arab Peace Initiative:
Re: Arab peace initiative: As long as the US keeps supplying to Israel the most sophisticated weapons of mass destruction and some $4billion a year in economic aid without any strings attached, Israelis have no wish to comply with the Arab peace plan or UN initiated plan. President Bush didn't have the courage to defy the Jewish lobby or Israel. Does President Obama have it? Munir Mian

Victor
United States
28/01/2009
Peace initiative.
If Israel accepts this peace initiative, that will be a miracle. Israel will be in a worse position geographically if they accept this and there is no full support of this plan from all MidEast countries. The next Arab step is to disarm Israel's nuclear capability and cut US support. Then the Arab armies can attack Israel and massacre all the Jews. A Muslim Victory over Israel.

Da man
United States
28/01/2009
israel
I believe the argument about the land taken after the 'Six Day War' should be brought up in George Mitchells' meetings w/Arab officials. This could definitely launch some intellectual conversation between government leaders other than the status quo, which is protecting Israel. Israel has a right to protect herself excluding United States tax payer’s funds. The United States Constitution when interpreted in its original context would absolutely never advocate intervening in foreign Problems.

Omar Iqbal
United States
28/01/2009
Shimon Peres Peace PRIZE?!
I cannot believe Israeli President Shimon Peres got a Nobel PEACE PRIZE of all things...Negotiating the Refugee crises should be the first thing you do with those type of accolades. Really now.

Great White North
Canada
29/01/2009
Arab peace, get real
If the Arab nations wanted peace then they would recognize Israels right to be a nation in the middle east and would have diplomatic relations with it. Ganging up on Tiny Israel does not indicate peace.

sam the palestinian
Afghanistan
29/01/2009
to hell with israel
they zionist took the land by force. they dont want to pay for the land they stole. they never wanted peace. anytime we are close to coming to an agreement, they attack and shatter the moment.the only way to get the land back is by force.

adel
United States
29/01/2009
arab peace plan.
ok, start off with a nice piece of land and give it to israel. that should make them very happy. I want to see the Israeli peace initiative one day. I think it's completely different then the arab one.

A hossain
United Kingdom
29/01/2009
victor&peace initiative
To bring true peace between israel & Arab countries,beleiving each other is the main point.Both parties specially Israelis have to make a lot of changes in their mentalities. I feel sorry for Mr victor,because his thinking is not wider than extreme TALIBAN thinking.Your thought won't bring peace for Israel because Palestinian deserve justice. I believe most people in the world don't think like you & they'll put presseur on dishonest leaders to do the right thing for innocent sufferers.

Ibrahim
Malaysia
29/01/2009
Those in charge in Gaza dont care?
Dear Robert, You're not living in Gaza so you don't know how it feels being starved for 18 months due to the Israeli blockade. Maybe your children have enough to eat. Unfortunately those mothers and fathers in Gaza don't have enough to feed their children. They have the money to buy food but there's no food to buy because of the blockade. What is there left to do for those in charge in Gaza but to fire rockets towards the Israelis that have been defying them their basic necessities?

Jeremy Woolf
United Kingdom
29/01/2009
The Arab Peace Initiative
Ibrahim, you blame it all on the siege but why did the siege start? Because of rockets and the Hamas governments refusal to renounce violence and state that it is prepared to recognise Israel in recognition for a Palestinian state. The cause of the problems is that Hamas is not willing to agree to this. Why should Israel take steps to aid an organisation whose aim is its distruction?

Naj
Afghanistan
29/01/2009
The Arab Peace Initiative
These Arab governments have been always there to protect Israel. They have played always this role and massacred any national movement or any resistance. These governments provide the enemy with Gas through Egypt and Petrol through Saudi Arabia. They have embassies with criminals. Chavez’s shoes are more decent than anyone of them.

Marie Devine
United States
01/02/2009
No Peace Until Word Of God Brought In
God always stirred nations against Israel when they turned from God's ways. Gaza is not perfect before God but at least they want Him to rule. Israel has adopted the Western anti-God in government. Wars are for those who reject God in truth. Arab nations have also been caught by the deceitfulness of riches. They cannot bring peace until the truth of the word of God is brought in. The primary message of the Qur'an is to follow the whole Bible. Jesus said to live by every word of God

George
United States
02/02/2009
Check your facts
Once again, you repeat the same imaginary arab deaths. There were no 500 casualties. In fact there were less than 45 palestinian casualties on that israeli operation.

Omar Iqbal
United States
02/02/2009
The Quran does not say to follow the bible
Okay, in response to the comment by Marie Devine, I agree that Israel has adopted an anti-God western ideology even if they disguise this truth under their Jewish National Banner, however.....the Quran does not say to follow every word of the bible, for the bible was corrupted by man and the Quran is the only preserved divine word of God.

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article