UPDATED ON:
Friday, February 27, 2009
13:11 Mecca time, 10:11 GMT
 
FOCUS: BANGLADESH
Mutiny reveals Bangladesh chaos

Money from UN peacekeeping duties may keep the Bangladesh army away from local politics [EPA]


The mutiny by Bangladesh's border security forces in the capital Dhaka has brought back the spectre of violence that has marked the country's recent political history.

That the army had to be called out to quell the uprising just weeks after December's election is an important reminder that the country's political situation remains complex and fragile despite the restoration of democratic rule.

Analysts had warned prior to the elections that any unrest could distract the poll winners from implementing much-needed economic reforms and discourage prospective investment.

They also voiced concern about the military's role once an elected government took charge.

The assumption at that time was that the army would remain behind the scenes for a while to see if the new government could tackle endemic corruption and avoid violence.

Overt role

Now that violence on such a dramatic scale has erupted in the centre of Dhaka, the generals may feel compelled to attempt a more overt role.

However, conflicts elsewhere in the world are likely to persuade the Bangladeshi army to leave governance at home to the politicians.

The incentive it has for doing so is that minimum local involvement means maximum flexibility to serve in various overseas UN peacekeeping missions.

Those missions, in which Bangladesh often has the largest contingent, generate compensatory payments to the country as well as salaries for the participating soldiers and officers salaries far above what they earn at home.

This very disparity could be a factor behind the current mutiny.

The Bangladesh Rifles (BDR), whose primary duty is border security, by the very nature of its job does not often get to share the UN bounty. It also does not have any officers of its own. Commissioned officers from the army do that job.

According to local media, BDR troops are demanding better wages, more food subsidies and additional holidays.

Major-General Shakil Ahmed, the BDR chief, has previously refused to listen to his troops' demands.

"It seems to be a mutiny of BDR troops" against their regular army officers, an armed forces spokesman said.

Coups and instability

The mainly Muslim but secular country of 144 million, formerly known as East Pakistan, has a history of instability, coups and countercoups since winning independence from Pakistan in 1971.

It experienced credible democracy for a while. But faced with serious economic and social crises, Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, the country's founder president, assumed authoritarian powers. Shortly afterwards, in 1975, soldiers mounted a coup, killing Mujib and wiping out his family as well as his cabinet.

After years of rule by army generals in and out of uniform, Sheikh Hasina, Mujibur Rahman's daughter, and Khaleda Zia, the widow of Ziaur Rahman, another slain president, alternated as prime ministers over a 15-year period that ended in late 2006.

Those times were marked by chaos, boycotts of parliament by losing parties, lack of compromise, bad faith and mudslinging, and deadly violence inflicted by and on political partisans.

"Regardless of who wins the election, the next government and the opposition parties will face the challenges of making parliament work and contending with an army that wants a greater say in politics," the International Crisis Group, which tracks conflicts worldwide, had warned in December.

While the sense of déjà vu may bring back prophesies of doom, it is still too early for the army to overtly exercise its influence.

The money involved in terms of much-needed foreign aid for the country and the UN peacekeeping earnings will discourage the military from taking on a more central role at least for now.

 Source: Al Jazeera
Feedback Number of comments : 30
 
Sadaf Khan
Bangladesh
26/02/2009
Ammnesty for the killers!
These mutineers killed over 100 officers, dumped bodies into the swerage and raped their family members. And our goverment have announced ammnesty after all this how can they do so.This goverment is trying cover it up. Media sould publish the real story and help the real victims.

Sakib
Bangladesh
26/02/2009
Desparate people take desparate measures!!
It was impossible to avoid this conflict,as BDR soldiers unleashed their desparity through this deadly bloodshed.Atrocities should be punished,so should be the corruption that brought this atrocities,armed force officers should take the blame for this mutiny,and restructe according to avoid such disaster again that left many ravaged

Dara Masur
United Kingdom
26/02/2009
Bangladesh BDR Mutity
The rebellion of the paramilitary unit called BDR has been building up for many years over neglect and the corrupt treatment on them by the Bangladesh regular army under whom they are assigned. The Daily Independent [Online] of Bangladesh reports today 26/02/09 that the regular army officers torture them and take a proportion of ration allocation and they (the army) engage in corrupt means of earning and consistently ignore the BDR’s request for improving their working conditions and pay.

Shamim Rumi
Bangladesh
26/02/2009
No rape in BDR HQ
sadaf khan reported wrong. no rape is happened in BDR HQ in Bangladesh. it is not possible.

Imran Ahmed
Bangladesh
26/02/2009
Mutiny reveals Bangladesh chaos
There was no rape by the BDR. Sadaf Khan is mistaken. BDR soldiers were forced to this. They petitioned their head who is military many times but were rejected to rpesent their miseries to the Prime Minister. One of them was shot by a military person in a meeting hall which provoked their rage. They have a very just cause. They put their lives everyday for securing Bangladesh while the military just give orders and take benefits away

Ahmmed
Bangladesh
26/02/2009
Is it democracy?
In a democratic country the army should act as supportive for the government.But in Bangladesh they are the one who are ruling the country from behind the scene. Almost every top positions we have the army people sitting there. Such a potential country like ours is just being manipulated by vested politicians and army people.

Raisul Afsar Mahmud
Bangladesh
26/02/2009
The Mutiny by BDR in Bangladesh
Mr. Sadaf Khan is not a Bangladeshi ? How could he report about reap ! There is no report of such till now. Dear all please do not let your people down in front of the world to become hero by giving misleading / false statement.

Abdul Hoque
United States
27/02/2009
Loss of lives, peace and tranquility
This is Allah’s wrath to a country, who is becoming champion to leave behind even all the developed countries in establishing a kingdom of Women. All the major ministries, and many high officials in BD are women, most of them without any skill, experience or reason.

Muhammad Ainul Huda
Bangladesh
27/02/2009
who is the real gainer?
What happened is really pathetic and alarming for a country like Bangladesh. It is too early to throw the blame game around. Having a armed force divided and less trusted on each other, will make the defense force even weaker. Eventually, a weaker border control by BDR and less self confidence of the combined armed force will make it easier for our enemies to destabilize Bangladesh. This will pave the way for outside force to enter B'desh in the name of "joint force". BE CAUTIOUS!!

khalil
Australia
27/02/2009
Bangladesh Unrest
The Govt. of Bangladesh is responsible for that , as they never take the status of BDR in serious way. and the corrupted army always lasting for power and money ........ who will take care of that ...

Babul Rahman
Bangladesh
28/02/2009
THE REVENGE?
One perspective could be that it was the Bangladesh Army who took power for nearly 2years and held Khalida, the former Prime Minister and Hasina the current Prime Minister on charges for corruption, inequality, fraud and so on. Now it was time for the Bangladesh Army to ‘Pay the Price’. With charges of corruption, inequality, fraud and so on from within e.g. BDR Mutineers, the Bangladesh Army has lost all its credibility. So is reputed a laughing stock. I bet the Army didn’t see that coming.

Mominul Hassan
Australia
28/02/2009
Who is on the back foot?
Please don't talk like silly and judge this extreme loss for Bangladesh with emotion only.It cannot be an incident happened just out of rage.Now it is obvious that it was well planned and third party arranged fuel in it.I am not denying unjust made to BDR but this sort of revange is not expected and excepted.Third party wants BDR to be free from Army.Now wants to send "Joint force".Be alart,we dont want to see our loved country like Srilanka and Nepal.?To shorten hands of army behind Govt.

JamesKalahan
Bangladesh
28/02/2009
A Bad Day
Last two days were bad day for our country. Soldiers in both BDR, Army , Police and other forces are deprived according to their views. It may possible that some of the army soldier may help those BDR to scape. The security on PM house has been increased because of what, I believe not for BDR may be for Army. Army may not be satisfied with the political solution of this problem. they may force PM to take some brutal action. In Bangladesh we have never seen fair trail for military people.

osman chowdhury
Australia
28/02/2009
The soldier of bdr do that kinds of brutaity which has no chance to pardone the brutal soldier.If bangladesh government pardone these inhuman soldier in future it is too easy to kill anyone for simple issse.

Abdul bari
Bangladesh
01/03/2009
BDR Mutiny
Army officers don't join army to go to BDR, they only follow govt order.This is a policy matter beyond their reach.UN mission for BDR yet army officers can't give that,ask govt and check out the the peacekeepers employment policy.There were all kinds of violations comitted at Pillkhana during that period,there are evidence,please don't be bias.Officers are not corrupt,their salary maintain in bank account please,try to know from banks the % of officers having over draw.it's game play by enemy

GS Chowdhury
Bangladesh
01/03/2009
No Conclusions Yet, Please!
We shouldn't rush to any premature concusion. What happened was not a mutiny but a massacre of some of the best officers of the Bangladesh Army. The surprising fact that is that this gruesome killing was carried out immediately after the new secular government of Bangladesh won a landslide in the elections and democracy was restored. Even after this unprecedented brutality, the military have remained calm and so far the government is in full control.

Maj Awal (Retd), BD Army
United States
02/03/2009
BDR Genocide
BDR Genocide is undoubtedly a brutal activity done by the BDR soldiers in the history of Bangladesh. From the core of my heart, I sincerely pray for all depart souls, who had been my beloved coworkers for a long time. The Govt must identify all related criminals and punish them.

Mukta Aktar
Bangladesh
02/03/2009
Real Culprits...
This may not be seen as Amin Ahmed. Its the only army for whom the country is standing as a soverign nation. Army persons are not politicians, They dont have any motive, they serve the nation. They dont hide in India or take bribe from Siemens. In all crisis army is called but why? All department have trained man. So are they ineffective? The country does not belong to M K Alamgir, Nurul kabir or the prince alone. Its our nation. Army saved the nation all the time. may Allah bless the murturiars

Syed Tareq Ahmed
Bangladesh
26/02/2009
Mutiny reveals Bangladesh chaos
This godforsaken country thrives on calamities, chaos, comical conduct of politicians and surely divine grace. A total lack of morality, fear of Allah and mad rush at self aggrandizement epitomes our so called ruling class without exceptions. Yet we the people who were once eulogized as ' what Bengal thinks today, India thinks tomorrow. What a shame.

kazi
Bangladesh
26/02/2009
u call killing officers justice????!!! r u kiddin?one of those officers wad my very very close friend who got married just 2months before..& what was his fault??An officers just came back from mission & joined on that day...what was his fault???

Prince
Bangladesh
26/02/2009
I want to say all of u that,we should control our emotions & think logically to find out the real cause.If army officers are taken away from BDR then who is going to be the gainer?Command channel of BDR will become weaker,border areas are going to be unrest,more over clash between two major forces are going to make the security system weaker.So the third party is going to get free entrance through the bordeer.Casualty of so many officers of Bangladesh is a severe threat for its soverienty.

Ridwan
Bangladesh
26/02/2009
Who should we blame???
The lion share of the blame should be on the top-most military officials who were involved in boiling the ranks of the BDR and was on the recieving end of the profits extracted through hard toils of the BDR jawans. On the other hand it was previous the goverments prerogative to solve the long standing problems of the law enforcements. If the current goverment doesnt take lesson from this incidence and keep politicing the military ranks, this types of situation will happen again.

Amin Rahman
United Kingdom
26/02/2009
Probably SADAF KHAN has got ARMY LINK!
SADAF KHAN came up with some imaginary facts. Every one in Bangladesh knows, ARMY is the most corrupt. So what happened today is just the reflection of the TRUTH. Bangladesh Government should do every thing to control army, may be stopping new recruitment, giving the old corrupt generals early retirements. God blass bangladesh.

Md.Niaj Imran
Bangladesh
27/02/2009
Totally unnecessary!killed their good image to civilians
When u have a knife u can use it for both legal and illegal tasks.BDR's arms were used like the 2nd one.When u have some demands u also may have some ways to earn it. As a good democratic country bangladesh's media is very strong.we have witnessed that media perform as if a shadow govt. of the previous popular army backed interrium govt. BDR soldiers can easily get the help of the media to spread their demands which could be the most efective way than killing their own brother's...

Fahad Akhand
Australia
27/02/2009
Bangladesh revolt
well, it was so ovious. I know it not a nice way but atleast from now on gov will look after their(BDR) rights. As a paramilitary force they always been neglected. it might looks weird ,but i do support this revolt abut not the killing of innocent peoples and army officers.

Ali mansoor
Australia
28/02/2009
after giving amnesty to all those BDR (heroes of Bangladesh) by our prime minister in front of 16 million people in our national TV. Now how come the army is arresting the BDR's and torturing and it was not mentioned on the speech of prime minister that those who were directly involved in the killing will be punished rather then amnesty was for all BRD's. this rage was not born in a day, it was the oppression of the army for a long time which led them no way but to become desperate.

Adv. Mohammad Mohiuddin
Bangladesh
28/02/2009
Extra-Judicial Investigation Is Required.
This occurence between BDR & Army has created a total insecurity throughout the country. The main reason 4 this occurence needs to be investigated properly & impartially by a Justice of Appellate Division of Supreme Court by leaving all the bad traditions that we've created in the recent past. What was the main reason of starting open fire at the senior most officers & what ignited the BDR soldiers needed to be known.

ayesha
Australia
01/03/2009
BDR Mutiny
Taking everything into account my conclusion is that this is not just over pay this was well planned and Pakistan, Jamaat i Islam are very well behind this. They did order this and those who killed were under them. It is sad to see how these idiots are denying their country to be strong and powerful at this most critical time. Shame on Bangladeshis who are part of Jamaat i islam they have ruined Bangladesh and they DO NOT REPRESENT ISLAM they abuse Islam for their own Political goals!!!

patriotBD
Bangladesh
01/03/2009
BDR killing
It is some politicians who let the atrocities take place. I think top ranking military officers and some other traitors have supported or by their inactive role made the killing easier. Only speedy trial by special tribunal can solve the problem faster.

Iqbal
United Kingdom
02/03/2009
MUTINY
This is a just a small eruption, a boil if you will. The real desease is overpopulation. Fortunately West Bengal is being fed by the Indian Central Government (for decades) but the East Bengal (despite being the worlds biggest basket case) has no one but the World Food Program !! The truth has to be told and only a warner from amongst themselves will firmly grasp the problem (like the Chinese Government has done) and take steps before a gigantic calamity occurs.

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article