UPDATED ON:
Tuesday, January 27, 2009
15:40 Mecca time, 12:40 GMT
OPINION: SOMALIA
UN and US should restore Somalia

Somalia's transitional government has failed to bring stability to the Horn of Africa nation [EPA]

The election and inauguration of Barack Obama as US president restores hope for millions of Muslims and Africans throughout the world.

With this new leadership, many Africans expect the US to adopt policies that will help to resolve deadly conflicts and address the HIV/Aids epidemic.

Many more, in the Third and Muslim World, hope the Obama administration will, at least, end the destructive foreign policies of past US administrations.

Somalis, like many around the globe, are hoping for a renewed spirit of internationalism in Obama's foreign policy.

They believe an Obama administration will have the opportunity to help address the complex external and domestic issues in this strategic Horn of Africa nation.

Statelessness

According to human rights organisations, Washington's previous policies toward Somalia have contributed to the suffering of millions of civilians - thousands of people have been killed and more than one million people displaced.

Your Views

How can stability be brought to Somalia?

Send us your views

In order for the Obama administration to successfully address the insecurity and humanitarian challenges in Somalia, it would have to roll back statelessness in the country and support a viable, comprehensive central government.

The world community must understand that the root cause of maritime piracy, which has garnered much media attention in recent months, and other security problems is the lack of law and order exercised by a central authority in Mogadishu.

Piracy off the coast of Somalia has been a persistent problem for the last five years but it had not garnered the media attention it recently received until a Saudi Arabian supertanker, the Sirius Star, was hijacked on November 18.

Since then, Efthimios Mitropoulos, the secretary-general of the International Maritime Organisation, has appealed to the UN Security Council to help address the problem.

An international conference on this issue was recently convened in Nairobi, Kenya in which many governments and organisations vowed to act to end the maritime threat.

Misdiagnosis

Despite their good intentions, however, many of those voices calling for action have misdiagnosed the problem.

Their solutions have been more of the same old and failed policy prescriptions: send more ships to the Somali coast, ask the Indian government to protect ships and pass more UN resolutions.

When some form of functioning local authority emerged in southern Somalia in 2006, piracy was all but eradicated.

In Somalia, there exists an inverse relationship between authority (or the lack thereof) within the country and an increase in piracy off its shores.

Therefore, if the US and the international community was to help establish a legitimate and functioning state in Somalia this could, in fact, prove to be a cheaper and more effective solution to the piracy problem than some of the alternative suggestions.

It would also greatly reduce the suffering of the Somali people.

End Ethiopian meddling

Much of Somalia is controlled by armed opposition groups  [EPA]
Ethiopia's occupation has also exacerbated the security situation in Somalia.

Now that Ethiopian troops have withdrawn from most Somali territory it is time that the international community pressure Addis Ababa to end its meddling in its neighbour's internal affairs.

The Ethiopian government should be pressured into stopping its attacks on Somalia and ending its support for notorious proxy warlords.

Interestingly, the Ethiopian government is playing its old games with the international community and over the lives of the millions of displaced Somalis.

Despite its official rhetoric that it would withdraw its troops from the country, Ethiopian forces are occupying new regions and arming notorious warlords under false religious names - Gedo, Bakool, Galgaduud and Bay regions illustrate this point.

Since 2006, many Somalis, whether or not they subscribe to the ideologies of the Islamic Courts Union believe that Ethiopia is largely responsible for the perpetuation of the statelessness in the country.

With the Ethiopian factor removed, most of the home-grown factions will be forced to pursue peaceful means to end their differences and hostilities.

Transitional authority and institutions

The UN has rightfully supported the creation of a transitional government and parliament; however, these processes must be administered very delicately.

The UN-led process has to be as inclusive as possible - most, if not all, Somali actors have to identify and own the results.

The current UN approach focuses on the two main actors (the transitional government and the Alliance of Re-liberation of Somalia), which threatens to alienate other players.

For example, business community leaders, religious scholars, members of the Somali diaspora, civil society, and women's groups must also be permitted to participate in the political rehabilitation process.

While including more stakeholders is necessary, designing context-appropriate political institutions that can function is even more important.

The often-prescribed semi-parliamentary system, the federal model and the proposed 550-member parliament have to be carefully considered.

One approach may include a presidential system modeled after the mechanism used in Somaliland and Puntland.

A decentralised unitary model of governance, and dividing the 550-member parliament into a bicameral system (senate and house of representatives) would be one way to rectify these problems.

Starvation

Humanitarian agencies are reporting that millions of Somalis are on the verge of starvation because of the protracted conflict and soaring food prices across the world.

While solving the political and security problems that led to the current situation is necessary, an immediate humanitarian rescue effort is needed.

In particular, the international community must help the displaced return to their homes.

Somalia's strategic value to world security and the world economy cannot be overstated; the UN - supported by the Obama administration - must intervene quickly. Piracy in the high seas is just one symptom of a large and complex problem.

A legitimate and functioning state that fulfils its international and national obligations is the answer to the insecurity problems.

With wise policy prescriptions, the use of home-grown values and forces, and the sustained support of the international community, legitimate authority can be restored. 

Afyare Abdi Elmi is a Somali-Canadian professor of political science at the University of Alberta in Canada.

The views expressed by the author are not necessarily those of Al Jazeera English

 Source: Al Jazeera
 
Topics in this article
Country

Organisation

Feedback Number of comments : 17
 
Tony
Afghanistan
28/01/2009
We should no longer be the WORLD Police
Maybe it's because I read this article on the Al Jazeera English site, but why is it that the only Country mentioned in this article is the US in terms of helping out Somalia? The US can no longer afford to be the world's police, no. 1 because we have too many issues domestically that we need to focus on, no. 2 because we always get blamed for being an imperliastic nation. I agree in the past the US is guilty of no. 2, but we can no longer be everyone's security blanket.

Kume
United States
28/01/2009
I agree
I'm Ethiopian-American, so maybe my view may be a bit skewed. I think Somalia has more or less got into this by itself. There are deep rooted problems in Somali culture and political organization that have led to this lawlessness. I am not a fan of the current ( or any historical) Ethiopian government. Dan brings up a good point. Where is the leadership in the Muslim World on this issue? There is none, just complaints.

Kume
United States
28/01/2009
Arab leadership
Since Somalia is/was a member of the Arab League where have they been for the past 20 years? Why do African soldiers have to risk their lives to keep the peace in a country that doesn't identify itself as African? I'm Oromo and I love Somalis, but this is the truth. Furthermore, Ethiopia does not meddle in Somali affairs anymore than successive Somali governments have supported separatists in the Ogaden. This includes the Islamic Courts Government of 2006.

Somali-American
United States
28/01/2009
Somalia Today
So USA Supported the TFG the Transition government Because Of The Oil Deal of Northern Parts of Somalia conoco philips and exxon mobile Both Jumped in to pay for the cost...That's why USA WAS Paying 600$ for every Ethiopian soldier who fought in Somalia for so called Fighting against Terrorist..Ethiopia today is trying to Drill Digging for Oil in the Ogden Part of Ethiopian which is originally Somalian land

Umar
Nigeria
28/01/2009
To Hell with either America or UN on Somalia
The so-called UN and US were the greatest travails of the present state of Somalia. So neither the Somalis nor the Muslim World need them. Allaah will take care of them against all odds.

Mr. Mo
Afghanistan
28/01/2009
UN and US should restore Somalia
This situation can only be solved by Somalis. Everyone tried and failed miserably. Good luck my brothers and sisters, and you should only count on God only.

Average American
United States
28/01/2009
been there done that
The UN and US has already tried this once and the people of Somali murdered the very people trying to help them. I don't think any country should try and help Somaila unless the people of somila vote and a vast majority favor help from outside Somila. Otherwise it will be another blood bath.

Dan
United States
27/01/2009
I have a better idea
I have a better idea. Instead of the Muslim world offering to hold the US's coat while we once again sacrifice the lives of our young men and women while all the while having the same Muslim world accuse of us Colonialism, how about the Muslim world put aside their own ancient tribal hatreds and work together to help Somaila yourselves? Instead of wasting billions on enriching your ruling monarchies pockets, how about using some of your enormous oil wealth to help your own brothers and sister.

Hassan Aden
United States
28/01/2009
Somalia Will Prevail Over all Odds
Somalia needs neither the US help nor the UN. All it needs is to be left alone. Then, it can handle the donkeys thinking to be horses because they (the donkeys) ate the leftovers of the horses.

Somali-American
United States
28/01/2009
Somalia Today...
Somalia is Nation of illiterates Domestically. And The reason they live for is Money like Anyone else in this Modern World(Westernized world) some make money by selling the land to be used for dumping Toxics for the Industrial Governments mostly from Europe and Asia.. Others used the land to Grow opium and coca leaves and traffic it to the west of Africa..So Everyone is Money Hungry and All the Governments in the world now days besides few are looking for their own interests what's in it for me.

Somali-American
United States
28/01/2009
Somalia Today
And who are the Islamic world you guys are talking about ..Arabs/Islamic LEADERS Do Run by the American/Israel/Some EU Countries order or they are EXCESS OF EVIL like Syria/Iran/Pakistan.. Westerns Governments are smart enough they did Grow there own people in those governments who do followed them by the book. and Somalians who are doing there down low deals with the westernize world by selling there own lands and own people are paid by who..Western Governments and who ever have interests,,,

Ali
Somalia
28/01/2009
Well, What Somalia needs is not US, UN, African Union, European Union help. What we need is to be left alone. The UN has been stealing funds appropriated for Somalia. The US has toppled our government Islamic Courts Union has formed. The African Union and Arabs are corrupted and dictators. We Somalis know what we want and we are capable of forming our own government if the interference stops.

liban
Great Britain (UK)
28/01/2009
change will come if......
If America and Ethiopia keep there dirty fingers out of Somalia everything will be solved . But if they keep getting involved they will get defeated by the resistance groups who control most of the southern parts of the country al-shabab.

JC
Afghanistan
29/01/2009
Left alone?
"All it needs is to be left alone." Yes, let the Somalis commit piracy in peace.

Mahamed
Somalia
01/02/2009
Who is to blame
I think people need to realise that ordenary somali never asked for any outside help. The six of peace in Somalia was the best time people had, where hope were restored, hearts filled with ambition and peopled dared to dream. The US and the UN have caused more damage to civillians than good in all the country they supposedly came to help, liberate (Somalia, Irag, Vietnam to name a few) as for the Arab leaders they are corrupt and the US supports them, which makes them complicit.

Dave
Afghanistan
28/01/2009
helping Somalia
Why should we help Somalia? You think because we have a black president that the USA should help Somalia? Personally, I believe that Somalia is beyond our help. Any effort to do so would be a waste of time and resources.

Zakariye
Denmark
03/02/2009
Somalia Need Allah
peace to all you, i´m somali and i was born in mugadisho Somalia, we somalies are peace loving people. no rasict, off course there are black ships beyong us selv, it´s like when i heard this, when Puntland has agread to allow some oil compnies. how and why. when other places are in fire. i'm upset with those oil compnies to hell with them Amiin. i wouldn´t do that to others. what we right know do each other is our issue. we are not killing your people.

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article
Aljazeera.net/english 2003 - 2010 ©
Designed & Developed by Aljazeera IT