UPDATED ON:
Monday, July 21, 2008
23:18 Mecca time, 20:18 GMT
 
Focus 60 Years of Division
The Nakba in al-Ramla
By Sandy Tolan

 

An elderly Palestinian woman remembers the Nakba [GALLO/GETTY]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The Nakba in al-Ramla is the second part of Sandy Tolan's account of the fall of an Arab town in July 1948 and the expulsion of its residents. Click here to read the first part.

Firdaws Taji Khairi will always remember the voices of Israeli soldiers shouting through loudspeakers outside her home in al-Ramla, as the Nakba unfolded right before her.

"Yallah Abdullah!" they cried as they pounded on people's doors with the butts of their rifles. "Go to King Abdullah! Go to Ramallah!"

It was a scorching day on the coastal plain of Palestine in mid-July 1948. A couple of days earlier, the town had surrendered to Israeli forces after they stormed the nearby city of Lydda.

Moshe Dayan led the attack on Lydda [GALLO/GETTY]
Word had arrived in the al-Ramla shelters: After a lightning blitz on Lydda, led by Lieutenant-Colonel Moshe Dayan, which left dozens of Palestinians dead, Israeli troops had gunned down dozens more in Lydda's Dahmash mosque.

Hoping to avoid a similar catastrophe, al-Ramla's "notables" had signed the surrender, believing they would be allowed to stay in their homes in the city, now occupied by the Jewish army.

Instead, Firdaws, 16-years old, could hear the soldiers announcing the arrival of buses to take residents of al-Ramla to the front lines of the Arab Legion.

No matter what the terms of surrender, or what Sheikh Mustafa Khairi, the town patriarch, had tried to negotiate, tens of thousands of residents of al-Ramla and Lydda were being forced to leave their homes.

Furnace of dispossession

The expulsions from al-Ramla and Lydda, 60 years ago this week, form one of the most significant and brutal chapters in the Palestinian Nakba of 1948.

The stories of eviction at gunpoint, and of the forced march that followed, echo six decades later from across the Palestinian diaspora: from the refugee camps near Ramallah, to the white stone homes of Amman, to living rooms in Kuwait, London, Boston or San Francisco.  

The recollections of those who marched through the heat of mid-July, coupled with intelligence dispatches and the archived documents from Israeli and Arab commanders of the day, create an indisputable record of forced expulsions that runs counter to the comfortable narrative that Israelis and Americans have understood about the 1948 war: That the 750,000 Arab civilians displaced in the war somehow left their homes voluntarily; or that, in the vernacular of an Israeli children's textbook, the Arabs "preferred to leave".

It is in this chapter of the Nakba that one can understand both the power of the Palestinian memory, and how the burning wish to return, by any means necessary, was forged in a furnace of dispossession.

The morning of July 14 was blazing hot. It was the seventh day of Ramadan. Thousands of people had already been expelled from al-Ramla.

Firdaws and her extended family sat waiting at al-Ramla's bus terminal. There were perhaps 35 in all, the Khairis and their relatives, the Tajis. Sheikh Khairi was among them.

They carried suitcases and bundles of clothes; some had gold strapped to their bodies. Firdaws had packed her Girl Guide uniform (akin to that of the Girl Scouts) and brought along her knife and her whistle.

At home, the family had left behind nearly all of its treasured possessions: furniture, rugs, books, family pictures, cups and saucers, etched crystal drinking goblets; sweet dried chickpeas, sugared almonds on silver trays, grape leaves in brine; silk and linen, fezzes and gallabiyas, balloon pants and sashes and belts; amber, coral, indigo, and silver bracelets with Ottoman coins; fields of okra and wild peas; orchards of lemons, apricots, and olives. The families would be back soon to tend to them all; of that they were certain.

The bus came and the family boarded it, rolling towards the front lines at Latrun.

'Drive them out!'

Some Israeli officials had been pressing military commanders to suspend the expulsions. 

Two days earlier, on the afternoon of July 12, Bechor Shalom Shitrit, the Israeli minister of minority affairs, had arrived at a junction of roads between al-Ramla and Lydda, where he was greeted by the sight of throngs of people walking east. He was outraged. As the man responsible for Arabs in the new Israeli state, he protested against the expulsions in a conversation with the foreign minister, Moshe Sharett.  

David Ben-Gurion decided to expel al-Ramla's civilian population [GALLO/GETTY]
Shitrit, however, did not realise that the decision to expel had already been made, at a meeting between David Ben-Gurion, the prime minister, Lieutenant-Colonel Yitzhak Rabin and Yigal Allon, commander of the Israeli military's Operation Dani.

Rabin, the future prime minister, would recall in his memoirs that Ben-Gurion, when asked what they should do with the civilian population of al-Ramla and Lydda, "waved his hand in a gesture which said, 'Drive them out!'"

Shitrit also could not have known that Allon had already considered the military advantages of expulsion.

Driving out the citizens of al-Ramla and Lydda, Allon believed, would alleviate the pressure from an armed and hostile population. It would clog the roads towards the Arab Legion front, seriously hampering any effort to retake the towns. And the sudden arrival of thousands of destitute refugees in the West Bank and Transjordan would place a great financial burden on King Abdullah of Transjordan.

Orders to expel the residents of al-Ramla and Lydda were given in the early afternoon of July 12. The Lydda order, stating: "The inhabitants of Lydda must be expelled quickly without attention to age," was given at 1.30pm by Rabin.

Marched towards exile 

The Lydda residents, prodded forward by soldiers who fired into the air behind them, received the harshest treatment.

Numerous eyewitness accounts, corroborated by Israeli official Aharon Cohen in a July 1948 cabinet meeting, describe Lydda residents being forced to surrender their gold jewellery and other valuable possessions before being marched towards exile. 
   
"Regrettably, our forces have committed criminal acts that may stain the Zionist movement's good name," Shitrit would say later. "The finest of us have given a bad example to the masses."

When the bus carrying Firdaws and her family arrived at the front lines at Latrun, they were ordered off and told to march north, towards Salbit. It was only four kilometres – people from Lydda had to walk much further – but by now it was 100C. There was no shade and no road, just a steep rise across cactus and Christ's thorn.

Firdaws looked up across the hard-baked earth as knots of people moved slowly along in the waves of heat.

Today, from her exile in Ramallah, she remembers watching a pregnant woman stumbling through the hills. There, her water broke, and she gave birth on the hot ground.

Thirst gripped everyone's mind as white crusts formed around their mouths. They were always looking for shade and water. They crossed fields of corn, where they plucked ripe ears and sucked the moisture out of the kernels. Firdaws saw a boy peeing into a can and then watched his grandmother drink from it.

Meandering journey

By late afternoon, they still had not reached Salbit, and some feared they had become lost. Years later, people would recall that their confused, meandering journey over rocky terrain would turn out to be much longer than four kilometres.

Related Articles

Tracing Gaza's Chaos to 1948

The Nakba: Catalyst for pan-Arabism

Opinion: Arabism's greatest loss

Realising the Zionist dream

Why the Arabs were defeated

Profile: King Abdullah I of Jordan

Habash: The bearer of the dream

The fall of an Arab town in 1948

The Khairis and the Tajis began to shed their belongings. Their suitcases had been discarded long ago.

After a time people found a well, and rejoiced, but then learned to their horror that the rope was broken. Women removed their dresses, lowered them into the stagnant water, and lifted them back up, placing the fabric to their children's lips so they could suck on the wet cloth.

An estimated 30,000 people from al-Ramla and Lydda staggered through the hills that day; the total number of people expelled from both towns exceeded 50,000. 

One of them was Khalil al-Wazir of al-Ramla, better known as Abu Jihad, who, 17 years later, would join forces with Yassir Arafat as Fatah launched the first of many guerilla attacks on Israeli soil - efforts to avenge the dispossession and fight for the right of return for Palestinians.

Another was Dr George Habash of Lydda, a medical student in 1948 whose sister had been killed by Israelis, and who would later form the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, well known in the 1970s for its embrace of "armed struggle," including many airline hijackings and attacks on Israeli civilians - actions designed, Habash would say, to deprive Israelis of any sense of "reassurance and security".

City of refugees

As the Palestinians trekked through the hills, commanders on both sides began receiving cables.

John Bagot Glubb, the British commander of the Arab Legion, knew it was "a blazing day in the coastal plains, the temperature about a 100C in the shade". He knew that the refugees were crossing "stony fallow covered with thorn bushes" and that, in the end, "nobody will ever know how many children died".

On July 15, before the march from al-Ramla and Lydda was over, Ben-Gurion wrote in his diary: "The Arab Legion has wired that there are 30,000 refugees moving along the road between Lydda and Ramla, who are infuriated with the Legion. They're demanding bread. They should be taken across the Jordan river" - into Abdullah's kingdom and away from the new state of Israel.

In the evening, Firdaws and her family came to a grove of fig trees in the village of Salbit. Hundreds of other refugee families were gathered in the orchards. Someone brought water. Firdaws tried to rest.

The next morning, trucks from the Arab Legion took the family to Ramallah. They reached the crest of a hill just west of the city. Below them lay a vast bowl: the valley of Ramallah. The city had long been a Christian hill town and cool summer haven for Arabs from the Levant to the Gulf.

Now Ramallah had been transformed into a city of refugees. Stunned and humiliated, they milled about, looking for food, and determined, from that moment, to return home.

Sandy Tolan is the author of The Lemon Tree: An Arab, A Jew, and the Heart of the Middle East, from which this account is drawn. He is associate professor of journalism at the Annenberg School for Communication, University of Southern California.

 Source: Al Jazeera
 
Feedback Number of comments : 31
 
Isa
United States
20/07/2008
the Nakba in al-Ramla
To David Doub: When Fox news gives an extensive series of articles on what the Zionist Jews did in Palestine, CAN YOU PLEASE ADVISE ME. Actually any major USA network that has a special on television will do also.

george
Canada
21/07/2008
the nakba
it is my understanding that the Arabs tried to push the settlers back into the ocean and that palestinians had sold properties to the Jews. It is my understanding that the Arabs started the war. Evil begets evil.It is all very sad. According to the jews and the Holy Book Israel is the promised land

Alex
United States
21/07/2008
Nakba
Jews were never expelled from any Arab countries from their homes. However it is a known fact that Jews were always moving from one prosperous country to another. So the question is not about expulsion of one community or the other but it is about the principle.

Shlomo Nahman
United States
21/07/2008
Jews from Arab Countries
To David Doub: Jews from Arab countries were not forced from their homes they were seduced by Zionists to immigrate to Palestine. Arab leaders begged them to stay home (in Arab countries) but Zionists coerced them to immigrate to Palestine to what is called "God's promised land". The same is done now to Ethiopian Jews and Sudanese Jews. Many prefered to stay as we see in North African Arab countries, in Iraq, and even in Iran, where we have the 2nd largest Jewish community in the Middle East.

Chris
Poland
21/07/2008
Isa, so it seems that you are comfortable with equating Al Jazeera with FOX.What about not looking at the others ? Actually there was an article about the expulsion of Jews in Al Jazeera a couple of months ago. It was written such that 'perhaps maybe in certain aspects' something like this might have happen to some individuals. Very dishonest approach to the issue...

Canadian/Middle Eastern Jew
Canada
21/07/2008
Jews from Arab countries
To those who say that no Jews were expelled - you are right, they "preferred to leave" just like the Arabs in Palestine did. In many cases they felt like if they did not leave, their lives would be in danger. Just ask my grandmother, who was driven from Egypt in the early 1950s.

carnation
United States
21/07/2008
Alex, you claimed that "Jews were never expelled from any Arab countries from their homes." But in 1956, the Egyptian government used the Sinai Campaign as a pretext for expelling almost 25,000 Egyptian Jews and confiscating their property. Approximately 1,000 more Jews were sent to prisons and detention camps. How do you explain that away?

Mohannad El-Khairy
United Arab Emirates
22/07/2008
Arab Jews
To compare the Arab Jews that were forced to leave their homes in Arab countries with the Palestinian refugee issue is unbalanced. Israel used a systematic policy to ethnically cleanse all native Palestinians from the lands of 1948, and right now a military occupation exists in the lands of 1967 for precisely the same aim. Death, destruction, dispossession, and occupation are some of the daily realities every Palestinian endures. Recognizing the context we're in is crucial.....

Mohannad El-Khairy
United Arab Emirates
23/07/2008
Answers
How are these 1,144,000 Palestinians living? In what kind of conditions? Do they have rights? And if so can they fully exercise them? Do Palestinians have "19%" or even equal representation in the Israeli political system or “democracy”, or are Israeli ministers today still calling for their mass expulsion. Israel attempts to make daily life continuously unbearable for Palestinians of '48. That to me is a form of Ethnic Cleansing, because that is Israel's intention.

Mazen El-Khairy
Canada
25/07/2008
Arab Jews
According to Israeli historian Ilan Pappe Arab Jews left their Arab countries when they were promised a better life in Israel by the Jewish Agency. Iraq was the only country that deported them but that was under pressure from the great powers of the day.

Warner Anderson
United States
27/07/2008
Nakba
The history is useful because, frankly, it is the memories that are more important than not the facts. The exchange of comments on this article shows the difficulty in the Middle East: as soon as you complain about what your cousin did yesterday, your cousin replies with a complaint about what you did to him the day before that justifies it.

Ronnie
Canada
27/07/2008
carnation, It is easy to say for you that the land does not belong to Palestine since you are living on a land that is not belong to you. That land belongs to native Indians. I feel sad for the people does not matter Muslims or Jews or other

David Doub
Canada
20/07/2008
Nakba
Eagerly awaiting a series of articles on Jews forced from their homes in Arab countries. PLEASE ADVISE WHEN IT WILL BE PUBLISHED.

Michael Steiner
United States
21/07/2008
To earlier comment
Well David, unfortunately the story of Jews being expelled from Arab countries can't be published since it did not happen. During the inquisition when Europe was being purged of Jews, it was the Muslim kingdoms that gave them refuge. Jewish communities thrive in Muslim countries (even now) and they later migrated to Israel to join the zionist entity. Perhaps the Muslims ought to have had a leader like Ben Gurion in the past, which would have then solved the Jewish question permanently.

carnation
United States
21/07/2008
"That the 750,000 Arab civilians displaced in the war somehow left their homes voluntarily or that, in the vernacular of an Israeli children's textbook, the Arabs 'preferred to leave'." That's what Jamal Hussein told the UN Security Council: "The Arabs did not want to submit to a truce. They rather preferred to abandon their homes, their belongings and everything they possessed in the world and leave the town. This is in fact what they did."

jon
Afghanistan
21/07/2008
1948
When you discuss 1948 there is no mention of the fact that the Arabs began the war and attacked the Jews after the UN partition plan went into effect. Yes there were Palestinians killed. So to were Jews killed. Death begets death. Peace is a process. Al-Jazeera may choose to be part of that process. I guess we'll have to see.

Alpha Prime
Canada
21/07/2008
History, Truth, and Justice.
I find the Al Jazeera coverage of the Nakba extremely useful. As an English speaking Arab of Egyptian origin, I did not know these historical facts until I was in university attending a course by a reknowned (Jewish) professor. Its if the GREATEST importance that Al Jaz. continue to present these facts in English for the Arab Diaspora. For in this Diaspora lies the truest and most reasonable hope for change. The history of the Holocaust is everywhere, I want to see flicks about the Nakba.

Bagbane
United States
21/07/2008
The Nakba
When the United States forces a native people off their lands and into reservations, it is called racism. When Isreal does it, it's God's will.

carnation
United States
21/07/2008
In March 1948, Ismayil Safwat admitted: "The Jews haven't attacked any Arab village, unless attacked first." Don't try to rewrite history now. There are too many contemporaneous sources which will make you look foolish.

Mohannad El-Khairy
United Arab Emirates
22/07/2008
Arab Jews (2)
....Palestinians living abroad can never return to their homelands, nor did they receive any compensation for all their losses. Both are due to ethnocentric Israeli policies that will be too long to list right now. In fact, why is it that until this day Jews are being compensated for Nazi war crimes some 60+ years ago? We're talking about something that Israel is conducting right now, as we speak..

Mohannad El-Khairy
United Arab Emirates
22/07/2008
Arab Jews (3)
If your family living in the US, Canada, Australia, Israel wants to return to their origins in Egypt, I would fully support their cause. For that is an injustice, and injustices have to be addressed. Yet there still exists an unjust, illegal and brutal Occupation, now in it's "new and improved" version of an Apartheid Wall. A Wall that again attempts to further expulse the native Palestinians by making life totally unbearable for them.

Mohannad El-Khairy
United Arab Emirates
22/07/2008
Arab Jews (4)
Finally, there is a higher moral ground on the Arab side as well. See the following article on the Jews of Arabia: http://blogs.zawya.com/sultan/080428223209/ The bottom line is this: Jews, Christians, and Muslims generally co-existed peacefully in Palestine specifically and the Middle East generally. It is the violent & illegal establishment of the state of Israel that managed to turn coexistence into pain, fear, anger, and (unfortunately), hate. It's a situation of Oppressor vs. Oppressed.

carnation
United States
22/07/2008
"Israel used a systematic policy to ethnically cleanse all native Palestinians from the lands of 1948," In 2006, the Arab population of Israel was 1,144,000, representing over 19% of the Israeli population. If Israel ethnically cleansed all native Palestinians in 1948, where did all those Arabs come from?

carnation
United States
23/07/2008
"The bottom line is this: Jews, Christians, and Muslims generally co-existed peacefully in Palestine specifically and the Middle East generally. " On August 23-24, 1929 - Arabs murdered 67 Jews in Hebron. There were also multiple cases of rape and torture. I can list attacks in Safed, Tel Aviv, Motza and Kfar Uriyah. That's just in 1929 and in a limited area. I can list more, but I think you get the point. Is that your idea of peaceful co-existence?

christian
United States
23/07/2008
nakba
Hey Carnation, As long as your stating the numbers, why don't you state how many Palestinians have been sloughtered compared to how many Israelis. There has always been far more Palestinian murdered by Israelis. There was a relativley peacful coexistance in Palestine between the two groups, if you compare it to the peace today in Israel. Why has Israel been fighting with all of it's neighboring countries for it's entire existance? Maybe you should experience what a Palestinian does regularly.

Mohannad El-Khairy
United Arab Emirates
23/07/2008
Answer 2
Yes they generally co-existed peacefully. Actually, one of El-Khairy/El-Tagi family doctors was Jewish (Dr. Ledvak if I recall from my father's stories). The 1929 Hebron massacres were reactionary. People were hearing stories of the Haganah terrorist group's murderous actions and reacted. It was wrong. 1, 2, 3, 10 wrongs on either side don’t make a right. So are you prepared to denounce Israeli War Crimes occuring right now?

Tareq
United Kingdom
23/07/2008
Carnation
Carnation: there is a lot of hate and mistrust between arabs and jews since the beginning of the 1900's. but please, read ur history and u will find out that anti-semitism was always a european/christian phenomenon. from the spanish inquisition, to the rise of fascism to the polgroms in russia. the jews under muslim rule is spain had great coexistence together. then the jews fled to north africa, other arab and palestine in 1492 to seek safe haven. under muslim rule in palestinian jews had

Tareq
United Kingdom
23/07/2008
Carnation 2
..palestinian jews, muslims and christians could practise their religion for complete harmony for 14 centuries except for during the crusades when jews, muslims and "eastern christians" where massacred. hostilities between arabs and jews only started after the european/zionist project commence in palestine in 1897. Do not claim that arabs wanted to push us into the sea from day one. If u read ur early zionist quotes they clearly state that they wanted to establish an exclusive jewish state!

Harley
New Zealand (Aotearoa)
24/07/2008
It's funny what people care about. The holocaust draws so much attention. Is it because they are Jewish? I don't understand didn't like 30 million russians die? Does slav mean non human? And if we are giving things back why not give france to the visigoths? Im confused. I can understand why they gave Israel over after the war but why do they allow Israel to keep taking more and more?

Bintu Saffini
New Zealand (Aotearoa)
27/07/2008
when will this end
when will this end? Why would the world just close their eyes? When will US citizens see a strong leader tht will do something for the sake of his country

Warner Anderson
United States
27/07/2008
Nakba
....But, even if the Israelis stop treating the Palestinians poorly, will the Palestinians start treating each other well? One can only hope.

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article