UPDATED ON:
Friday, August 22, 2008
10:18 Mecca time, 07:18 GMT
 
Focus BEIJING 08
Paying the price of protest

Wu, left, and Wang say the government has broken its promises

With gleaming venues like the Water Cube and the Bird's Nest stadium, the Beijing Olympics were intended to portray the modern, progressive face of China in 2008.

But in a grimy, rubbish-strewn backstreet on the other side of the Chinese capital – far from the carefully manicured Olympic green - 79-year-old Wu Dian Yuan, and her partially deaf 77-year-old neighbour, Wang Xiu Ying, have a different story to tell.

Forced out of the homes they were born and raised in to make way for luxury apartments, they have fought for six years to have their claims for compensation heard.

Sentencing papers say Wu and Wang had 'disturbed the normal social order'
Now, after applying to protest their case in one of the specially designated Olympic protest zones, they were presented earlier this week with papers sentencing them both to a year-long term of re-education through labour.

"The government told us we had the right to protest," said Wang. "Now they've broken that promise."

It was the latest in what the two women say were at least 16 different protests aimed at getting someone - anyone - in government to listen to their grievances.

On previous occasions they have tried to draw attention to their cause by unfurling banners in Tiananmen Square, and even tried to set off firecrackers outside the closely guarded Zhongnanhai compound that is home to China's political leaders.

The firecrackers failed to go off, but their efforts undoubtedly drew the attention of the authorities. Two years ago their power was cut off and they have had to rely ever since on oil-burning lamps.

Sentencing them both to a year in a labour camp, the official paperwork says Wu, who walks with a stick, and Wang, who is deaf and partially blind, had "seriously disturbed the normal social order".

'Not afraid'

The two women say the do not care about the jail sentence. "At out our age, we have nothing left to lose, we're not afraid of doing anything," says Wu.

"This whole thing is about the fact we've been deprived of our human rights. Even though I'm illiterate, I still know we should be entitled to our basic rights."

But a Chinese labour camp is a tough sentence for anyone, let alone someone approaching their 80th birthday. Under Chinese law they do not even have the right to appeal.

It is a far cry from the image of China the government is eager to portray to the outside world.

Last month, in what was presented by the International Olympic Committee as a significant concession, Chinese authorities said they would permit three official protest zones in parks across the city for use by demonstrators during the games.

Similar zones had been set up in previous host cities and many had doubted that China, with its strict approach to public security, would follow suit.

But as of Thursday, with just a few days for the games left to run, out of 77 protest applications filed not a single one had been formally approved.

The protest zones have stayed silent.

In a statement, Beijing’s public security bureau said the vast bulk of applications had been withdrawn because the relevant authorities had resolved the applicants' problems through "consultations".

For Wu and Wang, both of whom are obviously frail, the resolution to their case appears to have been to try to intimidate them into silence.

Human rights groups say the women's case proves that government pledges to allow protests during the Olympics were a sham.

Prime target

Government designated protest zones have stayed silent through the games
Wu and Wang's family homes used to lie several kilometres away from where they now live, on the eastern side of Beijing's Temple of Heaven park – a popular tourist spot in the centre of the city.

That popularity and China's booming economy has made the area a prime target for developers.

Two years after their homes were demolished, Wu says, her family of seven were eventually offered compensation totaling about $20,000 - a sum they rejected as insufficient.

That would have struggled to buy them just five square metres in the luxury condo that now stands where their homes once stood.

Wu and Wang's case is far from unusual. As we spoke to them in Wu’s leaky, sparsely furnished one-room home, a neighbour explained that most of the resident's in the area had similar stories to tell.

All had been forced from their homes with little or no compensation. None had had their complaints listened to.

Fake promises

Luxury flats now stand on the site of Wu and Wang's former homes
"In the whole history of China I’ve near heard of a government doing such ugly things to old people," says Wu.

"At first we were happy to hear the government was allowing protests during the games, but now we realise that promise was fake. I'm very, very angry."

As they wait to hear when their sentence will start, the two old women say they face round-the-clock surveillance from plain clothes police officers.

"Even when we go and have breakfast, they're still watching us," says Wu. "It’s a real pain."

But despite their anger, despite their sentence, and despite the government's failure to deliver on promises to allow public protest, Wu and Wang say they still believe Olympics is a good thing for China.

The games have brought great changes, says Wu, although she feels that none have applied to the people at the bottom of the heap like her and Wang.

"The cops offered to bring us a small television so we could watch the opening ceremony," she says. "But we turned them down because they cut our power off."

 Source: Al Jazeera
 
Feedback Number of comments : 11
 
ayub
Afghanistan
22/08/2008
The price of protest.
Nice try Joe Havely.In 2005 a father and son were arresred in alabany,NY US of A for wearing anti iraq war t-shirts and jailed for 2 days,in the so called free world and home of the free.Joe try and concentrate on the olympics and keep your nose out of the chinese affairs.In new Orleans,LA people are still trying to recover from the floods and the idiot bush was on vacation.In Sichuan earthquake the response time was 30mins and if i remember correctly hu jin tao arrrived as soon as he heard.

Mike
Afghanistan
22/08/2008
Paying the Price of Protest
ayub in Afghanistan: No matter what is or isn't happening anywhere else, this is a news worthy story. And if it's a matter of consistency, perhaps you should keep your nose out of the US's business and refrain from even reading these stories that you so ineptly summarize.

R West
United States
23/08/2008
Chavez ravine
It makes me think of Chavez Ravine here in Los Angeles and the clearing away of thousands to make room for a low-income housing project that failed and instead became Dodger Stadium.

richard columbare
United States
23/08/2008
justice
Hey Joe Haverly,here is how justice works in Charlotte County Florida. Someone makes a charge about you to the police they issue a warrant,then they jail you ,then they offer you a plea and tell you if you do'nt accept it and make the state take you to trial they will go for the maximum punishment which is four times the plea offer. And the judges and the prosecution all work together and are on a first name basis, and they think that's justice!

Ayub
Afghanistan
23/08/2008
price of protest.
Yonah.You may have a point.You are right you can't compare the US and China.But the chinese do not cover up their policies regarding human rights practices.The US deceives the general public and their citizens regarding all political matter.I never heard of a democratic society eavesdropping on their citizens,the communists do that.I myself was protesting the war and was arrested in LA,CA and jailed for two days,what do you say to that.

Linduh
United States
22/08/2008
Paying the Price of Protest
The Supreme Court in the US now allows the state[s] to confiscate(condemn) private property if the new private owners will pay more taxes than the evicted previous owners. Sounds the same as Wu and Wang's situation. People with nothing left to lose will be the ones to ultimately take back their rights and property.

Brandon
United States
22/08/2008
When a home owner fails to pay their property tax for multiple years, I think the limit is 3 years right now, the government seizes the property and will give it to anyone will to pay all the back taxes. When the government takes your property for their use, they are exercising their right of domestic sovereignty but they must give the homeowner fair market value for the property. Very different that Wu and Wan.

Yonah
United States
22/08/2008
The facts
Ayub, the men were not arrested for wearing t-shirts, but for protesting and tresspaing on private property. They were inside a mall, which is owned by a private owner, therefore it was not a public venue. The property owner reserves the right under law to now allow such things. When asked to leave by security, the men refused, and that is why they were removed. You can not compare the legal system in the US to that of China, even by hiding facts.

Sara Torres
United States
22/08/2008
Alas, the development problem is a problem in the US as well, I have a good many hard working friends who have been kicked out of their homes to make way for multi-million dollar condos, and this is in Seattle! What enrages me is that the Chinese government would force these elderly women in to labor camps! For doing exactly what they had been given permission to do. This sounds like an elaborate ruse to find and silence dissidents.

Dietrich Rehnert
China
23/08/2008
Paying the prize of protest
China should never have got the Olympics. My country (Germany) should never have got the Olympics in 1936

Selvin
United States
23/08/2008
Pathetic
China is going all out on their assault on poor people. This happen in the US also but not to the blatant extent that China has taken it. This just serves as more proof that all governments are shady, regardless of how America potrays other countries records ours is just as bad.

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article