UPDATED ON:
Friday, December 19, 2008
12:27 Mecca time, 09:27 GMT
FOCUS: HUMAN RIGHTS AND THE UN
Activists fight female circumcision

The Egyptian government says that circumcising young girls is illegal and inhumane [Bauomy]

Amal Mahmoud, 44, cringed as she recalled the ceremony which took place after her circumcision in a small town south of Cairo 32 years ago. 

"The whole family was gathered in celebration. Everybody was eating and the children were dancing to Egyptian music on full volume," Mahmoud told Al Jazeera.

"Suddenly, the wound [from the operation] tore open, and blood stains spread all over my white dress."

She tried to dance in step with her cousins but the pain was unbearable.

"I was 12 and in deep pain ... I collapsed."

Her circumcision had gone horribly wrong; instead of a clean, straight cut, the barber miscalculated and sliced off her clitoris with a shaky hand, causing the wound to break open constantly.

Condemned cultural ritual

Mahmoud is one of many Egyptian women who have undergone circumcision or female genital mutilation (FGM).

A common cultural ritual that some believe pre-dates Islam, it has been condemned by the Egyptian authorities but remains widely practised.

Muslim as well as Christian women are circumcised in Egypt but the rituals vary in each community. The most popular ritual is meant to ensure fertility after the girl gets married.

"When a girl gets circumcised they take the clitoris, powder it with sugar and attach it to the upper arm with a thread," says Mahmoud.

"They say the girl has to be 'sweet' when she gets married. In our culture that means the girl will be able to have a lot of children."

Most families wait until the summer to have their daughters circumcised so that the girls have ample time to heal before school starts in the fall.

After having the clitoris tied to the arm for a week, the family performs another ritual by throwing the dried remnants into the Nile.

Not religious

Amel Fahmy, the technical officer at the World Health Organisation (WHO) department of reproductive health and research and an expert on FGM at the UN Population Fund (UNFPA), said: "The procedure isn't confined to religious boundaries but has deeper cultural roots."

Fahmy says many Egyptians believe that in addition to the perceived hygienic benefits, a circumcised genital area is more aesthetically pleasing and contributes to the overall beauty of the woman.

It also is a rite of passage for young girls into womanhood.

"These rituals are hard to track back and they are definitely not Islamic, but there are also no records of similar ancient Egyptian rituals. I think, somehow through time, they just manifested in the Egyptian culture. Nowhere else that I know of, where FGM is practiced, do they perform these rituals," Fahmy said.

Awareness campaigns

According to the UN, Egypt, Guinea and Mali are ranked as having the highest FGM prevalence rates in Africa.

A 1996 demographic and health survey showed that 97 per cent of Egyptian women between the ages of 15 and 49 have been circumcised.

According to 2005 data published by the WHO, some 94 per cent of married Egyptian women were found to have been circumcised between the ages of 9 and 18.

In the past decade, the Egyptian government, in collaboration with the UN Development Programme (UNDP), and the National Council for Childhood and Motherhood (NCCM), has mounted successive - and aggressive - campaigns to raise awareness of the inhumane and illicit practice.

A ministerial decree condemned the practise in September 2007 and there are efforts under way to sentence to jail those who perform the dangerous operations. 

Street barbers

The three types of FGM

According to the WHO, there are three main types of FGM:

- Removal of the clitoral hood only (most common in Egypt)

- Removal of the clitoris and the labia minora (inner vaginal lips)

- Removal of all of the woman's external genitalia and the narrowing of the vaginal entrance

Until recently, FGM was mainly performed by local street barbers, using unhygienic razor blades that could result in infections.

In September 1994, CNN aired footage of a FGM operation as world leaders gathered for a UN conference on population and development in Cairo.

The Egyptian government was pushed into action and in 1996, the ministry of health and population banned FGM in state hospitals.

However, resistance has emerged in the most unlikely of quarters; one of the biggest obstacles facing human rights advocates is the widespread acceptance of the procedure by the medical community.

In 1996, a group of Egyptian doctors challenged the ban saying that female genital circumcision was entrenched in Islamic life and teaching. 

When several girls bled to death after being circumcised by street barbers, many families resorted to doctors who could charge as little as 150 Egyptian pounds ($27) in poorer areas and up to 1,500 ($270) in middle and upper class residential areas of Cairo.

Fahmy says, "The medicalisation of the procedure has almost legitimised it even more. This has to stop."

In November 2006, a conference of scholars from the Muslim world ruled by overwhelming majority that FGM was contrary to the teachings of Islam and should be stopped immediately.

It was not until June 2007 when an 11-year-old girl died while a doctor performed the procedure that the government universally banned the practice.

Sanctioned by religion?

However, Fahmy concedes that eradicating FGM entirely has been hindered by the common arguments tying the bloody practice to Islam.

Others claim that FGM is a remnant of ancient Egyptian rituals, though there has been no historical evidence supporting such a theory.

Ali Gomaa, the grand mufti of Al Azhar University, the highest body of jurisprudence in Sunni Islam, issued a fatwa - or religious edict - in late 2007, clearly denouncing FGM.

He emphasised that FGM is a sin and forbidden in Islam.

However, that has failed to stop many from continuing the practice.

A beautiful cut?

Mahmoud and Ibrahim travel to rural areas to educate girls about FGM [Bauomy]

Mahmoud now uses her experiences to educate young women in Egypt's rural areas about the illegality and adverse effects of FGM.

Despite the ordeal she says she has been through, Mahmoud remains boisterous and energetic, telling jokes and teasing her friends.

"This is the only way I can deal with what has happened to me. I have to laugh about life. Otherwise I would cry all the time," she said.

"And to be quite honest some of the things I went through seem funny in retrospect."

She and Fatma Ibrahim, who was circumcised when she was 10, are part of a team that regularly visits schools and colleges educating young women about FGM.

However, they realised early on that it is important to educate adolescent men about the procedure and its consequences as well. 

"The only way we can get the support from boys and men is by playing on their selfishness," said Mahmoud.

"When we go to youth centres around Egypt, we make clear to the boys that a circumcised woman will at the end of the day be worse in bed. We tell them men will have less pleasure if she is circumcised and that it is much more fun for him if she isn't."

"If we tell them that it is only bad for the woman. They wouldn't care," she told Al Jazeera. 

Intolerable crimes

In 2008, the NCCM launched large billboard campaigns on main highways and thoroughfares, bought television commercials to target a broad audience, and set up a national hotline as part of its media drive hoping to change perceptions.

Their message is that FGM will no longer be tolerated by the authorities. 

Ibrahim says people frequently call the hotline with questions about the safety and appropriateness of FGM. She says many are confused and some parents are seeking help for their daughters.

The UNDP has been assisting the NCCM in holding lectures in elementary and high schools and has launched the Free Village Model whereby 120 villages throughout Upper and Lower Egypt promise to actively tackle FGM after participating in workshops and attending lectures.

According to a study by the Egyptian Demographic and Health survey (EDHS) in 2005, the prevalence of FGM among girls aged 11 to 17 dropped to 66 per cent, indicating a trend change over the time of a generation. 

However, Ibrahim and Mahmoud say this is not good enough.

"Our dream is that there would be no more FGM at all."

For Al Jazeera's coverage on the 60th Anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, click here.

 Source: Al Jazeera
 
Topics in this article
People

Country

City

Organisation

Feedback Number of comments : 16
 
tjm308
Afghanistan
19/12/2008
This is sick!!
Stop torturing these children!! Secret Slave - good name. Like being in the US?? Pls if you feel this way (I think I understood what you said) go back to where ever you came from.

Ernest Saenz
United States
20/12/2008
male circumcision
Since the subject came up, some personal experience. Not having been circumcised as a baby, as it is normally done, at the age of 28 I was put under anesthesia to the point of loss of consciousness and circumcised. My reason was due to working long days in the hot climate, the foreskin helped promote a yeast infection that then became easier to reoccur and cause discomfort. A reoccurring yeast infection causing discomfort had not been mentioned for the females. Here's a reason for a man.

Jay Elle
United Kingdom
20/12/2008
Female Circumcision
Juman Davalu is obviously ill-informed. What an ignorant thing for him to say! Almost laughable.

MB
Canada
20/12/2008
Circumcision
I will start campaigning against female circumcision amongst African and Middle Eastern nations when the governments of Western nations do two things: first, make male circumcision illegal, as it is just as bad as female circumcision, and second, make female circumcision illegal! 35 out of 50 US states allow female circumcision - perhaps someone should talk to the UN about that before they go after places where it is culturally rooted.

H.Klaus
Canada
22/12/2008
male Circumcision
I say it is complete nonsense to have and senseless to have female and male children circumcised. I am a male in my seventies and fortunately was not circumsiced. I never had any problems and see no problem why men or women could not keep themselves clean.

E.G.
United States
22/12/2008
tjm308, I think you misunderstood what Secret Slave was saying. I think he or she is actually against female circumcision and is using the argument that the tongue is used for pleasure (tasting) and could cause over indulgence, so why not just cut that off too? Maybe indulgence isn't the right word. I don't know. I think you get what I mean though.

mka4010- female
United States
23/12/2008
Female Circumcision
I wanted to say a big "Thank You" to Al Jazeera and to Jasmin Bauomy for the article. Mutilation of women is a crime against the human race, and it's important to educate and bring notice to these issues. I'm not Jewish, I'm not Muslim, but I don't agree with male circumcision either. I find mutilation of either gender's sexual body parts against someone's will to be a criminal act. If an adult chooses this, then they have that right - but to mutiliate children is beyond comprehension.

secretslave
United States
19/12/2008
organ or skin circumcision ?
salaam, For they are not the same, and when life takes away matter, it has to explain the right in thetaking account, to claim that the guard knows better then the sender of matters upon LIFE? So they do not do to the males whatis done unto the females, so from that account of gender who knows BEST, that inwhich took away what was sent? Its tongue has pleasure and could caus eit to over eat so why leave the tongue? Take its pleasure too then say it was to keep it from the over eating

Juman Davalu
Iran
19/12/2008
Female circumcision
Look, all circumcision needs to stop, including the circumcision of boys, naturegave us the parts they gave us for a reason. So all circumcision must stop, God did'nt want to punish the jews by taking thier forskin, & all theother justifications in favor of it are rubbish.

Kurt Urbaschek
United States
19/12/2008
Female mutilation
Hi, To me female mutilation appears to be ,first,agains nature,and second very primitive. But here,in the USA,most of the MALES are also mutilated( I am not,and one of our Jewish Doctors who examined me,looked at it several times in amazement,and shook his head),and this also appears to me,to be very primitive-but it appeares,that we are a Primitive Country anyway(one of about three countries in the entire world,which do not have the Metric System).Greetings from San Diego,California

Ernest Saenz
United States
19/12/2008
female circumcision
The Lord God created us in His image. God created a woman for mans companionship and procreation. A womans body is complete. Hygeine need only be acquired by bathing. To say that a womans circumcised genital promotes fertility is a falsehood. A woman genitals are not there for a "picture show" to say circumcision is aesthetically pleasing or contributes to the beauty of a woman. The medical community should not promote it to make money. Thanks to Grand Mufti Ali Gomaa for his fatwa.

Musa
United States
20/12/2008
Female Mutilation
I thought one reason Islam was revealed to destroy disgusting cultural practices such as this. There is some evidence of FGM in pre-Islamic times, there have been mummies for with mutilated genitals. What would Muhammad (a.s.) say if he heard that people claiming to be Muslims were forcing their daughters to tye their severed clitoris to their arm? Remember, God punishes injustice, and this is definately un-Islamic and injust.

Marc
Germany
20/12/2008
Traditions
Once again, women have to pay the price exacted by traditions to cope with society. It is always double standards, from granting males pre-/extra-marital sex to punishing females for getting raped. Near Eastern societies are always looking towards the gap in money, technical experience and armed forces when adressing the gap to the west - but what about rights for nonmales? It is the utmost shame that so much from the womanhood-loving prophet has been distorted by male theologists and lawyers.

RL
United Kingdom
21/12/2008
The term Female Cicumcision is misleading
Please, Female Genital Mutilation is nothing like male circumcision! This is why we should never refer to it as female circumcision because then uninformed people believe the two to be similar. They are in no way commensurable. Male cicumcision does not cause the same damage. Please stop belittling the suffering of millions of girls and women by bringing in arguments about male circumsicion here. These debates are seperate and should be held apart. The barbaric butchery of women must be stop!

mimm
Sweden
21/12/2008
female mutilation
How circumcision is to be performed is mentioned in the hadith narrated by Umm ‘Atiyah, may Allah be pleased with her, according to which a woman used to perform circumcisions in Madinah. The Prophet (Peace and Blessings of Allah be upon Him) told her: "Do not abuse (i.e. do not go to extremes in circumcising) that is better for the woman and more liked by her husband." (Reported by Abu Dawud in al-Sunan, Kitab al-Adab he said this hadith is da‘if). islamqa.com

tjm308
Afghanistan
22/12/2008
Illegal
MB – you need to do some research before you start running your fingers across the keyboard.. FGC is illegal in Canada under section 267 and 268 of the Criminal COde. It was prohibited by federal law in the US in 1996 - illegal in ALL states. I would say the late date is because we didn’t have anyone DOING it for the better part of 2+ centuries

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article
Aljazeera.net/english 2003 - 2010 ©
Designed & Developed by Aljazeera IT