UPDATED ON:
Wednesday, February 18, 2009
17:05 Mecca time, 14:05 GMT
 
FOCUS: ISRAEL VOTES
Israel's forgotten Palestinians

Palestinian women and girls are the most disadvantaged sector of the Israeli population [EPA]

The rising mistrust of Israelis towards the Palestinian citizens of Israel raises the question of what will happen to the indigenous inhabitants of Palestine, who already suffer discrimination.

While they used to make up the majority of the population of Palestine before the 1948 Arab-Israeli war, only 150,000 out of 950,000 native Palestinians remain within what is now known as the state of Israel.

After this tragic war and the forced expulsion of the people – known by Arabs as al-Nakba, or the Catastrophe - Israeli forces occupied 213 villages and expelled more than 400,000 refugees before the British mandate ended on May 15, 1949.

After the defeat of Arab forces in December 1948, Israel confiscated nearly 85 per cent of the territory. Most of this land was taken from about 800,000 Palestinians from 531 villages, cities and tribes, who were thrown out or fled in fear of their lives.

Those who remain

Today, the Palestinians who remain in Israel account for less than 20 per cent of the population, roughly numbering 1.4 million of a total population of 7.3 million.

As part of its longstanding effort to "divide and rule", Israel identifies them as "Arab Israelis" rather than the Palestinian citizens of Israel to separate them from their kin in occupied territories.

The majority of them live in all-Palestinian towns and villages located in three main areas: in Galilee in the north, in the "little triangle" in the centre, and in the Naqab, or Negev, as it is referred to in Hebrew.

By referring to the desert area of Naqab as Negev, Israel tries to achieve a fait-accompli to erase what remains for the natives - a name.

Up to 220,000 indigenous Palestinians are displaced within Israel and not allowed to return to their homes, while 43 villages, where more than 70,000 Palestinians live, are not recognised by Israel.

All citizens are equal?

Israel identifies itself as a state "Jewish in essence and democratic in character".

Azmi Bishara, a Palestinian citizen of Israel and a former member of the Knesset, says it is unrealistic and prejudiced for Israel to be both Jewish and democratic.

"I would call it trivial democracy. It is a democracy for Jews," Bishara told Al Jazeera.

He called for a fair and impartial state for all Israeli citizens, taking into account the sizeable non-Jewish community.

"The Israeli state was established in 1948 on the ruins of the Palestinian people. Now if you want, in the language which will be known probably in Australia or America or even in South Africa, we are indigenous people, the natives of the place," Bishara said.

"And Israel was built on our ruins. We did not immigrate to Israel in order to become Israelis, like many French people would like the Algerians to integrate into France or to be accepted as equal citizens.

"We did not choose to be Israelis. Israel came to Palestine, destroyed Palestine and emerged from the ruins of Palestine.

"We are Arab Palestinians. Israeli identity does not exist even according to Israel - they insist their identity is Jewish. There is no such thing as Jewish Israeli identity.

"Our Israeli citizenship was forced upon us. Now we use it as a framework for work to demand equality."

Racism and discrimination

Discrimination favouring "Jewish nationals" pervades nearly all walks of life, depriving Palestinians from enjoying their social, civil, cultural, political and economic rights.

Negatively indentified as "non-Jews" in Israeli statistics, and subdivided into groups according to religious affiliation rather than nationality, Israeli law establishes Jewish nationality status as well as Israeli citizenship as differentiated levels of civil status.

The theocratic character of the Israeli legal system is shown by the fact that the enjoyment of full rights is determined by faith.

In depth


Al Jazeera's coverage of the Israel elections

Palestinian women and girls are the most disadvantaged sector of the Israeli population. They are the lowest paid and least educated segment, subject to legal abuse and inadequate judicial protection.

Every year, Israel demolishes dozens of houses belonging to Palestinian Bedouin in unrecognised villages in Naqab, leaving dozens of families without shelter.

"Most Palestinians in Israel live in discrimination in all walks of life. They cannot go back to their villages. They become internal refugees, living 5km from their villages, from which they were driven away, and cannot go back to their properties," Bishara said.

"There is a phenomenon called 'unrecognised villages'. Villages that should not be there, although they were there before the state of Israel emerged. So, it is a severe case of discrimination."

Figures and statistics

According to a report released by the Israel Democracy Institute in June 2007, about 56 per cent of the Jews in Israel publicly voice their opposition to full equality for the Arabs.

As many as 78 per cent of them reject the idea Arab parties should join the government or any crucial political decision-making body. 

Other Israeli statistics show that half of Israel’s non-Jewish population is defined as "poor".

Among non-Jewish citizens, 51.2 per cent of the families were poor as opposed to 15.4 per cent of the Jewish families in 2006, according to the Central Bureau of Statistics.

As stated by the Law of Return, relatives of Palestinian citizens of Israel abroad cannot return to Israel, while Jews automatically qualify for citizenship.

Most worryingly, 66 per cent of Jews do not trust Palestinian citizens of Israel and 55 per cent of them think that they should leave Israel.

Government prejudice

Tzipi Livni, the current foreign minister of Israel and a frontrunner in the race to become the next prime minister, told a group of secondary school students in Tel Aviv on December 11, 2008, that Palestinian Israelis should not remain in Israel once a Palestinian state is eventually created.

"My solution for maintaining a Jewish and democratic state of Israel is to have two distinct national entities," Livni was quoted by army radio as saying.

"And among other things I will also be able to approach the Palestinian residents of Israel, those whom we call Arab Israelis, and tell them: 'Your national aspirations lie elsewhere,'" Livni said.

Another party leader who advocates Livni's plan is Avigdor Lieberman, whose party Yisrael Beiteinu seems set to become the third-largest in Israel.

Lieberman also wants to strip citizenship from Palestinian citizens of Israel, whom he considers to be disloyal to the "Jewish state".

The rising popularity of Lieberman reflects the general mood of the Jews towards the indigenous population.

Such discrimination does not exist against Jews in Arab countries. In Morocco, for instance, Jews are well integrated in the society and Andre Azoulay, a Moroccan Jew, is a senior adviser to King Mohammed VI.

Israel is not accountable for such prejudiced measures, but if such things happen to Jews anywhere in the world, they will be considered anti-semitic.

The views expressed by the author are not necessarily those of Al Jazeera.

 Source: Al Jazeera
Feedback Number of comments : 30
 
Jonathan
United States
09/02/2009
A few observations....
* Arabs in Israel are discriminated. However, Arabs have a few representatives in the Israeli parliament. I haven't heard of a single Jewish holding political power in Arab states. * Palestine is a name of a region. Nowhere in history will you find mentioning of a Palestinian state. Even today, there is currently no state named as Palestine. * The "original" name of the region, "Province Syria Palestina", cannot be pronounced in Arabic - no P letter. That is why there is Falastin in Arabic

Aaron
New Zealand (Aotearoa)
10/02/2009
Israels forgotten Palestinians
Israel's forgotten Palestinians By Ahmed El Amraoui Upon reading this article, although it mearly colaberates what I suspect, zoinism is nothing but racist, aggresive expansionism, which would be labelled anti-sematic by the Hypocrates of israel. Dirty, dirty Israeli government, and those who support it.

mzmarlena
United States Minor
10/02/2009
Palestine and Gaza
says the article, "Such discrimination does not exist against Jews in Arab countries. In Morocco, for instance, Jews are well integrated in the society and Andre Azoulay, a Moroccan Jew, is a senior adviser to King Mohammed VI." Please, Morocco is an exception. Jany left in Iran, or Afghanistan? How many in all the Muslim areas? Good grief. n. I've been on a visit. Don't even tell me about Jews in India, who thanks to Islam have left. How many Jews were killed in Mumbai?

AHMED
Saudi Arabia
10/02/2009
DISCRIMINATION
WELL MR.AMRAOUI I WAS VERY MUCH DISTRESSED TO KNOW ABOUT THE SUFFERINGS OF THE PALESTINIANS LIVING IN ISRAEL AND I AM PRETTY MUCH SURE THAT IF SUCH THING HAPPENS TO THE JEWS LIVING IN THE OTHER MUSLIM COUNTRIES THEN THERE WOULD HAVE BEEN GREAT HUE AND CRY NOT ONLY FROM JEWS BUT FROM THE AMERICANS TOO,AND IF U ASK AMERICANS ABOUT THIS RIGHTS VIOLATION THEY WILL SAY ISRAEL HAS A RIGHT TO DEFEND ITSELF.COME ON GIVE ME A BREAK I HATE TO READ ANY NEWS ABOUT ISRAELIS.

redhot
Philippines
10/02/2009
Israels existence
I dont understand why arabs always put in mind that Israel did not exist even the start of time. Israel did exist hundreds of years BC not just in 1948. Israel is the most historic country in the World. It is where the cradle of civilazation begun. It is even mentioned in what they called Koran.

Victor
United States
09/02/2009
Trust?
Israelis do not trust the Palestinians living inside Israel for only one reason - 1.4 million potential suicide bombers.

Benny
Israel
09/02/2009
Very good article, but you ignore some facts.
In 1947 the UN suggest 2 countries. The jews accepted the solution, but the Palestians not accepted, and they start the effensive on the Jews. Now, the only reason for the disthrust, is that the Arabs in Israel are aginst the Jews. All the time they demonstrate fior their brothers in the west bank and Gaza, and in the latest war they throw stones and attack jews. So, next time, do not be supprised for the disthrust.

Guy Body
New Zealand (Aotearoa)
10/02/2009
Arab anti-semitism
I don't doubt that Israeli Arabs suffer immense injustices, but your statement that there is no anti-semitism in the Muslim world is fantasy. Anti-semitism varies from non-existent (as in Morocco) to brutal (Yemen). You might want to consider that, if the Muslim world had been truly tolerant, Ehud Olmert might have been Prime Minister of Iraq! As it is, the most intransigent group in Israel are those Jews who remember Arab persecution. It's made a bad situation worse.

Atif
Afghanistan
10/02/2009
Israels forgotten Palestinians
I am glad that finally someone spoke out about the plight of palestinians living inside the 'illegal entity of israel'. The words of livini just shows how 'moderate' she is. With 'moderates' like her, who needs hard liners. Over all, this article is a slap on the face of those who call israel a 'democratic state' and chose to ignore all the human rights violations that are commited by 'illegal entity of israel'

David
Netherlands
10/02/2009
Israels forgotten palestinians
''indigenous inhabitants of Palestine'', Who are they? King David (Daud) of King Solomon ( Sulaiman) were Jewish, not Palestinian. More than 3000 years ago there was a Jewish kingdom on what the call Palestina now. After King Nebucadnezar of Babyloon took the Jewish people into captivity, enslaved them, after Allexander the great of Macedonia, after the Roman Empire en many other occupiers, including Arabs and muslims, now who are indigenous inhabitants of Palestine?

dana
United States
12/02/2009
anti zionist
i feel like where back in the Salem witch trials where, whoever spoke against these little girls and there false accusations, were accused of being friends with the devil and even accused of being witches...just like today...whoever speaks out against Israel...is accused of being ANTI-SEMITIC!!! just get over it...there not anti-semitic, there anti-Zionist.... BIG DIFFERENCE...at least try to understand between the two words...maybe one day you'll get it...maybe!!!

Imad
United States
12/02/2009
Redhot I think you better start reading a little more or maybe alot more. For your information no there was never a country named Israel before 1948! What you are referring to is the land of Israel which means the land of Jacob which happens to be in a country called Palestine. Example in that part of the world thats how you describe some ones home , the home of so and so, that does not mean that is the name of the land which the home sits on . How long ago was bronze age ? PALESTINE READ

sam
Thailand
12/02/2009
knesset
although there are a few arabs in the knesset-they are never invited into the government-which effectively gives them no power..thats ontop of the aphartied israel practices in the WB

michael
Ireland
14/02/2009
Israels forgotten Palestinians
A squater is always a squater. 10/100 or even a 1000 year from now the zionists whether they are from a russian ,european, american or an african origine ,they will never ever be classed as the indigenous people of palastine, every squater has palastinian blood on his hand ,directly or inderectly. the zionist government kill palastinians to make room for this foreigners. spreading like cancer cells.

Mursyid
Malaysia
14/02/2009
The Promised Land
True jews, who practised orthodox judaism will know that they're banished by god and are not allowed to have a state, the promised land that was often said is taken away from them because they refused to fight for it thousands of years ago. Muslims has more rights than the jew on Palestinian Land, what happened in Palestine was never a religious matter, but it is truly a political matter of Zionism who wanted to seize Palestine. Zionism was created about 100 years ago by an atheist

dima
Yemen
12/02/2009
TO- Guy Body New Zealand (Aotearoa)
u have no rite to talk about Yemen or any other middle eastern country since before Israel existed,Jews were living happily with the Arab countries...your lucky the middle east did not torture or even kick out these Jews living in their own country.be thankful we aren't cruel like the west with Hitler,the Nazi and fascist Italy.that's why Israel exists today.because the west did not want anything to do with the Jews so they put them in the middle east.its a shame how Jews aren't wanted anywhere

Bob
Afghanistan
12/02/2009
Israel and its palestinian population
Well,well,well, this can't be! I am shocked. Could a democratic state like Israel, which is a model for us, all behave this way? There must be some mistake. The author must be a terrorist to describe the brave citizens of Israel in this fashion. Some day I hope the shoe will be on the other foot, if you get my drift.

Imad
United States
12/02/2009
Israels forgotten Palestinains
Nice try David that may work for those who are uninformed. I guess that is why the Palestine Thalmud was renamed the Jerusalem Thalmud. Alot of those Palestinains are Arabized Arabs dear sir. But no matter what you call them they have more of a right to that land than those eastern and western European jews (Ashkanazi jews) who are converts into that religion and are not from the tribes of Israel. Jesus (PBUH) was a Palestinian Jew. Stop kidding yourself David. Cover one lie with another.

Mike
United States
12/02/2009
Israels forgotten enemys
Was ther not a partition, Jordan and Israel just as Pakistan and India? Is it because muslims can't live in peace anywhere? Didn't over every Arab country attack israel on the day of Independence in 48? Where are the 900,000 Jews who lived in Arab land less than 60 years ago? Where are the people of the book who the prophet preached to go? Quit drinking your Islamic kool-aid. A lie repeated 7 times, 77 times, 777 times is still a lie. For the sake of humanity, our children, stop the lies!

Umar Al-Farouq
Malaysia
12/02/2009
Zionism, Jewish & old story
Jewish should read history and should learn it. Jewish should aware, in their history, they only live in harmony during :- 1. Rise of Cyrus the Great (Persian King) 2. Rise of Darius the Great (Persian King) 3. Rise of King David & Solomon (Kingdom of Israelist) 4. Rise of Umar the Great (2nd muslim caliph) Should the debt paid by kiling more palestine or muslim? Should the Jewish take responsible for Zionism sins? 5. Rise of Saladin (Muslim Sultan)

Abu Jadeela
United States
14/02/2009
Israels Forgotten Palestinians
To Jonathan I think that you are an ignorant when it come to palestine or the Palestinians. First of all the Philistines which are the Palestinians were in existance before the creation the so called Israel or Jewish and even before Ibraham. Secondly, Israel, jews or jewish they never have aplace to be called home. An example, Chinese In china, German in Germany Greeks in greece and so on. Try to educate yourself before you attempt to give your opinion.

bruce
Australia
14/02/2009
A one state solution
For peace Israelis need to come to terms with the disaster their state has brought local Arabs who predate the Zionist project. All citizens west of Jordan River need equal rights regardless of religion. Only justice can bring Jewish people safety.

Majeed
Australia
14/02/2009
semetism
I think there is a lot of misconception about semetism, all palestinians are also semites, all jews are not semites, consider the fact that if you criticise palestinians, you are anti semetic

ilan
Israel
14/02/2009
solotion
what you don't understand that Livni only want the good thing for all of us- 2 states for 2 coltures. why shouldn't all the "Israeli arab's" or the "Palestinian citizens of Israel"- it is no metter how you call them- why shouldn't thay be a citizens of the Palestnian state.most of all the areas that thay leave in now, the Israeli leaders would gladly give tham to the new Palestinian state, it is more then a fair solution. but there is one problem, the arab's don't want it becuse thay prefer to..

ilan
Israel
14/02/2009
continue to the solution
the arab's want to stay part of the state of israel because they way of life and prosperity is much better than in all the arab's states around Israel. about hte democracy- were else un arab country there is a jew miniuster, in israel the minister of sport's & coulture is an arab that critisized the last war- if you think he is a co-zionist! the conflict will end only in one condition- WHEN ARAB'S WILL START LOVE THAIR CHILDREN MORE THAN THEY HATE ISRAEL!

Zak
Australia
15/02/2009
freedom for palistine
the Palestinians were living in Palistine before their was a race called jews or Israelites. the name jew came after the existence of judah and israel from the children of jacob, the great grandson of the prophet Abraham. In the bible Abraham emigrated in the land of Canaan as a stranger Genesis 17:8. so in fact PAlistine was all ways their and these murderers came after.

Jay Hubbell
United States
15/02/2009
Ethnic cleansing 101
Zionism is based on the irrational notion that a religious sect has a theocratic claim to land based on the fact that 2,000 years ago some people of a similar religion lived there. Israel is a white European colony imposed on the indigenous people.

AndyB
Canada
15/02/2009
No Palestinian History? Give your head a shake...
Arabic does not contain a "p" sound. But where you are mistaken is that "Palestinians" is not how they call themselves, hence "Filistines." I call a country Germany, but the people who live there call it Duetchland. As far as there being no history, or only mentioning King David or Solomon... ever read "And David slew Goliath"? It's in the most printed book in human history. Goliath was a Filistine. Read more, arabs did exist in antiquity. And "cradle of civilization"?!?!? Try Ur/Babylon.

Jayadevan
India
15/02/2009
Indian Jews
mzmarlena, A small correction. Indian Jews left for brighter job prospects in Israel, better chances of getting a Jewish bride or a groom than in India, where their community was minuscule to begin with. The Jews who died in Mumbai were not Indians.

Lovin K Johnson
Canada
15/02/2009
self-reflection
If you are intelligent and look at it scientifically, if one group of people face discrimination after being fully accepted wherever they grow and later being kicked out, it probably is has nothing to do with other groups that have no such serous issue who came and went or got integrated, it has to be with the talmudic tale that they are superior to goys. Besides the saphredic jews were defended against the church by the muslim ottomans until zionism sowed seperation

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article