UPDATED ON:
Tuesday, January 20, 2009
03:36 Mecca time, 00:36 GMT
Focus The Obama Presidency
Obama 'is no Martin Luther King'

Many African-Americans have drawn parallels between Obama and Martin Luther King [EPA]

Glen Ford, the executive editor of Black Agenda Report, explains why he rejects ties between the US president-elect and the iconic civil rights leader.

The two days touch: Dr Martin Luther King's Birthday observance and Barack Obama's presidential inauguration, January 19 and 20, respectively.

To many, the juxtaposition is self-evident confirmation of the intersection of the two men's missions.

Dr King's journey, which ended with his murder in 1968, and Obama's ascent to the presidency, are seen to merge as the dates approach to form a perfect, tragic-glorious symmetry - a 48-hour revelation.

The coincidence of the calendar makes for good copy and grand sermons, but in fact reveals a great moral and political dissonance.

It is true that there could have been no Obama presidency had Dr King and the movement he sprang from not existed, but that simple fact of history does not amount to a King benediction from the grave for Obama's moral character and political policies.

Indeed, Dr King's life and words are indelible evidence that he and Obama represent opposing moral and political camps.

Tens of millions of African-Americans - who did not choose the little-known Obama to be their champion, but supported him near-universally at the polls once his candidacy had been made "viable" - will celebrate a vicarious attainment of power when Obama is sworn in.

Yet when confronted on Obama's political agenda, enough of which has been put in motion and otherwise made plain since election day, few Black Obama supporters can mount a cogent defence.

Policy vacuum

"Better than McCain" doesn't cut it, anymore.

In depth

Focus

Twitter: Live inauguration updates
Obama 'no Martin Luther King'
Inauguration guide 

Videos
Civil rights activist celebrates

Playing for president Obama


Your Views
Send your message to Obama
Send us your video views
When the New York Times describes the emerging Obama administration as "centre-right," there is not much for an honest progressive to defend - and most African-Americans are progressive on economic issues and questions of war and peace.

Beyond a ritual counting of the president-elect's African-American appointees, most African-Americans seem oblivious to the political nature of his cabinet, his policy pronouncements and shameful silences.

More likely, they pretend to be oblivious so as not to lose that once-in-a-lifetime feeling that happened when a black man won.

It is not simply that the Obama-ites failed to muster a defence in Harlem or Baltimore or other venues; admittedly, it is difficult to defend the indefensible.

What is most shocking - maddening - is their rejection of any political or moral standard for evaluating the black soon-to-be president.

All that remains is the fact of Obama's power and the delusion that blacks somehow share in that power.

There is no thought of speaking the truth to those in power, and certainly no place for a moral compass in such a valueless void.

Military spending

We can understand, then, how people would imagine Obama and Dr King to be soul mates.

Obama is set to send more troops
to Afghanistan [AFP]

The fact that one of these men fought his whole life against the forces of militarism and economic exploitation, while the other empowers, and is empowered by, bankers and militarists, does not register on their anaesthetised moral and political sensors.

If the Obama-ites had more presence of mind, they would avoid comparisons with Dr King, which can only redound to Obama's great detriment.

King's break with his one-time ally, Lyndon Johnson, the former president, set the standard for both political and moral behaviour.

When it became clear that the war on poverty, a programme of government aid to help the poor in the mid-1960s, was doomed by the war in Vietnam, which acted "like some demonic destructive suction tube," devouring all available resources, King publicly declared against the war.

In doing so, he severed what had been the most productive relationship between a US president and a black leader in US history.

But the war gave him no choice, since military expenditures made "rehabilitation" of the American poor impossible.

Both morality and politics led to the same conclusion: the movement could not coexist with war.

The lesson is directly applicable today, but Americans, black and white, find it difficult to recognise the characters.

Obama is Lyndon Johnson.

Historical comparisons

National revitalisation, including redress of historical African-American grievances, is impossible unless military expenditures are dramatically reduced.

Would Martin Luther King have
backed Obama? [GALLO/GETTY]
But Obama is committed to putting 100,000 new pairs of Marine and Army "boots on the ground," an expanded war in Afghanistan/Pakistan and a generally bigger US military footprint on the planet.

This, in the midst of global economic collapse.

Dr King would find creative ways to confront Obama's militarism, and to actively resist further diversion of public wealth to the bankers.

Were he to survey the current political scene, King would be most impressed, not with the Obamas' party plans for the night after his birthday, but with the way that a daughter of Georgia salvaged Black America's moral reputation at the beginning of Israel's assault on Gaza.

Cynthia McKinney's [US former Green Party presidential candidate] attempted voyage of solidarity with the besieged people of Gaza on the medical relief boat Dignity, rammed and almost sunk by Israeli warships, reminds the world that not all African-Americans have morphed into warmongering clones of Colin Powell and Condoleezza Rice.

Thanks to the presence of the former Georgia congresswoman on the mission, millions of Arabs have been made aware of a different 'Black America' one that is not silent, like Barack Obama, in the face of a purposely inflicted human rights catastrophe.

Some of us are still in our right minds.

Hopefully, most of the others will recover, sooner rather than later.

Glen Ford is executive editor of Black Agenda Report - an edited version of this article appeared on its website.

The views expressed by the author are not necessarily those of Al Jazeera.

 Source: Al Jazeera
 
Topics in this article
People

Country

Organisation

Feedback Number of comments : 17
 
mike
United States
21/01/2009
this article is projected at the most frustrated type person who is constantly looking for something to bitch about. there is a much wider vision in humanity needed right now and i think it sad for your reputation that it recieved such a spotlight in your reporting we need balanced people being a little on the positive side and what are you doing? feeding the frustrations of wallowing in the mud come on now lets take some responsibility for doing something good

Lee Siu Hoi
Hong Kong
21/01/2009
Obama is no Martin Luther King
Some people talk about civil rights. Some people act on civil rights. By virtue of running for Presidency, Obama already believe in his implicit civil rights. The rest is history. Just talking about civil rights is going back in time.

Steve Weaver
Sweden
21/01/2009
High horse
Glen Ford needs to get off of his sanctimonious high horse. Nobody is saying that Barack Obama is The Rev Martin Luther King! As he notes in this whiny diatribe, the claim is that Barack Obama would not have been in a position to even be considered as a candidate for president of the US without Dr King's clearing the way. If you really need a comparison with a previous headliner then President Obama is more of a JFK than an MLK. Is he perfect? No, but give him a fair go before knocking the man.

Brigitte
United States
21/01/2009
Obama vs Martin Luther King
Thank you for a great article. You sum up the apprehension many of us have, watching the "ususal" right of center" staff he hired and the ultraconservative image he projects with his election: a monarchic wedding more than the beginning of change. The poor were moved out of the way for the pomp. The money will continue to go into war not prosperity for all. Let's hope Obama has a change of heart at some point.

AS
Netherlands
21/01/2009
Agree
Obama is a black person who lives white and thinks green.

Mohamed
Germany
21/01/2009
Obama is no Martin Luther King
I must agree that yes, Obama is no Martin Luther King. He did not say that he was, and he gave no inclination that he gradually plans on running the world less, and fighting for civil rights more. Obama is unabashidly a politician, trying to mitigate as many divergent interests as possible, and not lobbying for just one. He needs to diplomacy and tact, that is what gives leverage when it is time to move with urgent matters. Being a champion for ONE cause alone will wearken those abilities.

Jack
Australia
21/01/2009
I don't think Obama's to blame, at least not yet. I'm sure Obama would've liked to implement more radical reforms in healthcare, social security, climate change, foreign policy but look at the USA now. Bush left him in two failed wars at a $trillion each, which spiked oil prices and crippled the economy. He is the POTUS, so his first concern is going to be remedying America. And Afghanistan needs more troops USA already left that country demolished once, and the Taliban took over. It's needed.

Camilla
United States
23/01/2009
Preseident Obama is Barack Obama
- And President Obama never ever stated or projected that he is Dr. King. That is in your mind - and for not in mine one of the millions of votes that voted for him as out President. Not to be President of the "brothers and sisters" in United States of a certain color or agenda. But for all of us. A President is not suppose to make a cabinet that reflects his skin color. But his policies. Wait, is that not what our sacred Dr. King fought for? Shame on you Glen Ford - Shame on you.

Duke Quaye-Mensah
Ghana
24/01/2009
President Obama is no Martin Luther King
Who on earth would ever say that President Obama could be anything like Martin Luther King, well for those who don’t know, President Obama is an excellent and intelligent democrat who has made it to the US Presidency, God bless his soul, where as Martin Luther King was only playing a small part of civil right movement in the 50’s and 60’s.

George
United States
23/01/2009
MLK was a Preacher
There is no doubt that President Obama and Dr King are very much different. Thank goodness for that. King was a part of the civil rights movement of the 50's and 60's...but he was only a very small part. There were many other African Americans who took plenty of licks from the oppressor to make the tyrant change their ways and laws. Unfortunately the author of the article like so many other Americans have deified Dr King into something he was not. True he was murdered, like Medgar Evers.

Brian Steele, Sacramento, CA
United States
23/01/2009
Black Agenda Report
Glen Ford belittles himself, and the organization he represents, in attacking President Obama's political agenda and ideology. President Obama has demonstrated concern for all humanity, foreign and domestic.

melanie
United States
23/01/2009
obama and mlk
it's hard not to draw some relationship here growing up in atlanta in the 50s. but of course, mlk had the fortitude to devote his energy to non-violence and i believe that obama, if he checks in with his consciousness, would prefer to take that same path HOWEVER, one is more establishment than the other and let's face it, MLK would have never been elected, then or now. UNFORTUNATELY. I am relieved. That's all I can say. We are on the road to sanity with many obstacles along the way.

JFJ
United States
23/01/2009
Obama Presidency
Obama "is not Martin Luther King" reminds me of internet chat rooms that are full of spite, innuendo, and baseless attacks. You may not understand this concept but Obama's charge is to represent all Americans. He has been President for 48 hours yet you condemn him without cause nor facts. Your statement that King and Obama have opposing moral direction is laughable. Is it a wonder why your battles are never won? Respect, sincerity, and objectivity would help you effect the change you seek.

Robert Rice
United States
23/01/2009
Obama is no Martin Luther King
"When it became clear that the war on poverty, a programme of government aid to help the poor in the mid-1960s, was doomed by the war in Vietnam, which acted "like some demonic destructive suction tube," devouring all available resources, King publicly declared against the war." There was no US government deficit at the time so clearly the US could have payed for both "wars". Dr. Kings opposition to the Vietnam war was a moral issue not an economic one. Peace out!

Marlyn R.
United States
23/01/2009
Obama is no MLK
Ford's a perfect example of Aesop's 'Fox & the Grapes'.The fox couldn't get what he wanted, so he declared the grapes sour...never having tasted them. What would Ford do if put in Obama's place? Ignore the reality of 2 active wars, an economy in tatters, & over 2 dozen major messes to clean up care of the most incompetent President we've ever had in the U.S? Obama's a pragmatist. He's fixing what he can as fast as he can. Look what's he's done in just 40 hrs out of 4 years! Sweet!

Kuldeep
India
24/01/2009
The Obama Presidency
Its too early to comment, start giving judgment and draw comparisons. Obama is Obama. His own journey to this stage shows that he can bring change. We should not forget that he is a human being and not god. Challenges are plenty and expectations are enormous.

Antonio Uceta
United Kingdom
26/01/2009
Obama is not Martin Luther King
The differences bewteen BO and MLK is that in principle thre are no obstacle to allow BO to change much needed policies in the US and the the rest of the world. MLK cleared the way and has been an inspiration to BO and many of us, but he would have never been president of the US. He was too good for that. BO got there, at last. Not easy task. Now is time to see what the man is able to do.

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article
Aljazeera.net/english 2003 - 2010 ©
Designed & Developed by Aljazeera IT