UPDATED ON:
Thursday, October 23, 2008
00:23 Mecca time, 21:23 GMT
 
Focus US Elections 2008
Is Arab support for Obama fading?

Obama's image has been damaged in the eyes of many Arabs [EPA]

It is no secret that many people in the Arab world looked at Barack Obama, the Democratic US presidential candidate, as someone who, if elected president, could bring positive change to US foreign policy in the Middle East.

Such an attitude seemed strong during the presidential primaries, but since Obama's victory in the primaries last June over Hillary Clinton, the former first lady and Obama's rival for the Democratic nomination, Arab support for the Illinois senator appears to have faded away.

The main reason is Obama himself.

He has carefully distanced himself from Arab and Muslim issues in the US and abroad over the last six months.

The Democrat has been fighting against a tough negative campaign that has tried to highlight his Muslim roots, foreign name and brief political history to portray him as a "hidden Muslim" who is part of a conspiracy to destroy America from within by electing a Muslim as president.

As part of the campaign, Obama was portrayed as a "closet" Muslim, a pro-Arab and anti-Israeli candidate.

Americans were told that Obama was willing to sit and negotiate unconditionally with America's worst enemies, such as Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, the Iranian president, and that he could not be trusted with the security of the US, nor Israel.

Rumours circulated

In response, Obama has caved inward and systematically distanced himself from anything Arab or Muslim.

His outreach co-ordinator to American Muslims resigned a few days after his appointment in early August after rumours were circulated in attempts to link him to Muslim extremism.

Meanwhile, the Obama campaign refused to let female Muslims supporters, who were wearing headscarves, appear in the same photograph as the Democratic candidate, fearing that their appearance would hurt Obama's image.

Out of the same fear, the Obama campaign has also failed to organise any serious outreach efforts to Arab or Muslim Americans despite a well-publicised effort to reach out to other minorities, new voters and voting blocs.

On a policy level, the Illinois senator announced his support for Jerusalem as the "undivided" capital for Israel before the powerful Israeli lobby group, the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC), last June.

Obama has also tried to reduce the emphasis on his pro-dialogue approach toward countries such as Iran and Syria and instead assert his willingness to use force in places such Afghanistan and Pakistan.

Senator Joe Biden, Obama's chioce for vice president, is a self-described "Zionist," who believes that there can only be progress in the Middle East when "the Arab nations have known that there is no daylight between us [the United States] and Israel".

Realistic and militaristic

The more realistic, militaristic and pro-Israel Obama has been a disappointment for many Arabs, who hesitantly supported Obama during the primaries due to his different background and rhetorical emphasis on hope, dialogue and "change".

But, at the end of the day, many Arabs gave up on America and American politics a long time ago.

A poll of Arab public opinion conducted by Zogby international earlier this year found that 70 per cent of the Arab public have no confidence in the US.

It also found that 18 per cent believed that Barack Obama had the best chance of advancing peace in the Middle East, compared with 13 per cent for Hillary Clinton and just four per cent for John McCain.

A Pew survey found that there was "little enthusiasm" for either of the two main presidential candidates in the Muslim world compared with places like Europe.

In Egypt for instance, only 31 per cent have confidence in Obama and 23 per cent in McCain.

Both surveys were conducted in the spring of 2008 and since then Arabs have became more aware of the positions of Obama and McCain toward the major issues that most interest them such as Iraq, the Israeli-Palestinian peace process and Middle East democracy.

Such awareness may have deepened fears that neither candidate is daring enough to transform Washington's Middle East policy. 

Dialogue and diplomacy

Obama generally seems more willing to use dialogue and diplomacy, push the peace process forward and refrain from using force and confrontation than his Republican counterpart.

But Obama's views on the Middle East are not radically different from his opponent and predecessor.

The Democrat's plan for Iraq does not put a specific date for the withdrawal of all US forces from Iraq.

Instead, Obama says he will keep an undetermined number of troops in Iraq for an undetermined period of time to "protect" US interests there - a plan vague enough to keep the door open for a prolonged American presence in Iraq.

On the peace process, he has opposed Palestinian democracy and does not seem to support internal Palestinian dialogue and efforts to encourage unity.

Obama also appears to lack a clear plan for promoting Arab democracy.

He seems opposed to changing Arab governments by force and also seems disinterested in promoting democracy in the region.

He appears willing to support the status quo in exchange for gaining the support of Arab governments in stabilising Iraq and confronting Iran.

Obama has clearly moved right on Arab issues since becoming the Democratic party's presidential candidate. 

No better choice

This is not to say that McCain is a better choice for Arabs than Obama.

McCain appears to be more of a neo-conservative toward the Arab world than George Bush, the incumbent US president.

On Iraq, McCain had been calling for the removal of the government of Saddam Hussein, the former Iraqi president, since 1998 - five years before the actual US invasion of the country.

McCain also does not seem to have any interest in moving the Israeli-Palestinian peace process forward and seems to want to empower Israel and to help isolate it from its neighbours, by force if necessary. 

This is why McCain quickly supported the isolationist policies adopted by Ariel Sharon, the former Israeli prime minister, such as the construction of the separation barrier and disengagement from the peace process.

This means that neither Obama or McCain seem to be the right candidate for Arabs.

But some Arab idealists will still support Obama out of hope he may improve and out of fear that a McCain presidency could end up bringing more harm to the region than even the Bush administration.

 Source: Al Jazeera
Feedback Number of comments : 10
 
Barry Watts
United States
22/10/2008
Is Arab Support for Obama fading?
What people in the ME need to realize is that no candidate could win the US presidential election by aligning themselves with Arabs or Muslims, not after 9/11. There are millions of honorable Arab and Muslim Americans, but for the most part they are in isolated communities in big cities, suburbia, and rural America. Most Americans rarely interact with Arabs or Muslims and many unfortunately associate them with terrorism and radical Islam. Obama is doing what he has to do to win the election.

Barry Watts
United States
22/10/2008
I was shocked to see on CNN...
A group of American Muslims who actually support John McCain and referred to Obama as a "terrorist". It appears that there are, at least in the US, some Muslims who applaud the policies of George Bush, which really boggles the mind. On another CNN report, I saw Muslim-American McCain supporters get highly offended when a Christian McCain supporter displayed a mock "Obama for Change" bumper sticker with the Muslim crescent and the Communist hammer and sickle. What a strange new world we live in.

Blake Roberts
United States Minor
22/10/2008
Obama needs to do this...
To win an election in America Obama needs to pander to the rural gun toting redneck idiots through out America. And if that means not taking pictures with Muslims because of the ignorance and racism of some Americans so be it. 9/11 made the the Arab, regardless of his religious affiliation, and the Muslim America's sworn enemy. Muslims and Arabs need to realize that Obama is not Anti-Arab or Muslim. He's our best hope to salvage the tarnished reputation of the horrible Bush administration.

Sohail Gill
Pakistan
22/10/2008
Obama ?
Barry,although I do not live in the US yet a fair amount of input is grasped everyday since we are now living in a global village,hats off to the different media channels!What is Obama's goal?To be the president of America .OK but his recent attitude towards Arab muslim world on the issues like Palestine,Iran has been negative & on Pakistan overly hawkish which obviously is not liked by any muslim,he is appeasing jews to attract for votes but his muslim votebank has certainly shrunk,NO BOTHER!!!

benjamin r
United States
22/10/2008
American Sentiment
It is amazing that this hasn't been discussed in the Western Media more. It is truly upsetting to be a citizen in this country right now. Bush has killed the American empire, and rightly so because it was outdated long before his crimes. Arab nations need to understand that Obama is not another talking head with a knife clutched behind his back. Obama represents a U.S. of diplomacy and progresivity. When elected, he will help shape a new global community, because he will LISTEN & WORK for peace.

TIm
United States
22/10/2008
Obama the person
I can understand why people in the Middle East might be a little pensive when seeing Obama lean toward the right some regarding ME policy. It is true that he has to tread very carefully because there are many ignorant people in the US, and it is VERY important that he get elected. But I think the Arab and Muslim people need to see that he is a good man, a solid man of ethics who has come from a multicultural beginning, and his presence on the world stage will be good for everyone.

Che Nadel
United States
26/10/2008
Give the man a chance!
Barry Watts is correct. Reaching out to Muslims at this stage is the one thing that could destroy his campaign. The US is a narrow-minded, racist country at it's heart. The fact that I regret this doesn't make it less true. Obama has no choice at this stage but to distance himself from the culture that Americans fear so deeply. Please - be more mature than the average US voter. Have faith, and give him a chance to make a difference. I believe it will be worth it.

Little Murph
United States
23/10/2008
I hope Arab Support Does Not Fade
Senator Obama is our nation's last great hope. Please know that our nation is not filled w/idiots but rather a nation of thinkers who do not voice their opinions as loud as the uneducated. It brought me great peace in hearing General Powell commenting on the completely inappropriate comments from people on Senator Obama's religion. This country's gov't is suppose to be separated from church and state because of the many walks of life that live in this nation. Please know we are not all the same

michael
United States
24/10/2008
is arab support for obama fading
OBAMA has to play the game to be elected do not think that he will truly carry on the same ignorant policies of the previous adminitration in dealing with other nations there are a lot of people who have hatred for obama here they call him an arab or a muslim or a comunist or socialist in a derogitory term as another way of saying he,s black they used the same tactic against BROTHER KING AND MALCOM in the 60s people are real nervious here about what will happen if ther candidate dosnt win

Slingerland
United States
05/11/2008
Che Nadel wrote "The US is a narrow-minded, racist country at it's heart." What an idiot. The US is a nation of immigrants, of many cultures and traditions. It is a nation of great generosity and compassion, especially towards its enemies. It has abundantly proven this in the past and will do so again, in the future. It abidges the right of NONE to worship as they choose or live as they please. It is not perfect, but at least our vote counts. A historic victory is ours!

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article