UPDATED ON:
Thursday, December 25, 2008
13:52 Mecca time, 10:52 GMT
News Africa
Tutu: 'Use force to remove Mugabe'
Desmond Tutu has always advocated a stronger stance be taken against Mugabe [AFP ]

The South African archbishop says force may be needed to remove Robert Mugabe, the Zimbabwean president, from power.

Desmond Tutu, a Nobel Peace prize winner, told BBC radio that he hopes members of the African Union can be persuaded to issue Mugabe an ultimatum.

Tutu described the situation inside Zimbabwe, which has been crippled by hyper-inflation and a protracted battle for political power, as "desperate".  

He said said the AU should threaten to intervene if Mugabe continues to cling to power.

"All of us want to see a resolution of what is just an awful situation and I don't think you can have any real solution unless Mugabe steps down," he said.

"They can ask him to step down and if he steps down, OK, and if he doesn't, maybe he should be forced down."

'Legacy betrayed'

Tutu also accused South Africa of betraying its legacy of struggling against apartheid by failing to take action against Mugabe.

While regional countries such as Botswana and Zambia have taken a tough line against Harare, the South African government has stopped short of calling on him to resign.

South Africa had strong historic links with Mugabe, who provided support during the struggle against apartheid.

Rights activists

Tutu's comments come as a high court judge in Zimbabwe ordered a group of detained human rights activists be taken to hospital in order to investigate allegations of torture.

Jestina Mukoko, a leading human rights activist, and six others have been charged with plotting to overthrow the Zimbabwean government.

A human rights lawyers said on Wednesday that a judge ordered Mukoko and six other activists be sent to hospital under police guard.

Beatrice Mtetwa told the Associated Press the seven activists would be brought to court again on Monday to determine the next steps in the case.

Mukoko, a former newscaster who headed the Zimbabwe Peace Project, was taken away at gunpoint in Harare on December 3 by unidentified men.

If found guilty of the charges, the activists could face the death penalty, lawyers have said.

Zimbabwe police officials have denied holding Mukoko, who had not been seen since being taken from her home on the same day as nationwide protests against the country's deepening economic and health crises.

The case has added to doubts over the implementation of a power-sharing agreement between Mugabe and opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai, seen as a chance of rescuing the once relatively prosperous country from economic collapse.

The pact was formed in September, but has unravelled due to a fight over control of important ministries.

Amid the political stalemate, Zimbabweans continue to sink deeper into poverty, and more than 1,000 people have died from a cholera epidemic that threatens to spread to neighbouring South Africa.

 Source: Agencies
 
Topics in this article
People

Country

Feedback Number of comments : 17
 
Victory George
Nigeria
28/12/2008
Which way Africa?
It is so painful that Africa just refuse to be dynamic in a dynamic world. Our static nature is evident in our governance. If Mugabe refuse to leave power, Then something is underneath. The attachement to material wealth in Africa is reallydemoralising us. We have always considered power as a means of ammassing wealth and no to serve the interest of the People. Please AU respond to the suggestions of Desmond Tutu. africa must Grow

H. (Bart) Vincelette
Canada
28/12/2008
Archbisop Desmond Tutu & Zimbabwe.
Two of the men I admire most , are Nelson Mandela and Desmond Tutu. They are both men of greatness. If Archbishop Tutu recommends that force be used to overthrow the Mugabe , you can depend that the situation must be dire.

Jack Maseko
United Kingdom
28/12/2008
Act Now
Why should the World accept the Zimbabwe crises as "the best tv series on electoral fraud, torture and human rights abuses, and all the evils you can associate with leadership" staring Mugabe and his henchmen. Come on World we are greater, with a conscious bitter than Mugabe and his selfish crew. If We Act Now we reduce the chances of the Zimbabwean situation ever happening any way else under the sun. Come on!

I-JahRain
United States
29/12/2008
Change is comming
I was elated when the Union Jack came down and Zimbabwe was free from the shackles of colonial rule,however being realistic,things have not changed for the better and here we are today,I ask myself are we better off now than we were then,awhile ago we blamed the external forces for our lot,today we have to hold ourselves accountable Mr Magube please step down and let us ensure that the generation which is yet to come can have peace and stabality for the prosperity of the nation RASTAFARI

Ian Ross
Canada
31/12/2008
ICC?
Where is the ICC in all of this? Surely, Mugabe's neglect for, at the very least, the cholera epidemic is means to have him tried for crimes against humanity?

Guluva
United Kingdom
02/01/2009
I am surprised and deeply disappointed with Desmond Tutu's comments on using force to remove Mugabe. When does force help solve a problem? Look what has happened in Iraq and still happening in Afghanistan. I don't think using force is the right way to revive Zimbabwe, the Zimbabwean situation is very complicated is a shame that all the supporters for use of force or violence underestimate the damage it could do to a country and its people.

Tatenda Runyararo
Afghanistan
02/01/2009
Force or nothing
Mugabe was a statesman and a leader. There is only one way for him to go: force. Tutu is right. In 2002 he said he was going in 2008 and we listened - now 2010. Zanu PF is not a problem. The problem is the ideology that revolutionaries die in power. Zimbabweans need help. Mugabe out. Ballot box in in Zimbabwe is a waste of time. Thrice it has failed us. Surely, when are we going to stop 'normalising the abnormal.' Going to South Africa to buy bread and tea leaves.

Chux Ugwaka
Germany
02/01/2009
Shame on you Tutu
It is very unfortunate that a bishop should advocate using force. Could it be that prayers have become ineffective? Nobel Peace Laureate indeed! Mugabe gave back stolen lands to their rightful owners and that has made him become a "dictator" according to the US and GB and their African sell-outs like Tutu and Odinga. 4 per cent of 87 per cent of farmland in South Africa belongs to the Blacks, what has Tutu said about this injustice? When will a Black man become a Pope, my dear Tutu?

David G
United States
02/01/2009
He has become what he fought
It seems Mugabe has become the kind of person he was fighting against oh so long ago.

BIG_G
Australia
04/01/2009
Use force to remove Mugabe
Are you in your mind, Desmond? It is shame on you. You call yourself an archbishop, a person who carry the word of God, but you are not. You want to see bloodshed in our soil. May God forgive you

David
Denmark
04/01/2009
Shame on you Tutu
Shame on you Tutu This guy, Desmond Tutu is out of his mind. Mugabe is our hero. You can't call Mugabe a dictator. You are not standing for Africans, but for your slave masters. Remember, Mugabe gave back stolen lands to their rightful owners. Shame on you Desmond.

babwean
Zimbabwe
05/01/2009
Chux and David require a lesson on Zimbabwe
Perhaps the two of you should look at the facts of the land transfer. If you believe the 'rightful' landowners to be the current zanu-pf cronies of Mugabe then I must have missed a class in history! The general population of Zimbabwe has not benefitted from Mugabe's version of land reform. People are dying each day from cholera and starvation because this man refuses to let the money he has been given by countries such as Denmark and Germany reach the people due to his greed. He is a dictator

ian ross
Canada
05/01/2009
Tutu has guts
I think Tutu is being pretty courageous for being a man of the cloth, yet recognizing a suffering that could go on for much longer and claim many more lives than an overthrow of the Mugabe regime by force ASAP. I may not have the facts straight, but was it not his own cronies and cabinet members and other socially elite families whom he sold back much of the stolen land to? Most of that land fell into total neglect, and landless peasants were blocked from buying any allocated in the reform!

ian ross
Canada
05/01/2009
"Great Liberator of Zimbabwe"
Also, a leader who would choose to bulldoze a massive slum in his own capital in 2005 and turn more than a half million people out into the streets, only to crush their protests with violence and intimidation a few years later in a sham election, in this day and age can be called a liberator? No, it's time for him to go. I think the only people in the end who will stand up for him when push comes to shove are his closest party members anyway. And they are simply part of the problem.

Ailsa
South Africa
06/01/2009
Chux and David, Im horrified!
I am absolutely appalled at the lack of understanding and limited knowledge of people like Chux and David. Mugabe's people are starving, have no water, no medical care, are being killed and tortured if they protest... the list goes on. But you feel this is acceptable because he gave productive farms to his cronies who have no idea how to farm! If a man of Desmond Tutu's calibre recommends force as the only way to get rid of Mugabe then we have to trust that it is the last resort.

Patrick
South Africa
13/01/2009
Zimbabwe - shame on the world
Zimbabwe is a product of ignorant westerners. These same people wanted to get rid of the former Rhodesian government are now faced with the mess in Zimbabwe. South Africa will soon follow the same route. The former colonies, once returned to the ignorant, uneducated pheasant masses are doomed to failure from day 1. The value systems that African have ,differ from Wester values, they do not understand democracy but only tribalism and tyranny!

Vimbai
Zimbabwe
13/01/2009
Force doesnt help
I don't think removing Mugabe by force is the solution to Zimbabwe's problems. The talks were a good start but maybe both Mugabe and Tsvangirai should step aside in their parties. Christians are supposed to use peaceful means and Tutu already lacks credibility with most Africans. Zimbabwean youth are being disadvantaged by selfish politicians, its time for these politicians to see the big picture and let Zimbabwe prosper like she should.

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article
Aljazeera.net/english 2003 - 2010 ©
Designed & Developed by Aljazeera IT