UPDATED ON:
Monday, August 18, 2008
15:46 Mecca time, 12:46 GMT
 
News Americas
US blamed over S Ossetia crisis


The US has trained and equipped Georgian military forces [EPA]

The US has had stern words for Russia over its military intervention in Georgia to back South Ossietian separatists, but many analysts say that the Bush administration must share the blame for the crisis.

Washington has formed a close bond with the government of Mikheil Saakashvili since he came to power in the 2003 'Rose Revolution,' offering military and economic aid and encouraging Georgia to join Nato.

Jon Sawyer, the director for the Pulitzer Centre for Crisis Reporting, said US politicians had encouraged their Georgian counterparts to think they had the backing of the US when Tbilisi decided to launch its attack on South Ossetia last week.

"The US has for several years now mishandled the situation in Georgia," he told Al Jazeera.

"The way that Mikheil Saakashvili has approached this [has been by] thinking that he could be an extension of the west, a partner of the United States."

"In many ways we have given him cause for thinking that, with the many visits to the United States, the talk of Georgia as a beacon for democracy."

Charles Kupchan of the Council on Foreign Relations, agrees that US encouragement may have made Saakashvili "miscalculate" and send Georgian troops into South Ossetia.

"I think in many respects Saakashvili got too close to the United States and the United States got too close to Saakashvili," Kupchan told the Reuters news agency.

"It made him overreach, it made him feel at the end of the day that the West would come to his assistance if he got into trouble."

US backing

The statistics seem to back the view that Tbilisi felt itself under the protective wing of the Bush administration.

US and Georgian leaders have forged
a close relationship
As well as diplomatic encouragement, Saakashvili's government was offered both economic and military aid by Washington.

US special forces trained Georgian troops in 2002 to combat Chechen fighters in the Pankisi Gorge, which borders Chechnya, as part of the US "war on terror".

And Georgian forces continued to recieve training from the US as they prepared to send troops to Iraq, following the US-led invasion in 2003.

Washington gave $151 million to the Georgian government in security aid between 2004 and 2006.

Tbilisi has also benefited from the Millenium Challenge Corporation, a Bush administration programme intended to reward countries for "effective governance".

The corporation has signed agreements totaling $295 million, making Georgia the fourth-biggest recipient of funds.

Energy needs

The US may have welcomed Georgia as its key ally in the old Soviet Union's sphere of influence.

"By declaring the Caucasus, a region that is thousands of miles from the American continent, a sphere of its 'national interest,' the United States made a serious blunder."

Mikhail Gorbachev, former Soviet leader

But analysts point to the presence of key natural resources as a reason for the scale of US largesse.

The Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan (BTC) oil pipeline runs through Georgia, allowing the US access to oil and gas supplies not pumped through Russia to the north or Iran to the south.

"Underlying all this is a larger, more significant contest: a geopolitical struggle between Russia and the West over the export of Caspian Sea oil and natural gas," Michael Klare, the author of Resource Wars told the New American Media website.

"The United States seeks to use Georgia as an 'energy corridor' to transport Caspian energy to the West without going through Iran or Russia; to this end, it helped build the BTC pipeline across Georgia and helped beef up the Georgian military to protect it.

Kosovo connection

Other's believe that while Georgia have miscalculated the level of support it had from Washington, the US has also erred in thinking it could influence events so close to Russian borders.

Mikhail Gorbachev, the former leader of the old Soviet Union, said the US had made a "serious blunder" by allying itself so closely with Georgia.

"By declaring the Caucasus, a region that is thousands of miles from the American continent, a sphere of its 'national interest,' the United States made a serious blunder," Gorbachev said in an opinion piece to be published in the Washington Post US newspaper on Tuesday.

Other analysts say that US diplomats may have underestimated the level of anger the US recognition of Kosovo created in Moscow, leaving it fearful that Georgia would assert itself further in South Ossetia.

"The Kremlin made abundantly clear that it would view Kosovo's independence without Serbian consent and a UN Security Council mandate as a precedent for the two Georgian de facto independent enclaves," Dimitri Simes, the president of the Nixon Centre, wrote in a post on the Washington Note blog.

"Furthermore, while president Saakashvili was making obvious his ambition to reconquer Abkhazia and South Ossetia, Moscow was both publicly and privately warning that Georgia's use of force to re-establish control of the two regions would meet a tough Russian reaction, including, if needed, air strikes against Georgia proper."

 Source: Al Jazeera and agencies
 
Feedback Number of comments : 44
 
Alex Maher
Canada
16/08/2008
my compliments
finally some journalism on this issue, I just had to say nice work. Thanks for digging deeper than the US rhetoric continually pumping out of western news channels. Journalism should be reporting the bias of governments, not adopting them. Keep it up! I blogged a link to this article on CNN and Canada's CBC today as an example of real journalism. Alex

Alex
Australia
16/08/2008
US blamed over S Ossetia crisis
I am agree completely. That what US does, creates problems for whole world by supporting 'democratically' elected 'leaders'. These 'leaders' are shame for they own countries. I am disgusted.

C. Woodruff
Canada
17/08/2008
Conflict in Georgia
How convenient the West has forgotten that South Ossietia and Abkhazia were forced against their will to be part of Georgia by Joseph Stalin (himself a Georgian)when setting up the old USSR. The South Ossietians and Abkhazians are not ethnic Georgians. Furthermore, the Abkhazians are Muslims which has made them a target of Georgian Christian bigots.

Sarh
United States
17/08/2008
The American people have been brainwashed by their governmnet and media (which is owned by people who have huge influence in the government). I am american, and it makes me sick to see what is going on. Some of us do see around the lies, but we are still the minority. I have been ashamed of this country for a while now.

kaykay
Nigeria
17/08/2008
russia-Geotgia war
America is not bad in helping nations across the globe. But it hard more bad situations to killing innocent people. where was America when Russia was bulding Georgian nations. Now you are creating more enemity and havoc to that nation georgia. please the east bloc understand themselves than we think. NATO,USAIDS,WESTERN EUROPE SHOULD let Georgia sort themselves with Russia. Ukraine, Belarus, Pribaltic and all other C.I.S are should be more concerned not America. Bush should stop provoking tensions.

Max Gross
Australia
17/08/2008
Whats good for the goose
So when the US attacks ruined Iraq and ruined Afghanistan, on the other side of the planet, that's OK. But when Russia beats back a Georgian sneak attack, its not OK? Reality check for Bush: stay in your own backyard!

REGGIE WATSON
United States
17/08/2008
US INTERFERENCE IN RUSSIA AFFAIRS
Thanks for your true and responsible journalism in regards to the Georgia conflict. Again the US use another country (Georgia) for it's own personal gain in that region which would be for the natural gas/oil pipe line. Pure greed. The root of capitalism.

Amvet
Afghanistan
17/08/2008
Georgian attack in Ossetia
In the west, crimes committed by Georgia are not to be discussed. No mention of the piles of new US weapons captured by the Georians nor of Russians killed with US supplied weapons. Georgia is "good", Russia is "bad". The propaganda war continues. Amvet

Gordon Arnaut
Canada
17/08/2008
US Blamed Over South Ossetia Crisis
Good job Al Jazeera. This is actually a very mild critique of the one country in the world that is single-handedly responsible for 99 percent of humankind's suffering the monstrous empire USA. It is interesting to see comments from Americans that only prove they are completely brainwashed by the US media, leaving them unable to think for themselves. The American people unfortunately have not the slightest notion of the reality of what their evil empire is doing in the world.

Joe
United States
17/08/2008
Ossetia
In response to my fellow Americans' comments. The rest of the world sees us that way because our government has continually over thrown, installed, or "influenced" many countries governments where there is an economic interest. America uses the idea of exporting democracy along with many other forms of propaganda in hopes that most people won't seek the truth about what is actually occurring. We are constantly lied to about most things. Truth is ugly, calling people terrorists wont change that.

Robcph
United States
17/08/2008
Mikey doesnt like it?
Tough little boy,so you went to Iraq to fight in Bush's illegal invasion,and that somehow enables you to decide who should be in America?,maybe you should actually try reading that little document called the U.S. Constitution some time son, your gonna have to get past that America can do no wrong mantra,now go shine your lapel flag.

Antoine OhIcidhe
Australia
17/08/2008
Once more the forces of darkness, led by neo con political and even religious forces are working to undermine the peaceful peoples of our planet. As an atheist, I still say, may they rot in hell (if there be such a place)

Dave
Canada
17/08/2008
Mike from the U.S. states, "we stand up when everyone else backs down. Why is that? why does everyone run and leave when there is a problem in the world?" ...like Rwanda Mike? How the U.S. abandoned thoudands of genocide victims. Also, Mike states, "...if you hate us get out. we dont need you here." The old "get out" line. How about those people stay and help change the way you are? First witches, then Communists, then terrorists, now Russians. Who's the scapegoat next, Mike?

Wayne
Canada
17/08/2008
Georgian crisis
Really we the people are terrorists for condeming US for a made-in -hell foreign policy that sucks up to any region in the world that has any black fluid gushing up from the ground. It is time for US citizens to rethink their role in the world and fix their own problems and allow more peaceful nations to make progress

Richard
Canada
17/08/2008
Mike, I believe your opinions are sincere. The problem is that the US press is so utterly biased that Americans (like you) are getting a distorted view of world events. In Indo-China, Afghanistan and Iraq alone, the US has KILLED around FIVE million people - most of them non-combatants and now everybody asks "why did they do it?" and nobody really knows! Two words explain why USA is so reviled: "Foreign Policy".

Shenanigan
United States
17/08/2008
Georgia
This may have been the reason of Bush staying Drunk the whole time in China.He was thinking he might got WW3 on it way.But when you remember they never been a president from texas that can win a war,you got wonder why the American People stand for it. Poland Radar and missles back by the Man power of USA needs to make the statement than if Any inference into Russia internal affairs those sight will be knock out by russians missle if not by russia booms then they build theirs a short away

Just Pencil
India
17/08/2008
US interference in the Caucasus
Bush, his side kicks and the American people have the least privilege to cry foul on Russia. Think of the Iraqi children and women massacred by the US thugs (Read Army). Russia was just saving lives from an American stooge. America needs an occupation, Bush and his side kicks need death sentences. Thats Justice. An eye for an eye makes the world blind. But equal.

ali
United States
17/08/2008
love
o people of love and peace we need to understand each other and not let politician play games in our mind thinking.i would like to share with you guys one think that is whatever is going on is nothing else but bussiness and selffishness.isnt better as people american african arabian etc not let politician to play game with us and make us hate each other while they filling their pockets.again it is nothing else but self fishnes,so lets love eachother respect eachother and live peace together.

Peter Mathyssen
New Zealand (Aotearoa)
17/08/2008
Mike from US asks: Why do you people see us in the way that you do? Think about it. In the last 50 years, which country has been most often involved in wars, either directly or indirectly, has toppled democratically elected governments and supported despots who seized power through brute military force. As an Iraq vet you of all will know how US 'noble ideas' about democracy and freedom are delivered through the barrel of a gun. Millions have been killed..... Think about it. Face the facts.

Inga
Georgia
17/08/2008
getting involved in Georgia
What a shame for the US to get involved in another war problem . That Busch should stay out of the Georgian problem . Did he had the rights to evade Iraq ? What he things he is . Another Hitler ?

radii
Georgia
18/08/2008
Israel at the heart of this mess too!
Israel once again is at the heart of this mess. It is israel's control of the US policy-making and war-making that led to this needless war in Georgia. The israel-first neocons who control US politicians through donations and fear and who knows what else used their lobbyists to warp US self-interest into the massive blunder Gorbachev referenced. Israel's endless war strategy - using the US as its fool to do the dirty work - is still in the driver's seat and my country, the USA, is at risk now.

Deborah
United States
18/08/2008
US blamed over S. Ossetia crisis
One can tell by reading the feedbacks who has done more reading and who hasn't who believes these "wars" are over oil or who believes these "wars" are for "democracy." The US corporate press has said nothing about Sen. McCain's consultant being paid by Ossetia's government as an consultant nor Karl Rove's part in all of this .... Peace

Niyi Akinlabu
Nigeria
18/08/2008
The United States was admired by us all, a long time ago. We all loved the values and ideals that it stood for then. I am afraid that has all changed. In my lifetime, I have seen the world's perception change towards the US. It's not mine to pontificate over the effects that the actions and utterances of contemporary US leaders have had on the general view people hold of the great power. However, I must say that the waters of those lofty ideals have dried and have come to naught. Sadly so.

Victoria
Afghanistan
18/08/2008
US reaction of the invasion
How ironic, the Secretary of State and the White House up in arms vis a vis - Claiming that the Russian response was "overreaction" and "such force was not neccesary". I dont't recall when Isreal bombed Lebanon's airport, bridges and most infrastructures, including the dropping of cluster bombs "was over reaction". Victoria

Bill Reed
United States
18/08/2008
more nonsense as usual
So the US negotiates to do business with the sovreign nation of Georgia and Russians dont like it because they are getting cut out of the action. NewsFlash - Georgia is free to do business with whom ever they like same with Poland. And yet the US is to blame for Russians illegal invasion? The logic here at AJ is: Poitive article about US = Bias/lies and Negative article about US = honest journalism. Got it

Anonymous
Afghanistan
19/08/2008
Pretext for missile bases
THis is another US operation in disguise. This war was provoked by the US making Georgia proxy and escape goat. The main agenda for the US was to extend it's military hagemony and dominance over that regions which also has tremendous potential for natural resources and oil. I believe Russia has every right to defend and protect it's own interest as the US has- like the US talks or talked about the war in Iraq. I think we need Russia as superpower to counter balance monopoly of US dominance.

Balin
United States
19/08/2008
Hateful and Dishonest Forum
Al Qaeda declared war on the US because of her support for Israel & because we stationed troops in Saudi Arabia, at the Saudis request because they were scared sh*tless of Saddam's advancing army. After removing that threat, the US has given 4000+ young men & women in defense of a democracy struggling to take hold in the Middle East - a direct threat to the misogynistic and anti-semitic theocracies that rule the region. At the root of all of this is hate, jealousy, and religious intolerance.

Ben W
United States
19/08/2008
greed
its just funny to me that it all ways comes down to oil. all the fighitn the last for years in the US is oil. its sad

Robert Deslauriers
Canada
15/08/2008
Georgia
Does the US think it can meddle in Russia's zone of influence without consequences? Once again the US blows hard where it can't deliver. The US has long been a colonial power with it's mantra of democracy to try to hide it's intention to dominate. They will fail as others did. It appears their slide has already begun due to their vaunted globalization and corrupt capitalism.

jmain
United States
16/08/2008
blame and aid
Once again the US is blamed for an ethnic conflict or a land grab effort of a poor nation trying to assert itself upon the world...again. When we try to start dialogue with diplomacy, we are evil! Go home...stay away great satan. However, when there is a real need by some one downtrodden, and unable to fend for themselves, they say come.Humanitarian needs are met very quickly if allowed. I have seen and been a part of this. Keep the politics out..(read Putin...) We owe the world to try.

mike
United States
17/08/2008
I am an american. Why do you people see us in the way that you do? I am Iraq vet and yes maybe our country has made some mistakes but overall we just want peace for the U.S and the world. we stand up when everyone else backs down. Why is that? why does everyone run and leave when there is a problem in the world? And it sickens me that you people who are so called "americans'' and enjoy the freedom that we have talk crap... you are Terrorists !! if you hate us get out. we dont need you here.

Sally Anne Hamath
United Kingdom
17/08/2008
Bushs hidden agenda
The payback for Georgia for supporting Bush/Blair invasion of Iraq, was the military training, increased US Aid and the green light for admission into NATO. If Russia was to roll over and allow this unhindered at her backyard, then the next step would be a US military base. Anyway, I read reports of some Georgians wanting Russia's military presence to remain in order to deter other jingoistic Georgians rounding up able bodied youngsters to fight in their corner.

Rob
United States
17/08/2008
US blamed for Georgian Crisis
While I appreciate the service of the Iraq veteran, and all veterans, looking at the United States as the country that stands and fights, regardless as right or wrong, is destructive, and that's why we've completely destroyed the good will of the rest of the world. We armed the Saakashvili regime because of oil. They're not democratic. They started this whole thing. Thanks to Al Jazeera for publishing the first balanced piece I've seen on this conflcit.

Joshua
United States
17/08/2008
First, good work on the article. Second, to the "Americans" commenting, OPEN YOUR EYES!! Not only is "our" government destroying (not creating, nor trying to create) peace around the world, they are doing it to us, their "own" people. Terrorists?!? Watch lists, inflation, elimination of our civil rights. The creators of these are the true terrorists, along with the Nazis telling people who don't think like them to get out. Drop food, not bombs, then the world might believe you. Read some history

richard young
United States
17/08/2008
American peace through wars
Like Mike I am an American and a war veteran (Korean War). I am not a "terrorist" and am not about to leave my country because I choose to criticize it for engaging in criminal wars of aggression in Iraq and other places. To those Americans who think that all our Government seeks is peace for the world, I suggest they read the latest (2006) update of our Government's official National Security Policy outlining our national program for ruling the world by military force. Read it.

mohammed seif
Tanzania
17/08/2008
US is to blame
yes i agree with mike the americans stands to fight when everybody else backs down,but those who backs down are wise! see what they did in iraq and afghanistan,more paople have been killed because of american "stand up" then during the saddam and taliban era. now they put their nose in georgia and cause some stirrup and leave it to defend by itself!

Roger Lafontaine
United States
17/08/2008
US blamed for S Ossetia crisis
Georgia found out the hard way that it is not Israel. There is only one Israel that can do anything it likes and get complete and unadulterated backing of US. There is no Armageddon theology about Georgia that will incite a war of total destruction/self-destruction. The end they wish for is yet to come.

Mazen El-Khairy
Canada
17/08/2008
Georgia
I have noticed that, as usual, 'Ignorance' mixed with 'Arrogance' is what marks the comments of those who support the USA in whatever it does. Wake up people, the USA is an imperial power with all the trimmings that come with it!!

cml
United States
17/08/2008
Georgian mess
Of course we have made things worse in this region of the world by our support of the Georgian gov't. As an American I continue to be sickened and dismayed by our country's attitude, as expressed in the last two blogs. We need not be in Iraq nor in Georgia and wouldn't if it weren't for the oil. As long as we Americans assume our way of life is non-negotiable and that we are the greatest country in the world, the rest of the world will suffer. Maybe Mr. Obama will bring a little sanity to us

Firefighter
United States
17/08/2008
Robert #4
Well Bob maybe the world could suckle on the Canadian national nipple for awhile. I mean after all the Canadian compassion for whats happening in Georgia right now IS all over the news.

Andy
New Zealand (Aotearoa)
18/08/2008
U.S. Foreign Policy
Excellent, fair journalism once again! In Rockefeller's day the U.S. produced 100% of its own oil. Today it imports 75% of its oil needs. America is sick sick with basing its entire happy motoring suburbs and manufacturing upon fossil fuels and at current rates of oil consumption, the world will run out of the black stuff 35 years from now. This fact is at the core of nearly everything the U.S. does. You're American and can't understand the antagonism? Review U.S. Foreign Policy.

Jnaylor
United States
18/08/2008
Georgia
The Russian army is doing what it does best, surpressing non-russians who do not tow the Moscow line. The Geogians are at fault here, not the US. If they thought we would come to there rescue after invading Ossetia, or pat them on the head and say good job they were wrong! The people of S.O. should have been left alone end of story. That said the Russians over reacted, but when you have a country run by a KGB thug what do you expect.

monalisa
Canada
18/08/2008
US blamed over Ossetia crisis
So, because the US is friendly with a country, it gets blamed for starting aggression?? If we can recall that the UK and US gave western Europe back to the Europeans and Russia kept all the eastern parts and created the Soviet Union. Putin is pulling the strings to make Russia 'great' again. Sure the US isn't perfect, but it seems there's always many people that want to go and live there. When there's a crisis, everyone looks to the US to help. I'm happy they're our neighbour!

Eliot Mowa
Namibia
18/08/2008
Georgia
America could be blamed,but i think at the end of the day we need to keep in mind that Russia wants to stretch its wings in eastern Europe.Watch out.!

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article