UPDATED ON:
Friday, August 08, 2008
03:55 Mecca time, 00:55 GMT
 
News Americas
US state executes Mexican convict

The US Supreme Court rejected Medellin's last ditch appeal [AFP]

The US state of Texas has defied the International Court of Justice and executed a Mexican prisoner convicted of murder.

Jose Medellin, 33, was executed by lethal injection on Tuesday and pronounced dead at 9:57pm (02:57 GMT on Wednesday), the Texas Department of Criminal Justice said.

His execution came after the US Supreme Court rejected his final appeal on Tuesday night.

Medellin was convicted for his part in the gang rape, beating and strangling death of two teenage girls 15 years ago.

Ban Ki-moon, the UN secretary general, had called on the US to abide by an International Court of Justice (ICJ) ruling to stay Medellin's execution.

The ICJ had said that Medellin and about 50 other Mexicans on death row in the US should have new hearings to determine whether the Vienna Conventions were violated during their arrests.

Medellin's lawyers said he was denied access to Mexican consular officials during his arrest, a key part of the conventions

He was the first among the 50 to be executed.

Protest warning

Medellin is set to be executed on Tuesday [AFP]
The US embassy in Mexico ha warned of potential protests there if the execution took place.

Jorge Montano, a former Mexican ambassador to the US, told Al Jazeera that the US should respect international law.

"The biggest lesson once again for the rest of the world, the US is not prepared to respect any ruling when that ruling is not in their favour and that, for me, is like the law of the jungle once again. If we don't respect the international legislation, then how can we ask other countries to do so?"

George Bush, the US president, has asked states to review the cases affected by the ruling, but the US Supreme Court ruled earlier this year that neither the president nor the international court can force the Texan state government's hand.

David Fathi, the US programme director from the Human Rights Watch group, told Al Jazeera that the decision to go ahead with the execution had grave implications for US citizens possibly facing execution abroad.

The US would find it difficult to say other countries should honour their obligations not to execute US citizens when the US has itself violated international law, he said.

Brutal attack

Medellin was the fifth Texas inmate to be executed this year.

Trial testimony showed Medellin was the first of six members of a street gang to attack the girls when the incident took place in 1993. 

Sixteen year old Elizabeth Pena and 14-year-old Jennifer Ertman were taking a shortcut home across a railway bridge in Houston, Texas.

The gang attacked the girls for an hour before strangling them and leaving their bodies to decompose in a field.

 Source: Al Jazeera and agencies
Feedback Number of comments : 12
 
John Gere
Canada
06/08/2008
An Extreme Situation
You could hardly invent a more extreme test of ethics or jurisdiction than this. It will be impossible to satisfy every person's opinion. (Lethal injection seems too pleasant.) But if you let the case be argued philosophically, I think the only way out would be to go back and re-write the international law. A law or a ruling is tested by its practicability. This one clearly needs work, because, in a case like this, the theoretical wisdom is too far from the immediate reality of the crime.

john mcquire
Australia
06/08/2008
us executes mexican convict
ladylpnsman should remember george bush didn't listen to the U.N before he invaded Iraq, but soon as things got tough he soon invited the organization to get involved.as a people you can't choose when to listen and when not to the advise of this world body

James
Canada
06/08/2008
Executing Mexican Convict
Why not keep the prisoner alive but harvest his kidney's and other parts for transplants? Seems that would be fitter outcome than just executing him.

julle
Sweden
06/08/2008
Hi Mrs ladylpnsman! You seem to think, that the USA are not part of this world. Maybe you are right. Kick the USA out of the UN. They think they can do whatever they want, whereever they want, as also the case of Siddiqui shows. Not to mention Guantanamo. When will all the thousands of US war criminals roaming the world brought to justice?

boyprophet
United States
06/08/2008
I am amazed at the ignorance displayed by some of the persons quoted in this article (such as Ban and Fathi ). In fact, it strains credulity to think that they are so igonorant of American federal system that they can even make such statements with a straight face (but then that is what people with a political agenda tend to do because their primary credo is that the means justify the ends). The "US" did not execute anyone - the State of Texas did.

MariaV
United States
06/08/2008
Letal injection
The execution of law brakers here in the USA would make it probable that some USA citizens traveling abroad would come to the same demise, if they broke a law that calls for death of a citizen in that country, so be it. LEARN the laws where you travel, and this was a crime worth the punishment this animal got. In another country he would not have sat pretty for as long as he did in a safe prison. Mexican prisioners would have long ago delievered him feet first out of jail.

ladylpnsman
United States
05/08/2008
Texas execution
We are not the United states of the world, we are the United States of America. Ban, and all his pals need to give it to some one who cares, cause real Americans aint gonna take it from him or any other globalist. The prisoner is a murder and he's going to pay for his crimes.

Neil Hoskins
United Kingdom
06/08/2008
@ladylpnsman
I respect your opinion. However, if that's the case, then please keep your armies within your own borders like you used to in the days of "laissez faire".

TR
United States
06/08/2008
We the americans need to get off our high horse and respect these laws... how can we relay on a social construct (such as these interntional laws) when we don't support them through action and precedent... this death just made it that much more likly that we will be denied our rights abroad.. way to go supreme court!

Tom
Afghanistan
06/08/2008
what did you expect ??
“Attacked them for an hour”??? That’s mild. They beat them for an hour while taking turns raping them. Finally they strangled the girls with shoe laces. They were 14 and 16 years – their crime??? Being in the wrong place at the wrong time. Iran would’ve hung him years ago. No sympathy

james carter
United States
06/08/2008
medelline
Bush administration was the worst regime in the world.since bush step on power, nothing good has ever happen. is all killing and war.

Wayne Vokovich
United States
07/08/2008
What about the victims?
While Medellin enjoyed the full services of the U.S. legal system, the victims remained dead and buried. While George Bush pushed for a review of the case at the behest of the UN, the victim's families were without their loved ones. Medellin was a criminal and a murderer. He was in the U.S. illegally, and committed the worst possible crimes against two innocent, helpless children. These were crimes against humanity. What resonable person or countryman wouldn't cry out for justice!

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article