UPDATED ON:
Saturday, September 13, 2008
07:14 Mecca time, 04:14 GMT
 
News Americas
US 'in need of rebellion'

Has the US been irretrievably damaged in the eyes of the world? [GALLO/GETTY]

 

Al Jazeera speaks to Howard Zinn, the author, American historian, social critic and activist, about how the Iraq war damaged attitudes towards the US and why the US "empire" is close to collapse.

 

Q: Where is the United States heading in terms of world power and influence?

HZ: America has been heading - for some time, and is heading right now - toward less and less world power, less and less influence.

In focus

In-depth coverage of the US election
Obviously, since the war in Iraq, the rest of the world has fallen away from the United States, and if American foreign policy continues in the way it has been - that is aggressive and violent and uncaring about the feelings and thoughts of other people - then the influence of the United States is going to decline more and more.

This is an empire which is on the one hand the most powerful empire that ever existed; on the other hand an empire that is crumbling - an empire that has no future ... because the rest of the world is alienated and simply because this empire is top-heavy with military commitments, with bases around the world, with the exhaustion of its own resources at home.

[This is] leading to more and more discontent at home, so I think the American empire will go the way of other empires and I think it is on its way now.

Q: Is there any hope the US will change its approach to the rest of the world?

HZ: If there is any hope, the hope lies in the American people.

Zinn says the US needs a new
popular movement [AFP]
[It] lies in American people becoming resentful enough and indignant enough over what has happened to their country, over the loss of dignity in the world, over the starving of human resources in the United States, the starving of education and health, the takeover of the political mechanism by corporate power and the result this has on the everyday lives of the American people.

[There is also] the higher and higher food prices, the more and more insecurity, the sending of the young people to war.

I think all of this may very well build up into a movement of rebellion.

We have seen movements of rebellion in the past: The labour movement, the civil rights movement, the movement against the war in Vietnam.

I think we may well see, if the United States keeps heading in the same direction, a new popular movement. That is the only hope for the United States.

Q: How did the US get to this point?

HZ: Well, we got to this point because ... I suppose the American people have allowed it to get it to this point because there were enough Americans who were satisfied with their lives, just enough.

Of course, many Americans were not, that is why half of the population doesn't vote, they're alienated.

But there are just enough Americans who have been satisfied, you might say getting some of the "goodies" of the empire, just some of them, just enough people satisfied to support the system, so we got this way because of the ability of the system to maintain itself by satisfying just enough of the population to keep its legitimacy.

And I think that era is coming to an end.

Q: What should the world know about the United States?

HZ: What I find many people in the rest of the world don't know is that there is an opposition in the United States.

Zinn says "corruption" of the US
system enabled Bush to win office [EPA]
Very often, people in the rest of the world think that Bush is popular, they think 'oh, he was elected twice', they don't understand the corruption of the American political system which enabled Bush to win twice.

They don't understand the basic undemocratic nature of the American political system in which all power is concentrated within two parties which are not very far from one another and people cannot easily tell the difference.

So I think we are in a situation where we are going to need some very fundamental changes in American society if the American people are going to be finally satisfied with the kind of society we have.

Q: Do you think the US can recover from its current position?

HZ: Well, I am hoping for a recovery process. I mean, so far we haven't seen it.

You asked about what the people of the rest of the world don't know about the United States, and as I said, they don't know that there is an opposition.

"We have a long history in this country of violent expansion and I think not only do most people in other countries [not] know this, most Americans don't."

Howard Zinn

There always has been an opposition, but the opposition has always been either crushed or quieted, kept in the shadows, marginalised so their voices are not heard.

People in the rest of the world hear the voices of the American leaders.

They do not hear the voices of the people all over this country who do not like the American leaders who want different policies.

I think also, people in the rest of the world should know that what they see in Iraq now is really a continuation of a long, long term of American imperial expansion in the world.

I think ... a lot of people in the world think that this war in Iraq is an aberration, that before this the United States was a benign power.

It has never been a benign power, from the very first, from the American Revolution, from the taking-over of Indian land, from the Mexican war, the Spanish-American war.

It is embarrassing to say, but we have a long history in this country of violent expansion and I think not only do most people in other countries [not] know this, most Americans don't know this. 

Q: Is there a way for this to improve?

HZ: Well you know, whatever hope there is lies in that large number of Americans who are decent, who don't want to go to war, who don't want to kill other people.

It is hard to see that hope because these Americans who feel that way have been shut out of the communications system, so their voices are not heard, they are not seen on the television screen, but they exist.

I have gone through, in my life, a number of social movements and I have seen how at the very beginning of these social movements or just before these social movements develop, there didn't seem to be any hope.

I lived in the [US] south for seven years, in the years of the civil rights movements, and it didn't seem that there was any hope, but there was hope under the surface.

And when people organised, and when people began to act, when people began to work together, people began to take risks, people began to oppose the establishment, people began to commit civil disobedience.

Well, then that hope became manifest ... it actually turned into change.

Q: Do you think there is a way out of this and for the future influence of the US on the world to be a positive one?

HZ: Well, you know for the United States to begin to be a positive influence in the world we are going to have to have a new political leadership that is sensitive to the needs of the American people, and those needs do not include war and aggression.

[It must also be] sensitive to the needs of people in other parts of the world, sensitive enough to know that American resources, instead of being devoted to war, should be devoted to helping people who are suffering.

You've got earthquakes and natural disasters all over the world, but the people in the United States have been in the same position as people in other countries.

The natural disasters here [also] brought little positive reaction - look at [Hurricane] Katrina.

The people in this country, the poor people especially and the people of colour especially, have been as much victims of American power as people in other countries.

Q: Can you give us an overall scope of everything we talked about – the power and influence of the United States?

"Ultimately power rests on the moral legitimacy of a system and the United States has been losing moral legitimacy."

Howard Zinn

HZ: The power and influence of the United States has declined rapidly since the war in Iraq because American power, as it has been exercised in the world historically, has been exposed more to the rest of the world in this situation and in other situations.

So the US influence is declining, its power is declining.

However strong a military machine it is, power does not ultimately depend on a military machine. So power is declining.

Ultimately power rests on the moral legitimacy of a system and the United States has been losing moral legitimacy.

My hope is that the American people will rouse themselves and change this situation, for the benefit of themselves and for the benefit of the rest of the world.

 Source: Al Jazeera
 
Feedback Number of comments : 50
 
Shafiq
Bangladesh
08/09/2008
US empire facing collapse
I agree 100% with Howard Zinn. Whilst the US preaches freedom and democracy to the rest of the world voices of dissent within the US are silenced, marginalised and declared unpatriotic. Opposition to the aggressive US foreign policies needs to be mobilised and people have to say that enough is enough. The US has lost all credibility on the world stage and has no moral standing anymore. The empire has fallen.

Amelia
Afghanistan
08/09/2008
Howard Zinn article
I met with Mr.Zinn twice,and both times he told me to be patient and to hope for a better future. I am glad that now he does not see any other solution than the uprising of the people.

chris
United States
09/09/2008
good article
I liked this article. The US had a chance to show the world freedom and generosity when it was formed. It did not because of one word- greed. It's constant desire to be at the top has turned it heading toward the bottom. Because of a lack of care for others and selfish greed it has nothing. It is Divine law. For the sake of the US, I hope Obama wins. If McCain wins we may see a civil war again in the future and complete cut off from every nation.

Ian Lawson
Australia
09/09/2008
America needs a rebellion
One of the best reports I have seen for a very long time. How do we make it happen?

adam
United States
09/09/2008
While there may be some people who would agree with this author saying the US is in need of rebellion. If these are Americans then I am weary of the future. People of this opinion shouldn't wish things like this. Look at Iraq we do not want that hardship placed on our homes and faimlys. Rebelllion means death, it means a very, very hard life. If something like that would happen thoes same people would long for the peace we once had... Bush or not. No rebellion, no no no!

Chris
United States
09/09/2008
US NEEDS Rebellion
I agree the US needs a rebellion as per the Declaration of Independence. But I have seen so vanishingly few who are willing to even SEE the disaster we are causing, for example the horrors of depleted uranium being intentionally spread over entire countries. WE BETTER GET GOING SOON.

mike
United States
09/09/2008
US
Half the empires in the modern world would have fallen by now if the US didnt step in.He talks about how the US doesnt give aid to any country, how we just want to impose war. BULL@%$! The US is the only country that always stands up when another country needs humanitarian aid. I have never seen any country ever give aid to the US a natural disaster. He wants to talk about Katrina, what country stepped in to lend a hand with any cleanup or aid? None because they only worry about themselves.

Fred
New Zealand (Aotearoa)
09/09/2008
Much in agreement
Much in agreement with what he said, especially that there is opposition. Before this year with the whole Obama - McCain thing I thought most Americans either didn't know what they do or just are selfish enough to support what they do. However the amount of people supporting Obama changes my view, it shows the American people's desire of change.

Mike
United States
09/09/2008
HZ,I beleive you are spot on. I think that we as a nation should pay attention to matters at home. Feed our hungry, house our homeless, better our own society. I don't think that America can buy, admiration and respect through donating money,aid, and know how to foreign countries. I think our whole Political system is fundamentally flawed. Everytime they attack, support or send aid to another country it cost tax-payers dollars.

Robert
United States
09/09/2008
Funny
Revolt in the US is nothing but a fantasy in the mind of closet Socialist.

Ahmad R.S.Ringim
Nigeria
09/09/2008
Global Voices
I find aljazeera the only media outlet that brings you something u ll never find or know from the other media stations. To me, reading peoples feedback [Americans especially] really stream out their voices and opinion on the acts of their government.

Daftjack
South Africa
09/09/2008
Howard Zinn
The article was spot on. America is not nor will it ever be 'Democratic' election 2000 proved that. It is run by the Military Industrial complex and without war in the World, America could not exist. It is no coincidence America is the BIGGEST supplier of military hardware in the World.

Darren
Canada
09/09/2008
US in need of rebellion
Over the last number of years I have formed the opinion that the US has become that which it has most feared, A super-power that imposes it's will on other countries based on what they feel is right, and then dictating to other countries whether or not they can deal with the original country in question. Too many people the world over (in countries AT LEAST as democratic as the US, if not more so) the popular opinion is 'yes' the US has lost it's credibility as a 'bastion of freedom' Go Obama!

Virginia Gentleman
United States
09/09/2008
Howard Zinn
Mr. Zinn is obviously unhappy in the United States. I recommend that he hie himself to a country more amenable to his point of view, say Sweden that will applaud his socialism or Rwanda that will embrace his desire for revolution.

workneh
Afghanistan
09/09/2008
I feel that the good ideals of the American democracy have been hijacked and abused by the political system manuevered by the gaint economic powers that pushed aside the working mass. This arrogance is manifested in all corners of the world, where the US intervenes uninvited by the respective peoples. The US intervention, very often than not, goes to the extent of installing, propping up, and arming dispots at the price of the suffering of the host mass. Yes the fall of the US empire is near.

Mike Hopper
United States
09/09/2008
Howard Zinn Article
I tend to agree with Howard. The problems with most governments is that the individuals who rise to positions of power are those willing to use any means to attain and hold it. These are not people who are likely to make sane decisions, nor care particularly for the welfare of others, in their own country or in the world at large.

Greg
United States
09/09/2008
Howard Zinn
For those of you further up on the discussion board that said a rebellion would be a bad idea, Zinn never meant violent rebellion. True Americans don't dissent in such a barbaric way. I think Zinn is right, in order to bring about the CORRECT change, we must first come to terms with and accept that historically, American expansion has been brutal and unfair to those on the receiving end. There is nothing wrong with admitting this, it is simply one of many steps forward that we must make.

Timothy
United States
09/09/2008
Obama is not revolution
I love reading comments from readers both in the US and elsewhere who believe that Obama will restore America's dignity. Check his voting record. When he bothers to vote, he votes virtually the same as McCain. Obama and McCain are both terrible candidates neither will bring about anything significant in their presidencies.

Alex
United States
09/09/2008
Rebellion
I agree with Mr. Zinn. For far too long the United States has been corrupt with politics that "smell alike, but look different." You have to hand it to the powers that be, they are experts at crushing those who oppose their agenda. Free speach is dead in this country and is maintained only by the interests who control the US media. We need to have a major player in a 3rd political party. Unfortunately the system will not allow for a serious 3rd party challenger.

David in NY
United States
09/09/2008
Shouldnt he be playing shuffleboard in Boca
He is not a closet socialist, he is an overt Marxist. One of the dominant themes in his writings is class struggle. There will never be this "rebellion" in the US that he so salivates over because the far majority enjoy freedoms and liberties that others in the world can only dream about. 100 years from now people like him will still be talking about the imminent demise of the U.S.

don
United States
09/09/2008
HZ
He's an excellent author with some compelling viewpoints but sadly, he voices some misinformation...the US is without doubt one of the largest sources of monetary aid the world will ever see. Who fed Russia in the 70's when their economy wouldn't allow them to feed themselves? The US. Who sends more aid money to Egypt than Israel? The US. Who first on the scene when the tsunami hit Indonesia? The US. Who saved the world from both facism and communism? The US. This is a great country.

John DAmico
United States
09/09/2008
US in need of rebellion
Many of us here in this country believe in the principles on which this country was founded and still practice them. As such many of us are appalled at the direction Bush and his cronies have taken the United States. If 911 was his justification for the war in Iraq, he most certainly picked the wrong target. This debacle will certainly go down in history as one of the most ill thought out and deceptive operations in the history of our country. And we deserve better than Obama/ McCain.

Laurie Plant
Australia
09/09/2008
Global, not local, revolution
Zinn raises some interesting points, notably regarding the illusion of democracy - we have the same lack of choice in Australia. Voting every four years between two essentially like paties gives the public very little 'democratic' control of their politics. However, notions of social revolution are antiquated there will be a revolution, but it will be in the form of a new equitable world order: as more countries such as China, Russia and India rise to prominence, the US will accomodate them

dipsy
Afghanistan
10/09/2008
Any rebellion in the United States will be met by swift retribution. We have seen this at the RNC where reporters filming police beating demonstrators were arrested. Houses were raided by the police before the election as a precaution against rebellion. Believe me, as soon as the US left wing begins to take up arms, you will see how fast the Right changes its attitude towards gun control. No chance for rebellion in the US. Stop your dreaming. The sixties are over. Big Brother rules!

Harvey
Canada
10/09/2008
HZs optimism
I agree with Mr. Zinn's views on the state of the U.S and its reputation, but I fear that his optimism about a rebellion is a dubious hope. The responses from those who vociferously disagree (or simply condemn him) are probably more typical of American views than are those who agree with him. That CNN and the like are the major news suppliers fo Americans, that the theologically illiterate fundamentalists exert so much political, religious and moral influence, etc. gives little basis for hope.

jerry
United States
10/09/2008
Zinn
Holy cow! The Marshall Plan, Japan's restoration. Saved Russia's butt with aid. Money for friendship to half the countries of the middle east. Humanitarian aid to everyone. We should bring our troops home from everywhere and let the world castrate itself. Our system is far from perfectbut there isn't another that even comes close. Take a hike, Zinn

jtr32533
United States
10/09/2008
Rebellion in U.S. is Patriotic
Read anything about the founders of our country and they will tell you that questioning authority is the highest form of american freedom. Our founders warned us about blind allegiance and false patriotism.Do a little reading. Also, HZ didnt mention Viet Nam.Our government advised, then interfered, then took over the war.Eventually AMERICANS didn't stand for more. Americans WILL revolt to save our Country and Freedoms. Soon enough? How long since Floridas vote has counted?

Yaylong
United States
10/09/2008
Howard Zinn
Mr. Zinn said it. The man has the hindsight of a historian and, therefore, the legitimacy to speak about American society to with it. History is something we lack among our ranks as citizens, and something that should be stressed more. As for people calling him a "socialist". You guys serious? That Cold War mentality should be discarded get with the times. Plus, the man is speaking of a rebellion in terms of the mind and social awareness (our classic American trend), not armed revolt.

Ayub
Afghanistan
10/09/2008
Howard Zinn on US imperialism.
Hey Mike:cuba wanted to help and the idiot Bush refused,VeneZuela helped by giving the US free oil i believe.For your information the US consumes most of the resources at dirt cheap prices because of subsidizing farms across the globe.Look at all the fat people in the US.57% of the US is fat or obese,if they were to eat less maybe there might have been some food for Katrina victims.Also keep in mind that the US is in Iraq to steal oil.Give respect to Mr.Zinn he is right.Your'e a moron like Bush.

Chris
Afghanistan
10/09/2008
Howard Zinn
Let me put this in a simple way: Howard Zinn hates America. He is a wacky Left Wing Extremist with a very distorted view of our history. He should go back to school and learn how to be a proper American.

George
United States
10/09/2008
"We must not confuse dissent with disloyalty. When the loyal opposition dies, I think the soul of America dies with it" Edward R. Murrow
that guy Robert can call anyone a 'closet socialist' he wants, but is there any EDUCATED American citizen that can say they've been proud of their country in the past 8 years? as for the guy from Virgina..that's the kind of people that give the United States a bad name. Offering anyone to leave that critiques the nation too much I still have hope, probably until the bitter end simply because starting over would be an incredibly difficult task

aaron
United States
10/09/2008
Mike: Humanitarian Aid
Just to clear up Mike's idea that no other country sent aid to the U.S. after Hurricane Katrina. Mexico sent aid in September 2005. This can be confirmed on main stream media web sites and even wikipedia. Also, Venezuela provided millions of dollars in aid to the U.S. post Katrina. I confirmed this on globalsecurity.org and other web sites. The problem with rebellion in the U.S. is that there are still enough people like Mike who support the current system (as Zinn tried to point out).

Paul Wright
United States
10/09/2008
US In need of rebellion
I lived in Florida many years ago and travelled around the country. Lovely friendly, warm , generous people. What a shame to see despicable characters like Bush, Cheney and too many others to mention , controlling that beautiful country. My message to ALL AMERICANS.........( FOR CHRIST`S SAKE GET OUT THERE AND VOTE).

heather
United States
10/09/2008
Howard Zinn is right...
It's a shame that the US is now a plutocracy/theocracy, profoundly under the influence of "bread & circuses", i.e. the proliferation of cheap, non-nutritious food, mind-numbing prescription medication, religion & empty, non-thought provoking entertainment. We are fat, drugged & unaware of the world just beyond our borders. This is exactly what the corporations who control policy in this country desire, for who would "rebel" under such conditions. History shows us we will fail, unless we change.

Aaron Vlek
United States
10/09/2008
Rebellion?
The landslide fascination and love affair that the US is currently enjoying with Sarah Palin should illustrate the kind of revolution they want. The world should be very afraid, as are many Americans.

Kathy
United States
10/09/2008
Go, Howard!
One of the few political figures in the US who SHOULD be listened to with much care. I'm afraid I believe most Americans too complacent and, yes, too stupid to pull themselves out of this hole, be the country and people they should be. Thanks, Aljazeera, for this interview.

John Simon
Uganda
10/09/2008
HOWARD ZINN ARTICAL
Big Al jazeera for posting such a powerful article. Howard you hit the nail on the head and that only happens for those Americans who love their nation. Americas foreign policy needs a check. Showing off there miltary power and responding to any threat by use of miltary will make the World hate the more. Change for the better, go Obama.

raylan
United States
10/09/2008
US in need of more articles like from Howard Zinn
I was just in first grade when in November of that fatefull day in 1963 a television was wheeled into our classroom . President John Kennedy dad been assassinated. George Bush,Lyndon Johnson,Watergate,Billie Sol Estes,Dr. Mengele,Curt Kobain are all names and events that tied into said assassination one way or another. Some might say the US is nothing more than a banana republic and that was driven home when Powers That Be determined that Kennedy needed to die. I am just a rat in a cage

Paul
Netherlands
10/09/2008
Change is needed
Revolution is a feature of history because power concedes nothing without a struggle.peaceful or otherwise. I am a USMC(grunt)Vietnam vet I volunteered twice.Bush&Cheney are war criminals! They talk tough as long as others are bleeding&dying!In the 1930's Maj.Gen.Smedley Butler(see:War is a Racket) said 'See that no American boy dies for an oil well in Iraq.' In 1967 Martin Luther King said 'the greatest purveyor of violence today is the government of my country'. It is worse today

Al
United States
10/09/2008
Nah.
This is but one opinion in the arena of a thousand. Just because this man is an historian does'nt mean that he shares the views of the majority of Americans. Quite the contrary. Professional American academics tend to lack a true grasp of reality. They'll always have followers due to the way the American public university works. People that lock themselves in a college campus for 30 years rarely have their opinions or beliefs truly challenged because they are the boss in their community.

Ayub
Afghanistan
10/09/2008
Howard Zinn.
HZ is accurate in his assessment of the US in it's greed for blood and expansionism starting with the civilwar,murdering the natives,mexican war,spanish war,vietnam,central America,Korea,Japan,Iraq,Afghanistan the list goes on,i wonder who's next. Don,you are wrong and you have a false sense of patriotism,true Americans don't think like you do,the educated and the one's who care do not want war and invasions.FYI,Saudi Arabia were the first to help the tsunami disaster efforts.

TX Truth
United States
10/09/2008
National Elections a Farce
Mr. Cary, If you think our National Elections are the solution, please do the research. The elections are corrupt. The voting machines are rigged and the chain of custody of the paper counts is a joke. I invite you to research blackboxvoting dot org and see what is really going on behind the scenes. In my opinion, the elections have already been decided. It's like going to Vegas...you keep pulling the lever hoping to win but your gut tells you it's all rigged.

Julian in FL
United States
10/09/2008
US in need of rebellion
I agree with Zinn apathy has prevented Americans from truly making change. A segment of the U.S. populus is satisfied with the status quo, and they have to be awakened by a serious crisis. David in NY: Class struggle is a human concern no matter what sort of sociopolitical "-ism" we subscribe to. Scarcity is a real problem and as history has proven, there will be people who are priviledged and those who are not priviledged and aspire to be so. Expect friction between the two...

Eva
United States
10/09/2008
Zinn and Revolution
We in the USA certainly do need a revolution of VALUES. We are ignorant of our government's interference in the rights to self determination in our counter and in others. A look at the textbooks used in teaching History in our public school system will confirm this. Our continued Why Does the Rest of the World Hate Us? Mentality reveals just how out of touch way too many Americans are with their own history and how the global economic-political machine operates. Time for IDEALS to become REAL.

Evens
United States
10/09/2008
Babylon The Great Is Falling
Falling empires is a fact of life. From Atlantis to Egypt to Babylon, Greek and Rome. Egypt lasted for thousands of years as a world power. The U.S. is barely 230yrs old and the writing is already on the wall. I hope for the best but am prepared for the worst, history tends to repeat itself. I consider myself a world citizen and as a black man currently residing in the States I've learn to adapt.

JaneY
Afghanistan
10/09/2008
Katrina-others offered US aid
Other nations did offer help in the wake of Hurricane Katrina. Bush just rejected them. Cuba, particularly, offered to send doctors, medical, & other material aid. I couldn't let Mike-USA's claim stand: "what country stepped in to lend a hand with any cleanup or aid [after Katrina]? None because they only worry about themselves." We could still learn from Cuba's superb hurricane readiness program, which puts even our improved chaos to shame.

Yuri
Canada
10/09/2008
Imperialism
Although it is a popular nowadays to take jabs at the American Empire, we must not forget that the American Empire is only a symbol. It is a symbol for all the empires that must be combated, if we are to hope for a peaceful and just future someday. It doesn't matter whether it's British, French, Russian, Chinese or American empires. Empires must come down. Imperialism must come down. One big mistake that can always be made is to allow one empire to take the place of another.

Mike
United States
10/09/2008
There are those of us here in the US that have been waiting and praying for this exact situation. I think most of us are ready to do what it takes... whatever it takes.

mike
United States
10/09/2008
Howard Zinn doesnt believe in America?
"in the US we have something better than than a rebellion. We have a national election." -no the national elections isnt "better" then rebellion. Rebellion is a CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT, making it just as important "Zinn just doesn't get it because he doesn't like the idea of the United States and anything it does." -Howard Zinn is a true American. He served his country in WWII, then he saw problems and voiced dissent. He is a TRUE patriot.

Jim
United States
10/09/2008
US needs rebellion
I agree with the thrust of the article. Unfortunately, Americans are not likely to "rebel" because they are a part of the system which Howard Zinn is describing and unless there is something like a general economic catastrophe in the U.S. there is so much reticence to rock the boat little substantive change will take place. The U.S., like most empires of history, will likely continue in decline until a stronger power emerges. With global investments the privileged will remain financially so.

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article