UPDATED ON:
Monday, September 15, 2008
21:22 Mecca time, 18:22 GMT
 
News Americas
US election diary: Stupid season
Has the Republican campaign stuck strictly to the facts this week? [AFP]

In the time honoured tradition of presidential campaigns, both John McCain and Barack Obama proclaimed early on that their efforts to convince voters to give them the keys to the White House would be all about real, nitty-gritty issues, like the economy, the wars the US is fighting, and how to remedy the failed healthcare system.

And, in an equally time-honoured tradition, both campaigns have tossed the issues aside to get into truly idiotic political territory, all about pigs, lipstick, and Rubiks cubes.

First came the McCain camp's feigned high indignation over Obama's comment that saying the McCain economic plan was new was like "putting lipstick on a pig."

McCain operatives immediately screamed that Obama had made a nasty, sexist insult directed at Sarah Palin, because Palin joked in her Republican convention speech that the difference between 'hockey moms' like herself and pitbulls (not a bull, actually, but a kind of nasty attack dog) was 'lipstick'.

In focus

In-depth coverage of the US presidential election
The mainstream news media immediately bought into this manufactured controversy, and began showing video snippets of McCain and Dick Cheney, the vice-president, using the same silly phrase in the past.

They closely analysed whether Obama meant that Palin herself was the 'pig' in the context of the remark, or whether he meant (as he obviously did) that the 'pig' in question was McCain’s economic plan.

But wait, maybe Palin is actually the lipstick and McCain is the pig?

Obama appeared on a popular late night talk show, and the host asked him if he had every actually tried to put lipstick on a pig.

He said "that would be a no."

On National Public Radio, the host called up a farmer in Iowa and tried to get him to apply actual lipstick to an actual, squealing pig, out in the barnyard.

This experiment ended badly for all concerned.

Out of touch?

Now, after weeks of attacks from McCain, Obama's camp says its ready to strike back 'furiously'.

Previous entries


Part 1: Obama factor
Part 2: It's personal
Part 3: Overload
Part 4: A nasty week
Part 5: A week of war
Part 6: War and lies
Part 7: On the right
Part 8: Race card
Part 9: Bear baiting?
Part 10: No end in sight?
Part 11: Forced to wait
Part 12: Under par
Part 13: Tough choices
Part 14: Cashing in
Part 15: Making history

Part 16: Albatross
Part 17: Dog days
Part 18: The right notes
Part 19: Military men
Part 20: American voter
Part 21: Leap of faith
Part 22: Iron lady

It did so with a new ad showing McCain back in 1982, the year he entered congress, with an announcer saying "things have changed since then - but not McCain."

Pictures of people wearing unattractive early-eighties apparel, speaking on massive cinderblock-sized mobile phones, and fiddling with Rubiks cubes pass by, as the mocking narrator intones: "He admits he doesn’t know how to use a computer! He can't even send an email!"

So much for economy, war, health care and everything else we really ought to be debating. Bring on the pigs! And the lipstick!

It must be said that while there is a comical (or asinine) side to this, there is a more sinister aspect as well.

The McCain campaign is shamelessly spreading what the mainstream media squeamishly refers to as 'mischaracterisations' but which I will call, simply, lies.

One recent McCain ad claims Obama sponsored legislation mandating comprehensive sex education for kindergarten children.

In fact, the Illinois legislation, which Obama voted for but did not sponsor, was intended to teach kindergarten-age children how to fend off sexual predators.

Public 'awareness'

An example of candidate's seemingly being less than truthful on the campaign was also provided by none other than Sarah Palin, who, as she bid farewell to a group of Alaska National Guard soldiers en route to president Bush's disastrous war in Iraq, publicly linked the attacks of September 11th 2001 to Saddam Hussein and the ongoing combat between US troops and armed Iraqi groups.

Sarah Palin seemed confused about why
US troops were in Iraq [Reuters]
She told the guardsmen, who included her own 19-year-old son, Track, that they must "defend the innocent from the enemies who planned and carried out and rejoiced in the death of thousands of Americans."

The notion that the Iraqi government under Saddam was behind the attacks was pushed relentlessly by George Bush and Dick Cheney as they sold the war to the gullible and shell-shocked public back in 2002 and 2003.

But it has long since been discredited and even Bush has had to retract his earlier insinuations.

In Palin's case, however, this may be less about deliberate falsehood than simple confusion.

Palin, who showed in her first US network TV interview that she's probably never heard of the Bush Doctrine by which the US reserves the right to pre-emptively invade countries it thinks might be a threat, might very well be one of the 50 per cent or so of Americans who still believe Saddam was behind 9/11.

Of course, only about two out of five US citizens are able to name the three branches of the US federal government.

And barely one in seven can find Iraq on a world map.

So perhaps its not surprising US presidential politics sound pretty dumb.

We sound pretty dumb, too, for allowing ourselves to be diverted by this idiocy, and not demanding that the mainstream news media outlets quit behaving like giggling seven-year-old's with a short attention span.

'Bridge to nowhere'

Another area where Palin has seemed at the very least confused is her stated opposition to a controversial and expensive federal public works project in Alaska, the so called 'bridge to nowhere.'

In fact she lobbied hard for it until it became a national laughing-stock and it was cancelled.

Then she came out against the bridge but her office kept the money congress had appropriated for it.

Nonetheless Palin keeps on telling the same story as a way of proving that she is a fiscally disciplined cost-cutter, against wasteful spending, just as McCain himself claims to be.

The truth is, Alaska is notorious for grabbing as many federal tax dollars as it can for extravagant and wasteful projects, and Palin has lobbied for funds as a mayor and governor as avidly as the rest of Alaska's politicians.

Here's an excerpt from Palin’s interview with ABC News:

Question: "Governor, this year, requested $3.2 million for researching the genetics of harbour seals, money to study the mating habits of crabs. Isn't that exactly the kind of thing that John McCain is objecting to?"

Palin: Those requests, through our research divisions and fish and game and our wildlife departments and our universities, those research requests did come through that system.

Pigs, pitbull dogs, seals, crabs — what's with all the animals all of a sudden?

Maybe next week we can talk about some human issues.

 Source: Al Jazeera
 
Feedback Number of comments : 52
 
Byron Jones
Australia
13/09/2008
US Election Diary: Stupid Season.
What a pithy, intelligent article, Mr Reynolds! You unerringly cut to crux of the matter, revealing the sad facts about US election mentality. I hope Americans read it (but I shan't hold my breath), for they might just come to their senses (again, I shan't hold my breath).

Mike
United States
13/09/2008
washington correspondents are stupid
If you could extract yourself from Washington for a while you would find that most Americans are smarter than you because they do not identify with hate-America logic or patronizing,pitifully slanted articles. Grow up and become a responsible journalist. Ava Illinois

JB
United States
13/09/2008
corespondent has no idea
Your corespondent has no idea about what he is writing about. First off, the US health care system has not failed. Americans enjoy the highest standard of living in the world. Our health care system may have some flaws but is far from failed. And to suggest that Governor Palin is saying that she thinks Saddam had anything to do with 9/11 is an outright lie. The current fight in Iraq involves al-Qaeda. So when she states "defend the innocent from the enemies" she was right on target.

Dan
United States
13/09/2008
Out of Touch?
I find it appaling that you refer to yourselves as "..giggling seven-year-old's.." by annoying us day and night with your obsession with "silliness" but then accuse average Americans of being accomplices. Average Americans, the ones that pay the taxes and raise their families, the ones outside Hollywood, D.C. and Times Square, have little patience for your sensationalistic "journalism". We know what's important even if you don't: high taxes, high gas prices, and an indifferent corrupt congress

Marc Portelance
Afghanistan
13/09/2008
Election game desperation
It's frustrating to see how the american voters are being brought down the same old path, once again, of voting for either Reps or Dems. These two same parties forever and ever it seems. Some poeple are enlightened enough to sway from it and vote for independants. Yet still to many don't see the light. They'll never use the power of voing to shake the foundations of these two parties, and show who really IS the boss. What is needed now in America is revolution. Don't hold your breath for that.

Pete
United States
13/09/2008
Prepetual Motion
This writer has filled his comentary with all the garbage he is supposedly criticizing. He prepetuates the hypocricy. I wonder if he even sees that he is part of the problem. Denial is a wonderful thing.

Joshua
United States
13/09/2008
Certain Responses...
Certain people in the response section react harshly to articles like this for two main reasons (maybe more): 1) They cannot comprehend the concept of criticism - they are the same people who think that if you criticize something, then you hate it. They're very emotional people, which is the second reason they respond as such: they take it personally when anyone says anything bad about America - they feel as if someone were picking on them, and that makes them feel insecure.

Dr. Dave
United States
13/09/2008
US election Diary: Stupid Season
Seems like many posting comments about Reynolds' diary are like those complaining that the messenger has unfashionable shoes. Who cares if the Emperor is naked, quit pointing this out! Some will do anything but ask things like: When was al Qaeda first in Iraq? So sending US troops caused the problem in the first place! McSame will gladly send troops to Russia, Venezuela, anywhere. Better he be unemployed in a couple months.

Maurice
Canada
13/09/2008
Please do not destort reality!
Rob Reynolds is lying when he is claiming that according to Palin Saddam is conncted to 9/11. Pain NEVER made such a statement. What she said was that Americans soldiers are fighting Al-Qaida in Irak which is TRUE. It is common knowledge that since 9/11 Al-Qaida has been active in Iraq and everyone knows that Al-Qaida was behid 9/11. For journalists to resort to lies to accomplish their own political agenda is immoral and unaccetable.

Sabir Shahid
United States
13/09/2008
Dumb Candidates
The world get to see these two candidates for what they are since Foxnews likes to lie and spin the talking points in their favor. They both deserve a jail cell in Gitmo along with Bush and Chenney. As a veteran I am embarrased that Palin is so "dumb" on military affairs. Mcain can't even send a e-mail, talk about idiots running the country and out of touch. Russia will be coming across the Border and we all will be in concentration camps with these idiots in Washington. America is sick.

Kevin
United States
13/09/2008
US election diary: Stupid season
Even the "issues" that most Americans care about are selfish: high taxes, high gas prices, etc. They don't seem to care (or are completely unaware) that the federal budget is running in record deficit, that internationally, our country is morally bankrupt or that corporations have more power than politicians. No, they're content in their fantasy that Americans "enjoy the highest standard of living" and are more than satisfied with a candidate who will maintain that status quo.

Peter DeLorenzo
United States
14/09/2008
stupid season
As an American citizen, I am ashamed. So many people here are blind! It is sad and tragic. The media here is such crap. How can these wars continue to be justified? Unbelievable self absorption, self-deception, greed, and stupidity rise to the surface. No one wants to admit it, but America is following a dark path, a self-righteous, immoral, violent path. It is the path that leads to chaos, not peace. These politicians and the US media have led the way to our lowest point.

Forrest
United States
14/09/2008
Paranoia, thy name is Narrow
This wouldn't be the first or last time that a population resorted to electoral idiocy. But one would have thought that America might have been different (more enlightened) especially since we claim or aim to be so. And while we're at it, why all the battle-call requests for God only blessing America ... and NOT the world?

Bill
United States
14/09/2008
Looking forward to getting past election day
I am definitely looking forward to the end of elections season. Reading the news and talking to people about politics in this country is depressing. As someone who knows what the Bush doctrine is, can find Iraq on a map, knows Saddam had nothing to do with 9/11, and can list the 3 branches of government, I have to just cringe at the press time and and rise in popularity McCain/Palin are getting. I have no doubt if they do get elected, we'll be nostalgic for Bush by comparison.

Lauren
United States
14/09/2008
Everyone is missing the point..
There are a few of you here that are trying to pick apart this article but you are missing the point of the entire thing. The message here is not anti-american, it's simply pointing out that every election is riddled with poo-flinging from both sides, rather than focusing on important policies that SHOULD take precedence in elections. More and more, elections are just a form of entertainment, joining the ranks of Paris Hilton exploits. Shouldn't they be more serious?

Cocktailhag
United States
14/09/2008
Reynolds article
It is disturbing in the extreme to read the Fox News automatons from my once-respected country respond to this reasonable, balanced article. The worst part is, they have they writing and analytical skills of schoolchildren, and anyone reading can pretty much correctly assume that most Americans are racist nincompoops, so besotted with Bush and his war-mongering, and utterly bereft of any quality to redeem these deficiencies, that we all deserve the mess we're in. Sad, and embarrassing.

James Wilson
United States
14/09/2008
election season of idoits
If I were in power in the USA Pil Gramham of Texas would be charged with Treason. His banking deregulation bill and the Enron Loophole slipped into a bills and supported by John McCain has nearly brought the whole world to an economic collaspe. Thousands of retirees have lost thier nesteggs. Phil Graham was paid $750,000.00 to get those deregulations pased. An Enron Employee wrote the Electroinc Banking deregualtion part of the bills. Regulation are good!

Martyn
Spain
14/09/2008
Opening minds
Travelling the States for one year I was horrified by the poor quality information the media gave the people about the rest of the world. It is gratifying to see so many US responses here, so even if they do not agree with Aljazeera citizens are at least looking beyond Fox for their information. I saw Regan in 84 backing up Nancy in the ‘Say no to drugs’ campaign. I said to my girlfriend “ He has Alzheimer’s or something” He was re-elected. McCain has a frightening chance of pulling it off.

Sarah
United States
15/09/2008
Prior postings to this article
As a relatively well educated American, I heartily enjoyed this article. Those prior posters who objected to claims that our healthcare system has failed do not realize how many Americans are declaring bankruptcy as a result of unexpected medical bills, or seeking healthcare outside our borders. While I highly doubt that only 2/5 of us can name all three branches of government, I am appalled at how little Americans know about real econ/poli issues yet hold unshakable opinions anyway. VOTE OBAMA

Camilla
New Zealand (Aotearoa)
15/09/2008
Interesting
I'm really pleased to see so many Americans responding to this. One thing that concerns me, and probably many non-Americans, is the highly filtered and somewhat inaccurate world-view presented by media outlets in the US, so it's great that so many of you read this site. It gives a small degree of hope to us outsiders, I think. I shudder to think of what many of your compatriots believe, given their information sources!

Tess Luck
Sweden
15/09/2008
Compared their education?
Speaking of intelligence, i cannot see how these two candidates can be compared fairly. One is scholarly, contemplative and well educated in the miraculous steps that saved the US from tyranny at its birth! The other is everything that suggests popularism and corporatism, a bottomless pit that is centrist where NOTHING gets done. I come from an very old Virginia family and what these so called 'Republicans represent is not conservatism! Please do not lose hope.

waymon hodges
United States
16/09/2008
u.s. election
you cannot understand a u.s. election unless you understand racial history and racial policies of this country. the replublicans are trying to make race the only issue in this election. it is working. look for code words and images and read between the lines.

matt
United States
16/09/2008
enough
Your biased reporting is typical. You do not report both sides, and you should. Obama and Biden have as much wrong associated with them as McCain and Palin. If you so called reporters do not start doing your real job, you will be the first to see and feel the error in your ways.

john
United States
16/09/2008
Its amazing how most americans think that Al-Jazeera is some terrorist sponsored network. I read it for a differing perspective on the happenings in my own country, just as i do fox news and the ny times. i have finally come to the conclusion that FOX News is simply evil, and criminally biased.

Mike White
Australia
16/09/2008
In response to the comment by JB that "Americans enjoy the highest standard of living in the world", perhaps you should check some facts yourself. America does not come in at the top of any of the known methods of ranking living standards, largely because of the huge gap between rich and poor, one of the highest anywhere in the world.

Vianey Aguirre
United States
16/09/2008
knowledgeable journalist
I respect this journalist's article and support this kind of work. I just wish we had this kind of journalism in the United States as mainstream so people could be truly educated! To those who oppose this journaist's point of view...go watch FOX news and comment there...leave us educated people of America alone!

doug
United States
16/09/2008
U.S. presidential election
It would be nice to see aljazeera cover U.S. elections by giving all five candidates equal coverage, something the U.S. press is afraid to do. The U.S. press is afraid democracy might break out. By covering the campaigns of Ralph Nader, Cynthia Mckinney, and Bob Barr with regard to the issues this would show how the two corporate parties (democrats and republicans) are out of touch with the American voters on the major issues of war, health care, military spending, economic justice and ecology

Arnold
United States
17/09/2008
US Election Diary:Stupid Season
My introduction to predidential politics was during the John F. Kennedy run for president. The next day when the vote tallies were pulished in the newspaper, I asked my mother, how could they count all those votes overnight. She said "They Don't!" The distractions then are the same as now, except fraudulent voting machines make the job easier. The USA needs UN Election Observers.

Bob
United States
17/09/2008
great article
Great article about how childish the USA is... So if the USA had never existed, what language would you be speaking now?. Keep up the diatribe, we allow it here.

Diane
United States
17/09/2008
Third Party Candidates
There are smart Americans. I am one of them, that's why I am voting Third Party. I am not voting for McCain or Obama. Vote Third Party (Libertarian or Constitutionalist Party) Vote for Hope, not the Lies.

daniel
United States
18/09/2008
Stupid Season
Mr Reynolds: The problem with our election system isnt the republicans, and democrats, it is unfortunately the media outlets that only allow the two parties equal television time. Many qualified middle of the road idealists are unable to get their views heard because of journalist and media outlets like you. Most of America is middle of the road, able to disect topics from both points of view, unfortunately those elected must bo either fanatically conservative, or outrageously liberal

Martin
United Kingdom
13/09/2008
US Election Diary
Mike's response to the article seems to epitomise the lack of understanding about how (most of) the world views the US. Mike doesn't seem to understand that most people have very good reason for hating the US - or at least the policies and politicians who condemn millions to starvation, penury, ill-health, never mind about the military invasions that the US is so fond of. Mike's response is typtical, of course, of those who, when threatened by the truth, resort to personal insult.

John Melonakos
United States
13/09/2008
Reynolds Twists the Statements
Reynolds is twisting the statements in this article. Palin did not insinuate that Hussain was somehow behind the attacks on 9/11. Telling the soldiers going to Iraq that they are going to be fighting the terrorists that killed on 9/11 is TRUE. Al-qaeda is in IRAQ... maybe you're the one that is ignorant? Stop disparaging Americans for the fun of it. It's really not productive.

Bill Smith
United States
13/09/2008
sad
It is sad that people in my country would even think of voting for McCain. I personally do not think Obama is much better. I do wish Ron Paul wasn't so censored/ignored. He would bring about true positive change.

Mike
United States
13/09/2008
I thought this article was well done - stating many facts and yes added a little opinion. What's wrong with that? Also I didn't take it as disparging of Americans. Although we Americans could use more of that, given the state of our electoral process and the level of thinking that most Americans seem to apply to their electoral choices. OREGON

Hayes
United States
14/09/2008
Great article. US media is absolutely deplorable. I refuse to watch traditional US news outlets like CNN and FOX News - I rather enjoy reading Aljazeera and BBC. Sometimes Aljazeera is pretty negatively biased against the US, but who can blame them? And no, most Americans won't read this article - everyone knows that Aljazeera is run by dem dar terrurists!

Caleb Cupples
United States
14/09/2008
US Election Diary: Stupid Season
Personally, I agree with Reynolds's analysis of the current political situation in the US. As far as I'm concerned, politics in this country are focused on all the wrong things. Hell, as a habit, we Americans complain about everything, but do nothing to actually change things. Maybe, we will have actual change, but I fear that the only change in this election is the extra lipstick on the pigs, and this is coming from the heart of Republican country, Tennessee.

Poyani
Canada
14/09/2008
Article
The response of many posters here really reinforces the articles main points. Many American posters have been resorting to ad-hominem attacks against the author, while others falsely claim that American soldiers are sent to Iraq to fight Al-Qaida (According to US DoD at most only 2% of the insurgency is made of Al-Qaida) and one Canadian poster even makes the foolish statement that it is common knowledge that Al-Qaida has been active in Iraq since 9/11 (they appeared only after the invasion).

Parker Hall
United States
14/09/2008
American Elections
As an American Citizen, being force-fed these ridiculous elections over and over makes me wonder how our founding fathers would react to the level to which we have stooped in our decision making towards the president, we have strayed extremely far off of the path that has been laid for hundreds of years, we have been forced to choose the president by worthless topics, reducing the voting population to a mindless organism. We need change, not in the candidate but in the whole system itself.

Sergey
Canada
14/09/2008
US is the enemy of the world
It seems that Palin's IQ is not higher than of J BUSH and McCain :). If elected they will continue messing with the world their dangerous way ... new 911s, new wars, new tragedies... I do not agree that US needs a revolution, thay need a new education system.

Daniel
Canada
14/09/2008
relax about the correspondents already
What's everyone so bent out of shape about. This isn't news, nor is it pretending to be. This is a commentary, an editorial. The two are not the same - in fact their intrinsically different. If you like it or not, the views expressed in the article are viewed by the majority of the world. Rob Reynolds isn't saying anything evil or wrong. You have to remember, American culture is one of mass media. The whole world consumes it. So, that means the America we see on TV is the America we all know.

townie
United States
15/09/2008
US election
Right On!! I hear only Republican noise and blather to drown out Sen. Obama's message for "change". Dumber than Gov Palin's stance are the uninfomed, pitiful attempts to defend her by Americans responding to your blog. Keep up the sharp observations and thanks

Laurie
Australia
15/09/2008
Politics is the pig
In my opinion politics is the pig, and lipstick is the illusion of democracy presented to the poor public. The American voters currently have a campaign dominated by: a charismatic, but completely inexperienced Obama, a war hero, but way too old McCain, a hockey mom (an admirable vocation yes but not as vice-president), and a experienced but politically inept Biden. Democracy, the right to choose between this ragtag bunch!

DrZiggy
Canada
15/09/2008
US election: Stupid season
It always amazes me just how some Americans are so full of themselves and refuse to see what image they present to the rest of the world. Rob Reynolds article exposes of the the underbelly of American ethos: self-righteousness, self-absorption, and denial. The American election should be about issues that affect everyone inside and outside the U.S. But rather, it has become about who's fit to become the American Idol finalist. Obama's the only candidate that tried to stay on message....

Frank
United States
15/09/2008
Stupid Season
Great article! Most Americans will not take kindly to the truth these days so plz pay no mind to the earlier comments made by the insecure/ignorant ones that hate when anyone has anything negative to say about such a backward country as this! Backward is being mild considering the ridiculously low IQ of the majority in this country! Thank you for reporting the news as is unlike the mainstream media here that continues the process of dumbing down an already dumbed down population!

todd
United States
15/09/2008
mccain email
for all you peolpe that bust on McCain for the email thing. He can't use a keyboard. His fingers were broken in captivity several times for torture. Maybe if we tortured alqueda like this they could'nt use their guns and make bombs.

Vanessa
United States
16/09/2008
I think we're a little off topic here but I'd like to respond to Todd's comment because it seems to be endorsing torture? I hope that is not what you truly believe but it does make me sad to read. I think that if something bad is done to you or to someone you know it does not mean that you should go out and do it to someone else. Rather, see it for the ugly, terrible thing that it is and don't wish it on anyone else.

robert werkheiser
United States
16/09/2008
please.
vote for a 3rd party.The 2 major parties offer zero help for the U.S.A.more fighting.more hate.Please be smart and show the world "we are change".wWe need too.

mellonhead
United States
18/09/2008
Why is it that when Americans try to make an intelegent critique of our shamefully shallow election process we are labled as "Un-American" and "Un-Patriotic? Why does the American population immediately lable someone as an "elitist" when they choose to be educated about the world around them? I proudly contend that Americans live in one of the best countries in the world and we have a lot to be proud of - but every election just makes me more embarassed, outraged, and ultimately sad.

Amy
United States
20/09/2008
US election diary: Stupid season
FINALLY! An article showing how many US citizens get all up in arms about idiotic phrases and strange campaign ads that don't address the real issues facing our citizens (and, of course, I had to go to the foreign press). Where is the concern over the failing AIG, Lehman Bros, Washington Mutual, etc.... what about the foreclosure crisis? I'm tired of the attempts to mask ignorance on these issues. Get wiht your advisors and come up with real solutions!

Leo
Australia
20/09/2008
Elect more WAR
Well said Reynolds, "barely one in seven Americans can find Iraq on a world map". They have no idea how many military bases they have on foreign soil, let alone the reasons why they keep expanding their global garrisons. Somalia, Iran, Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Philippines, Cuba, Ecuador, Venezuela and Colombia say: Yankee Go Home.

Nunez
United States
21/09/2008
Stupid season / Ignorant People
The Bush administration has squandered our national treasure and our once good reputation, yet our media, election process, and ignorance of national and international affairs all harmonize to assure the world that we have traded in the mantle of freedom for the sword of imperialism. The 85% of the American people who say the nation is headed in a (very) wrong direction need to stand up and shout that very loudly. Perhaps we need another revolution.

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article