UPDATED ON:
Thursday, September 25, 2008
07:10 Mecca time, 04:10 GMT
 
News Americas
How the financial bubble burst
Are more US financial houses about to come crashing down? [AFP]

The roots of the panic in financial markets around the world are deep and complex but they lie in the convergence of three factors.

Millions of people pursuing the "American dream" of home ownership, politicians and regulators who dismantled a system of financial safeguards and then ignored warnings of impending disaster, and financial markets and institutions disregarding risk in their headlong pursuit of profit.

Let's go back to the beginning - or at least to the year 2000 - when the 'Dotcom' boom went bust.

That drove down stocks and sparked a recession and then came the attacks of September 11, 2001 - a body blow to the US economy.

To hasten economic recovery, the US central bank, the Federal Reserve, headed by Alan Greenspan, used the most powerful weapon in its arsenal - it cut interest rates repeatedly.

Lower rates made it easier for banks to lend and consumers to borrow and spend.

"It did stimulate the economy," says Clyde Prestowitz, the head of the Economic Strategy Institute.

"And it stimulated housing, because effectively the cost of investment was negative, you could borrow money for virtually nothing."

Easy borrowing

Home-ownership is the bedrock of the "American dream".

US tax laws encourage home ownership by allowing people to deduct the interest they pay on their mortgages.

Freddie Mac underwrote thousands of
US mortgages during the boom [AFP]
And government-sponsored financial institutions such as Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac contributed by underwriting mortgages and making it easier for people of modest means to put down the money for a home.

From around 2001 and 2002, with mortgage interest rates at near-record lows, millions of Americans went shopping for homes.

With demand soaring, the price of housing nearly doubled from 2000 to 2006.

But many of those buyers couldn't really afford what they were getting, Prestowitz says. 

"They wanted to buy a house and it's understandable, they wanted a piece of the dream and the mortgage industry was encouraging them to buy.

"It got to the point where the brokers were offering mortgages to people who had little or no income, who somehow thought they could put these payments together."

Sensing a potential bonanza, banks and mortgage companies began peddling loans to riskier segments of the population - especially low-income first-time homebuyers.

These were called "sub-prime" mortgages.

"Many of the mortgages were adjustable-rate mortgages," Prestowitz explains.

"They were built so that in the first year your interest rate was low, but somewhere down the road, your interest rate jumped."

Ideological drive

But something else was at work as the housing bubble grew: The US government, under the sway of the free-market, anti-regulation ideology, had begun to systematically dismantle rules and regulations established after the Great Depression of the 1930s.

In 1999, the US congress and Bill Clinton, the former president, repealed laws designed to stop financial crashes - saying markets should regulate themselves.

Government regulation, we've been told, is bad, it's evil, and the government doesn't know what it's doing economically.

Lawrence Mitchell, financial analyst and author

Why?

Lawrence Mitchell, the author of The Speculation Economy: How Finance Triumphed Over Industry says it was the triumph of ideology over caution.

"Since Ronald Reagan became president in 1980, free markets have been preached in this country as being our economic salvation," Mitchell says.

"'Government regulation' we've been told, 'is bad, it's evil, and the government doesn't know what it's doing economically'."

"'It should be out of people's business'. That's nonsense, but that was the ideology that was driving it. 'Regulation is bad, free market is good'."

The next president after Clinton, George Bush, continued to de-regulate housing and financial markets and bragged about the results at the 2004 Republican convention, saying: "Another priority for a new term is to build an ownership society, because ownership brings security and dignity and independence.

"Thanks to our policies, homeownership in America is at an all-time high."

Mortgages sold

Of course, it  wasn't just the politicians who allowed the reckless financial frenzy to grow. It was also the man who the financial press was hailing as a genius -  Alan Greenspan.

Alan Greenspan has been blamed for
deregulating markets [AFP]
"The Fed is responsible for oversight of the banking system, but under Alan Greenspan it basically stopped doing oversight," Prestowitz says.

"That allowed for fraudulent practices and, as a result mortgages being given to people who had no assets and no income, prudent lending went out of the window."

In the new, hands-off regulatory environment, banks and mortgage companies transformed the loans they were making into commodities.

The change was the banks no longer held the mortgages and the home finance industry began to securitise, or underwrite, them.

In the past, when you would buy a house, you would get a mortgage from your bank.

The bank would hold that mortgage and you would pay it off, with interest.

Today, you get the mortgage from your bank and the bank immediately sells your mortgage to Goldman Sachs or Lehman Brothers, or Deutsche Bank or any of literally tens of thousands of mutual funds, hedge funds, pension funds, or private-equity firms.

Those pools of mortgages are then bundled together into securities, just like bonds or stocks.

Millions of securitised loans were sold to firms all over the world.

At first it was a lucrative deal with high returns and little apparent risk.

The bubble bursts

But there was a worm in Wall Street's apple: Millions of the mortgages being sold -  more than 20 per cent at the peak of the frenzy - were high-risk "sub-prime" loans.

"What was happening was a lot of bad stuff was being mixed with good stuff and it was being called good," Prestowitz says.

Thousands of homes have been
foreclosed [GALLO/GETTY]
The global financial community seemed to believe housing prices would just keep going up and up but then the bubble burst.

The Federal Reserve began raising rates to fend off inflation.

As the rates rose, people who had taken on balloon-style mortgages - thinking they could easily pay the initial rate - found their payments being increased and suddenly ... they couldn't pay.

In 2006 home prices started to drop. Houses glutted the market and stayed unsold month after month.

In formerly red-hot housing markets, like Florida and California, home prices fell 10, 15, even 20 per cent. A huge wave of loan defaults and home foreclosures began.

In 2007, mortgage lenders with lots of risky loans on their books started going bankrupt.

Then major investment banks came under pressure and began to fail. In March, Bear Stearns was the first of the majors to go under.

The problem then was not, and is not now, about houses. It's about credit - or the lack of it.

With so much bad debt out there - and no one really knows how much there is - banks around the world have become extremely risk-averse.

They've stopped lending money to individuals, businesses and even each other.

Unable to get loans, Lehman Brothers, the fourth-largest US investment bank, went belly up.

Central banks have by now pumped hundreds of billions of dollars into the global financial system, but the flow of credit, known as liquidity, has slowed to a sluggish trickle.

Bleak future

For the first time since the 1930s, a true, systemic financial crisis is under way. 

That's why the US government is considering sweeping and costly measures to buy up millions of bad mortgages.

But while the plans announced late this week seem to have boosted confidence on Wall Street, no one really knows what will happen next.

"It could get a lot worse, said Mitchell, gloomily.

"I haven't read any significant empirical evidence to suggest we are anywhere near the bottom."

"Where's the bottom?" I asked him.

He replied: "The bottom could be very deep.

"I really don't want to know."

 Source: Al Jazeera
Feedback Number of comments : 22
 
richard columbare
United States
22/09/2008
why it happened
The reasons for this financial meltdown are these. First comes GREED,then comes CORRUPTION, and over all of these things comes LACK OF ETHICS. It's what brought on the great depression of 1929,and now it's come round again.

Lilly
United States
22/09/2008
How the financial bubble burst
It is truly ashame that we as tax payors let our government create this problem that started during the Clintron presidency and continued on. Our politicians no longer have the back bone to sometimes tell Americans we can't do some of the things they want. GREED was the preeminent factor in all of this debacle.

kk
Malaysia
24/09/2008
how the financial bubble burst
first, the presumption that they are self- regulating is wrong, many investment banks are driven by greed for bigger profit, they operate beyond their company objectives, instead of the normal fees- based income, they leverage their shareholding equity to dabble into high risk-high return collaterized mortgaged papers. It's like 'musical chair game', the ones caught with the last rotten apple lost the game and when the number reach critical mass, it become crisis

Scott G
United States
24/09/2008
Vinnie-New Zealand
What the heck does this article have to do with oil? But to educate you a little, oil is traded as a commodity by speculators, that trade in US dollars, as the dollar has declined, the price of oil has increased. Thats the simple version. "W" dabbled in oil, but that was more a label thrown on him by the liberal press to tie him to big oil.

Michael
United States
24/09/2008
Privatize profits, socialize risk
This is the formula which the Republicans think means "free market." They strip out the regulatory safeguards designed to keep the investment banks from gobbling up regular banks allowing the creation of financial entities so big that when they fail, they can pull the entire economy down with them. Then on the other hand they drop interest rates and pass bills forcing banks to make loans to low income (high risk) families. Not unsurprisingly, the dominos fall down, and now we pay for it!

Ahu Sam
Australia
24/09/2008
How the financial bubble burst
Now people can realize this free market is just a big hoax. It allows for rich powerful few people to play games (like betting) with money of hard working middle & low income taxpayers. Greed of these rich few people allows them snuff off good money without doing any work profit by just having money. It can be realized that if more ownership of resources continue like this people like these few are just a virus in the community. This virus is spreading check their bank balances, UN should act!

Thabit booley
Afghanistan
24/09/2008
always stealing from the people to enrich a few
The fact is that value cannot just dissapear into thin air.It must have gone somewhere.And it definitely didnt go into the pockets of the people.So once again we find that a few unscrupulous had profited at the expense of the people and the peoples money(700 billion dollars) is used to bail out the few.Wake up Americans .You are used to spending tonnes of money without getting value in return .eg war in iraq and afghanistan and billions payed to israel annually is theft paid for by you .

Alfred E. Neuman
United States
24/09/2008
Almost all the facts there....
There are two facts not mentioned here. First, if a central bank has total control of the money supply, problems like this are inevitable. If the US Govt needs tons of cash, they can turn on the inflationary economy to get it. It happens every war: VietNam and Iraq are worse than previous because there is no longer gold backing to help deflect problems. The other fact is that inflation encourages people to live beyond their means. I bought much less than I could "afford" and I am doing fine.

Vinnie
New Zealand (Aotearoa)
23/09/2008
Bush and oil
What I can't comprehend is how Bush, who's supposed to be an 'oilman', is unable to contain the price of oil for the US or at least guarantee its affordability. You'd assume that with his contacts and influence in the oil industry he'd be able to pull some strings. Maybe 'Big Oil' is pulling his strings and they are all making a fortune at the public's expense, and George collects the kick-backs. Or maybe this is the free market in action, and cartels are considered legitimate?

Jamshaid Anwar Chattha
Malaysia
24/09/2008
This is very comprehensive article covering the whole bottom line of this hot story. I just want to comment that despite the fact that they was greed in the process which made banks to neglect “due-diligence and prudent attitude”, they should have understood that how intensive and costly it would be for financial system causing multiple adverse effects on the rest of the world. I hope FBI investigation would bring some important implications for the others and stresses more on the “Transparency”

Jaime
United States
30/09/2008
How the financial bubble burst
I have read a number of articles written about the present financial crisis. For some reason or other all the columnists agree to one thing, and that is that the blame is on the consumer and not on the Wall Street speculators. It's about time that the players in Wall Street take responsibility for the chaos caused instead of begging the govt. for money our money to ease the crisis.

Saltwater Jim
United States
30/09/2008
How The Financial Bubble Burst
Great piece, but you left out the part about balance between prices and incomes. It also matters, that balance requires what is happening now. It is not odd or bad. House prices must absolutely come down, any way necassary. Balance must be restored, whether helped by Congress or not. As for the Market, it is over priced as well. Credit is said to be a factor. The Fed can help with that. They do after all actually cause the printing of money at their discression.

ABDUL HAQ
South Africa
30/09/2008
How the Financial Bubble Bust
America went in two unaffordable wars, which did not go as planned. The Iraqi an Afgani misadventures was financed by the tax payer, while Treasury kept on printing dollars on futures to sustain the war it could ill- afford, bringing unnecessary debt to the country. It does not take a rocket scientist to understand how America's financial bubble burst. The US taxpayer needs to ask the government to explain this mess transparently!

seth
New Zealand (Aotearoa)
02/10/2008
finanical bubble
the sad truth about all this is that the current crisis was engineered, the reason credit was so easily available was to get the middle class on board on the great swindle, look at the value of your house going through the roof, there's good chance you sold up moved on, brought that new fancy car, got a new house with the same if not greater level of debt you had before. no one's wages got doubled during the last 8 years, it baffles me to see that so many people jumped on this wagon.

invisible
Australia
04/10/2008
America is going down, its face in the outside world is freekingly deteriorating but it deserves because of what they do to other countries. Now it is the time for other countries to unite and never relay on America because whoever follows them it will fall in the same hole or face the same consequences. If you keep on following the same path i am afraid the world wont last and it will be vanished. it culd be a plan set up by americans to inflict on the economy of evry country so thy stay on top

ray clarke
New Zealand (Aotearoa)
04/10/2008
Comments on how the bubble burst.
This is an excellent article and exposes some of the inbuilt mortality of the policies which drove this ridiculous henomenon over the top. Interest Rate deductions are too generous as were the lack of deposit controls. Who has paid the price for all of this? Those folk in the U.S.A. and around the world as it has virtually affected credit supply to manufacturing, mining, and now the New Zealand Dairy Industry. Policies in the USa have an effect well beyond that Country and no doubt no change.

Sally Anne Hamath
Afghanistan
04/10/2008
US Financial woes
When the going was good, however tenacious, the investment bankers paid themselves multi million dollar bonuses and they showed their gratitude in donations to the political party that enabled them. E.g. I believe Paulson, now controlling the rescue package, received a bonus of $38 million from Goldman Sachs when he left to join the Bush administration.

Noor
South Africa
30/09/2008
USA Financial DOOM AND BOOM!
Forget all those stories. In the Beginning, Russian Prime Minister Putin warned George Bush not to attack Iraq and Afghanistan because George Bush will never win and will experience lots of problems such as financials. Because Russian once invaded Afghanistan and Russia became the poor country! What goes round comes round - G Bush paid the price by going to war on a lie! GOD IS FAIR!

Tim Seretis
United States
02/10/2008
DOMESTIC ECONOMIC TERRORISM
Since September 11, 2001, the United States has been waging a war on terrorism, but for the last two decades the real terrorists have been the CEOs, the banks, and all the rest of the financial entities, and they were not hiding in caves in Afghanistan, they were right out in the open at Wall-Street. The greedy CEOs in the name of global business raped all of people. Their greed to line their back pockets with $$$ millions while raping the people is an economic terror attack.

Giles Wynne
Thailand
04/10/2008
So it was a bubble?
Who created the bubble? The capitalists,gambling on the rich mans betting shop, the stock market. Don't blame the people for wanting a better life style,when offered cheap loans and credit to by commodities they need most. Housing,education for children, health care,transport, all things that government should provide,but government don't own the state, the capitalists do. Banks and investment institutions should be made to pay by taking them into public ownership with education,health etc...

james
Australia
12/10/2008
America You Have brought down the world s economy with all your greed and your foreign policy which only considers your own selfish interests. Start thinking about the rest of humanity before it is too late. Show more compassion to other countries worse off than you.

Joe B
United States
24/10/2008
How the Financial Bubble Burst
Speaking in laconic riddles doesn't equate to speaking the truth. Alan Greenspan is an arrogant and conceited twit who refuses any attempt at insight into his culpability for this tragedy. He would do the world a favor to shut up. He has done irreparable harm, and that is his legacy. His epitaph - the failed policies of a pompous ass!

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article