UPDATED ON:
Thursday, October 23, 2008
05:22 Mecca time, 02:22 GMT
 
News Americas
US treads warily over China rights

The Uighurs say the Chinese government has oppressed them for years [EPA]

Washington DC is perhaps a rather strange choice for someone accused of being an active terrorist to make their home.

But Rebiya Kadeer, 60, with her long, grey hair tucked underneath a traditional Uighur cap, marches through the US capital confident that there is little chance she will be detained.

Kadeer has lived in exile in the US since being released from jail in China after serving a seven-year sentence for involvement in separatist activities, activities that the Chinese government says involve "terrorist" groups.

From her office a stone's throw from the White House, she lobbies the US government to push China to allow greater freedoms and autonomy for the Uighurs, a majority Muslim minority, who live in Xinjiang, her homeland.

Warm reception

The reception she has received in the US has been warm.

IN VIDEO


A diplomatic balancing act between the US and China

More videos ... 

Pictures on her office wall show her in the 1990s in fond exchanges with then-president George Bush, his wife Barbara and other supporters in the US Congress.

And she is keen to highlight how much the current Bush administration has done to support her cause.

"The American government has negotiated with the Chinese government to prevent the execution and repression of Uighurs, urging them to give us the same treatment as the Han Chinese," Kadeer says.

But it is a policy which has not won George Bush, the current president, any friends in Beijing.

It also exposes serious contradictions in his government's own ideological direction when you consider that 17 Uighurs are currently interred without being charged at Guantanamo Bay.

US dilemma

"They give time to say nice words about democracy and supporting people who believe in freedom but rarely make a decision that is a tangible policy decision"

Dana Rohrbacher, Republican congressman for California

The cause of the Uighurs, the Tibetans, Falun Gong and other groups who claim oppression by the Chinese government presents a serious dilemma for any administration in Washington.

While public opinion might demand that the US government speaks up for the voiceless and oppressed, China today is a formidable power that needs to be engaged, not enraged.

Recent presidents, both Democrat and Republican, while happy to vocally support some of these issues, have rarely censured China in any serious or substantial way.

"This administration has been similar to every administration that I've witnessed since Reagan left office," says Dana Rohrbacher, a Republican congressman for California.

"They give time to say nice words about democracy and supporting people who believe in freedom, but rarely make a decision that is a tangible policy decision," she said.

One very real option open to the next president - if he felt China was not meeting commitments to maintain human rights - would be to withdraw its "most favoured nation" status, which carries with it low trade tariffs and other benefits.

Such an option, however, is unlikely in a world where trade with China is so vitally important.

And as the US lurches to avoid a recession, it is unlikely to risk angering one of its major trading partners.

Covert support?

Will the US still be able to push a
rights agenda with China? [EPA]
The other possibility, and one which many Chinese suspect is already happening, is to covertly support so-called separatist groups.

Professor Zhang Hongliang of Min Zu University in Beijing points to documented evidence of CIA activities in Tibet during the 1960s.

He says he thinks the US is still trying to destabilise modern China in order to neutralise a rapidly emerging superpower.

"Premier Wen Jiabao has promised to help the American financial markets, but as a reward the US is selling advanced weapons to Taiwan, meeting with the Dalai Lama and announcing that East Turkestan terrorists can stay in the United States," says Zhang.

And as China's economic and diplomatic power rises, it's going to become increasingly complex for a US president to push the agenda of human rights while maintaining good relations with one of its most important economic partners.

 Source: Al Jazeera
 
Feedback Number of comments : 8
 
aaron
Afghanistan
23/10/2008
US treads warily over China rights
Tibet was and is and will always be a part of China. Very different from western culture, Chinese people thinks the signory is the most important thing even more important then their life. so China lost over 20 million lives during the World War II to agaisnt the aggression from Japan.

Sharmand
United States
23/10/2008
Um...
Tibet is not a part of China, Aaron. I have met many Tibetans and not a single one of them has professed anything but outright aversion towards Chinese Communist rule.

Angelo Sartor
Afghanistan
23/10/2008
US treads warily over China rights
perhaps Aaron should familiarize himself with the history of Tibet before making such an innacurate statement. For over 1,000 years, Tibet was a separate and distict nation. Although it benefit from period of time when it did receive protection from China, it also enjoyed protection from the Mongol Empire under Ghengis Khan. China illegally invaded and annexed Tibet. This is ther simple (and to some) painful truth,

michael_xgw
China
24/10/2008
are you a chinese, i'm a chinese. "Chinese people thinks the signory is the most important thing even more important then their life", that is the largest lie you can make, nobody in any country think country signory is more important than their life, unless slaves!

Ayub
Afghanistan
26/10/2008
Thats what im talking about:
The US is weary,sure it is..China is fast becoming an economic and a Military power.It is also gradually winning hearts and minds around the Globe starting with the African Continent.The US is not happy about that because the US is gradually loosing it's charm and influence for obvious reasons.Invading Iraq and Afghanistan and murdering innocent people does not really make the uS look like a good guy.The Chinese are cunning and clever.Be very afraid folks the Chinese will rule the world soon....

Nicola
Italy
24/10/2008
US treads warily over China rights
Tibet was an independent nation for longer than China has been a country. China illegaly occupies Tibet. Something must be done to end their brutal occupation.

Phil
New Zealand (Aotearoa)
25/10/2008
US treads warily over China rights
In your article concerning the future of US-China relations, the following paragraph is disgusting: "While public opinion might demand that the US government speaks up for the voiceless and oppressed, China today is a formidable power that needs to be engaged, not enraged." How dare you suggest that it is more important to maintain our economic standing with China than to help people oppressed. The moral highgrounds of both countries are irrelevant, these people need a voice.

Steven
United States
28/10/2008
US treads warily over China rights
For that idiot who said Tibet has been an independent nation longer than China has been a country, get your facts right. China has existed in one form or another for thousands of years, longer than Tibet. And all of you people need to calm down about Tibetans, when Tibet declared independence no one recognized them and no one will now that China is a major power and a major trading partner. Stop treating the Chinese as monsters and Tibetans as saints, its stupid and insulting.

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article