UPDATED ON:
Saturday, October 25, 2008
04:09 Mecca time, 01:09 GMT
 
News Americas
UN: Major inequality in US cities

Cities in Africa had the highest levels of disparity, according to the UN report [GALLO/GETTY]

Levels of economic disparity in major US cities, including New York and Washington DC, are comparable to those of African cities, a United Nations report has concluded.

The UN-Habitat report "State of the World's Cities" released on Thursday said that, while the US has less poverty than many cities in the developed world, inequality is high, rising above the international "alert" line.

It said race was a key factor for US economic inequality.

"The life expectancy of African Americans in the United States is about the same as that of people living in China and some states of India, despite the fact that the United States is far richer than the other two countries," it said.

In one example, the report cited figures from western New York state, where 40 per cent of black, Hispanic and ethnically-mixed households earned less than $15,000 in 1999, as compared to 15 per cent of white households.

Beijing 'most equal'

The most balanced city, both in Asia and in the world, is Beijing, the capital of China,  whereas the least egalitarian in Asia is Hong Kong, the Chinese-administered former British colony, the report found.

The world's most equal cities are located, on average, in western Europe, it said.

Denmark, Finland, the Netherlands and Slovenia were among those with the lowest levels of inequality, it said.

In Latin America, Brazilian cities "have the greatest disparities in income distribution in the world," the UN repot said.

Brazil is struggling to control rising unemployment and declining wages.

Cities in sub-Saharan Africa have the world's highest levels of urban poverty, with more than half of city residents living below the poverty line.

The report also said cities in South Africa and Namibia continue to have extremely high levels of income inequality, despite the end of apartheid early in the 1990s.

 Source: Agencies
Feedback Number of comments : 17
 
glen roberts
United States
24/10/2008
inequality in US cities
Why doesn't the story mention Havana or Santiago, Cuba? There is housing inequality in Cuba, but, with rare exceptions, that's all, and even house poverty is only relative and nothing like the third world. There are almost no street people in Havana. Glen Roberts, nottalkradio.com

Gillien Cheung
United States
26/10/2008
Major inequality in US cities
Gang issues is severe in many US cities, especially among the low income areas. Schools are not safe, students don't even know if they survive another day on the street or at the school. How could their standard of living be improved in such conditions? What are the causes? There is a correlation between inequality and the impact of a rapid decline of moral standard. When family units are broken, kids growing up without physical and mental security, there's no hope for equality!

Robin Mead
United States
26/10/2008
Inequality in US cities.
This report from the United Nations is yet another way to keep US citizens divided on the real issues. The US Feds and her world friends plan to create a world Empire through the United Nations and the World Bank. Many Americans are waking up, realizing they have been sold a faulty bill of goods for years. Our government no longer speaks for the majority of us. While racism is not dead here in the United States, it has little to do with what we or the rest of the world is faceing.

Fred
New Zealand (Aotearoa)
28/10/2008
Somethings to say
Beijing I would not doubt is the most equal city, and if you are skeptical, you've obviously never truly experienced Beijing. Illegal immigrants? Because they are hispanic they are illegal immigrants? and Black people illegal immigrants? If you didn't want them there you shouldn't have shipped them there in the first place. As for gang issues, place like Shanghai with way more people can mange crime, if the US can't I think really its just incompetence

reza santorini
United States
28/10/2008
inequality
@Anna, ILLEGAL immigrants who do squeeze us dry for their perceived rights, not needed. Come here legally as I did. Learn the language, be a citizen of the US, that is fine. Stay illegal and ask us to be like your native country, you will not find equality, because you'd not be equal nor worthy in spirit. Good grief how unfair to think we'd treasure you more than your own country. If it was so good, stay and demand what you ask of us. I came legally and paid my dues into society.

reza santorini
United States
25/10/2008
inequality for some
Sorry but I don't feel sorry for the immigrants who come here illegally and without a plan. We don't have enough jobs as it stands. Switching to a Marxist, or Communistic economy is not what the US wants. If you think we are bad, don't come here go to China or to those countries you think will be fairer to you. Meanwhile Denmark and Netherlands, Sweden and the others are needing this increased population. They are more worthy than the US for your presence.

Rosemarie
United States
26/10/2008
UN report on quality of life in major cities
I'm questioning if Bejing came out with the highest rating on quality of life in the world's cities as related to the manner of benefits being linked in China to ones primary registered city? Is the reported data misleading?

Kenneth Abeywickrama
United States
26/10/2008
Most Afro-Americans are not illegal immigrants!
The Afro-Americans who are the most marginalized community in the USA are not illegal immigrants. They were brought here over two hundred years ago as slaves. They are more American than the large number of Americans of European ancestry who came here in the last 150 years.

Krys Jasmin
United States
27/10/2008
Urban Inequality
I am skeptical that Beijing is the most "equal" city, it has some extremely deprived slums, and I imagine cite such as Singapore, where most of the population live in public housing would feature a better technical score. The situation of the US does not surprise me. A cultural fabrics that encourages the "get rich or die trying" and "poverty is a choice" mentality at the same time is unlikely to be ready to face the consequences of these actions. Denial, or blaming the victim are more common

Anna
Canada
28/10/2008
UN: Major inequality in US cities
@reza santorini Curious which families you hope to have living in the under 15k/household range if this immigrant-free utopia you dream of comes to fruition. Yours? Capitalism doesn't function without low wage earners. You'll volunteer for the position?

Timespanr
United States
29/10/2008
Greed in the Citys
In Las Vegas where the poor are left to the strees and help from soup kitchen, the mosque, etc the only support they receive for the city is from the Police. The Police constant harass them, force them from what ever shelt they find and refuse to allow the to go into parks. Education in Las Vegas Nevada Looks Great on TV. But, the reality is that is 49 out 50 states in the US.. A parent in this city has but a 50% chance to see their child get a HS Diploma NV Casinos screem when you ment

Robert T
United States
29/10/2008
This is the true face of Capitalism and the side of it that those in power try to keep people from seeing. Here in the US the idea is driven into everyones head that the cause of inequality and suffering is because laziness or the immigrants, and not because of capitalism which is the true root of it.

Tammy
United States
29/10/2008
Equality
America is based on the idea that you can work hard and reap what you sow. Yes people are born into poorer neighborhoods. I was born in poverty and raised singlehandedly by my grandmother. Through hard work I have improved my life spiritually and financially. I personally know people that claim inequality yet refuse to get a job when they are physically capable. They sit at home and complain and want the government to take care of them. If that's your flavor of kool-aid you should move to Europe

Naomi
United States
29/10/2008
Anna & Reza
Anna ~ Beautiful Reza ~ If illegal Hispanic immigrants in the US could afford to fly to Europe they probably WOULD. Acting within the zone of survival in a capitalistic society requires winning sometimes. For every winner there's a loser, and simple statistical math insists that means some people lose ALL THE TIME.

Robert T
Afghanistan
29/10/2008
Cont.
They do this through the idea of the "American dream", that if you work hard you can climb the social ladder and become wealthy. However because of the nature of Capitalism no matter how hard you work only very few people will manage to do this.

Robert T
United States
29/10/2008
@Tammy, while you may have been one of the few to do well through hard work and getting some lucky breaks many never will. Because of the nature of capitalism no matter how hard you work only a few will actually make it. Because of this many people have become resigned and unmotivated.

Anna
Canada
29/10/2008
UN: Major inequality in US cities
@Naomi As capitalism depends largely on those who "lose all the time", perhaps "thank you" is a more appropriate response when discussing those who fuel the machine than dear Reza's "deport them" response. How much more painful must losing be?

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article