UPDATED ON:
Tuesday, December 09, 2008
11:05 Mecca time, 08:05 GMT
 
News Americas
US guards charged over Iraq deaths

The suspects had earlier handed themselves in
to a court in Utah [Reuters]

Five US security guards employed by the Blackwater firm have been charged over the killings of at least 14 Iraqi civilians and injuries to 20 others in a 2007 shooting in Baghdad.

In a 35-count indictment, the five men were charged with manslaughter, attempt to commit manslaughter and weapons violations, the US justice department said on Monday.

"The government alleges in the documents unsealed today that at least 34 unarmed Iraqi civilians, including women and children, were killed or injured without justification or provocation by these Blackwater security guards in the shooting at Nisoor Square," said Patrick Rowan, assistant attorney-general for national security.

The five had handed themselves over at a federal court in Salt Lake City, Utah, earlier on Monday.

A sixth Blackwater guard had already pleaded guilty to charges on December 5.

If convicted, the men face 10 years in prison for each manslaughter charge, plus additional sentences for other charges.

The shooting by Blackwater's guards as they escorted a convoy of US diplomats through Baghdad on September 16 2007, angered Iraqis and led US officials to tighten controls on private security firms.

The shooting also enraged the Iraqi government, which wanted to put security contractors under Iraqi legal jurisdiction.

Identity protected

The five men's identities and the nature of the charges against them had been kept secret for more than a year, but were also released on Sunday.

They were named as Evan Liberty and Donald Ball, both 26-year-old former marines; Dustin Heard, a 27-year-old ex-marine; Nick Slatten, 25, an ex-army sergeant; and Paul Slough, a 29-year-old army veteran.

Paul Cassell, a Utah attorney on the defence team, said as the guards were being heard: "We think it's pure and simple a case of self-defence ... Tragically people did die."

IN VIDEO


Blackwater on trial

Khalid Ibrahim, a 40-year-old electrician who said his 78-year-old father, Ibrahim Abid, died in the shooting, said: "The killers must pay for their crime against innocent civilians.

"Justice must be achieved so that we can have rest from the agony we are living in. We know that the conviction of the people behind the shooting will not bring my father to life, but we will have peace in our minds and hearts."

An Iraqi government spokesman said that they believed that the attack was tantamount to deliberate murder.

Ali Al-Dabbagh told Al Jazeera that Baghdad would maintain the victims' right to a fair trial and would not accept anything less than "normal standards available in such cases".

Decorated veterans

The Blackwater guards are decorated war veterans who were contracted to protect US diplomats in Iraq.

FBI investigators found in late 2007 that most of the deaths had been unjustified and the incident created a furore about the perceived ability of private guards to act with impunity in Iraq.

FBI investigators found that most of the 17 deaths in Baghdad had been unjustified
Blackwater said that the guards were returning fire after their convoy was shot at in al-Nisoor Square.

The head of Blackwater appeared before the US congress shortly after the incident, saying that the men acted responsibly.

The case has also been complicated because, at the time of the attack, private contractors like Blackwater operated without any clear legal oversight and it could be argued they did not have to answer either to Iraqi or US laws.

Under the deal Blackwater had with the US government, it was allowed to repair the vehicles involved in the attack before investigators saw them, taking away key forensic evidence.

 Source: Al Jazeera and agencies
Feedback Number of comments : 15
 
ming
United States Minor
09/12/2008
Blackhearts
Paid, armed mercenaries in a nation that did not invite them. These are murderers plain and simple. They do not belong there and must suffer the same fate as the many innocents they murdered.

steve
China
09/12/2008
Wet bus ticket
Come on guys give them a break,these thugs are what make America great,they will be slapped over the hand with a wet bus ticket given loads of dosh and retire in the sun somewhere,do we expect anything else, of course not.There bosses get away with murder everyday,stop buying American goods now.

Euro in US
United States
09/12/2008
Fry Them as we would say in US
There is no excuse for action of these individuals, however they are small "fish" and the main culprits of this and other related tragedies are Wolfowitz the mastermind of Iraq invasion by US, Dick Cheney and George W. Bush and all 3 should be sent to Den Haag to stand trial as War Criminals!!!!

Mohamad Ali Hein
Germany
09/12/2008
US guards charged over Iraq deaths
?????? ?????? as-salamu ?alaikum These so-called Security Co. is nothing other than an Mercenary Supplier and so it should be dealt with !As long as the US provides its Forces with Mercenaries it violate the Geneva Covention and can not be trusted in there Vows to retreat from Iraq !THese Mercenaries are Murderers,paid to kill unarmed Civilians and should be convicted by this Fact !!!

James
New Zealand (Aotearoa)
09/12/2008
Blackwater in Iraq
These poorly educated inexperienced young men committed terrible crimes against innocent civilians in Iraq. Were they young Iraqis committing the same crimes in the USA should be considered. What form of justice then and in which country should they be tried?

Richard
Yemen
09/12/2008
Blackwater
It is not only these five men that are on trial in the US, it is also the US judiciary on trial in the world

Thomas
Norway
09/12/2008
Only ten years for "each" murder?
Is that how little an Iraqi life is worth? OJ Simpson got 15 years +++ for carrying a weapon...

Mo
United Kingdom
09/12/2008
America
It is a war crime going into Iraq. Bush should be put on trial immidiately as he committed a crime and killed upto a million people which is not recorded in American Pentagon files. Billions of dollers has been spent on private contracters and still there is no clean water and electricty. It is Bush's father who provided all the materials and chemicals to Saddam Hussein so why was he the only person hanged. Please look at the history of Bush's family it is interesting and self explanatary.

Stephen M. St. John
United States
09/12/2008
Legal Proceedings against British Bombers of Basra?
Shouldn't the British Bombers of Basra face charges just like these Blackwater lads? They dressed like Arabs and were carrying arms and explosives in their car when caught by Iraqi police. How many bombings have been done by Brits in Iraq to stoke sectarian strife? These lovelies create the problems so they can provide the solutions where there is oil. This is the heart of the matter!

Esmeralda Mohamed
United States
09/12/2008
GUARDS CHARGED
These thugs should have their day in court! when ever innocent civillians are killed by terrorists ,they should be held accountable, nobody is above the law, these terrorists have clearly demonstrated from day one! This time they got caught. In the past there were complains of random civillian killings , but nobody paid attention, this time they got caught. We have a great justice system in this country and justice would prevail.

Ali
Kenya
09/12/2008
Blackwater!
This and million other deaths is Bush's fault. Justice can only be done if Bush and Blair are brought to book. They are the key why Iraq and Afganistan are to day suffering. We hear Al Bashir is wanted for Darfur reason but why Bush and Blair are not considered their mass Murder? Where is Justice? Blackwater is nothing than the reality.

Tam
United States
09/12/2008
US guards charged over Iraqi deaths
According to the US news there is a 6th guard that confessed these were unprovoked murders in exchange for a plea bargin. Hopefully justice will be done for the innocent Iraqis.

Sharmad
United States
09/12/2008
Double standard!
If these men are guilty of murder, they should be punished. I agree with that. See, that's what happens in the US, people who murder innocents are held accountable. But where are all the cries for justice for the Iraqis killed by their fellow Iraqis or foreign insurgents? Most of the people who are condemning these men's actions so fiercely are only doing so because these men are Americans. Were these insurgents, you'd likely have defended their actions or blamed the US for it. Hypocrisy!

Bill Dickerson
United States
09/12/2008
Charges
Unfortunately it seems innocent civilians were killed. No one wants that to happen but one of the insidious methods terrorists use is hiding among civilians and using them as shields. If it's found they acted recklessly I agree they should be punished but I can't see them ever being found guilty. From what I understand after the alleged ambush they left the area immediately. I don't think autopsies were done and I'm not sure a competent investigation was ever completed.

Still Curious
United States
12/12/2008
Blackwater
These are the highest trained men the US has to offer, Seals, Rangers, Green Berets and the like, all have had extensive combat experience and all are cool under fire, they respond to the situation, not instigate it. Their job is to protect whomever they are guarding in transit from embassy to their homes or other safe place. Very few men can qualify and most if not all are decorated, experienced veterans with battle experience of the Afgan and Iraq wars. Let us hear both sides and then decide

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article