UPDATED ON:
Saturday, February 28, 2009
15:10 Mecca time, 12:10 GMT
 
News Americas
US to boycott UN racism conference

Israel and pro-Israeli groups applauded the decision to boycott the conference [GALLO/GETTY]

The United States has decided to boycott an upcoming UN conference on racism unless its final document is changed to drop all references to Israel.

The Conference Against Racism, to be held in Geneva in April, is a follow-up to the conference held in the South African town of Durban in 2001. 

On Friday, a US delegation taking part in the preparatory talks in Geneva, said the draft resolution was unacceptable.

The US and Israeli delegations walked out of the 2001 meeting in protest against the resolution which likened Zionism - the movement to establish and maintain a Jewish state - to racism.

Israel and Canada have already announced they will boycott the conference, which is known as Durban II.

'Not salvageable'

According to Robert Wood, the US state department spokesman, the "document being negotiated has gone from bad to worse, and the current text of the draft outcome document is not salvageable.

"A conference based on this text would be a missed opportunity to speak clearly about the persistent problem of racism."

Wood said the US would not participate in the conference unless its final statement does not criticise any one country or conflict.

The US also did not want the document to take up the issue of reparations for slavery, which was another hot topic in the Durban 2001 conference.

'Anti-Semitic'

Tzipi Livni, the foreign minister, welcomed the decision.

"Under the fig leaf of combating racism, this conference is blatantly anti-Semitic and anti-Israeli," Livni said in a statement on Saturday.

"The decision of the United States should be an example to other countries that share our values."

Pro-Israeli groups also hailed the US move.

"President [Barack] Obama's decision not to send US representation to the April event is the right thing to do and underscores America's unstinting commitment to combating intolerance and racism in all its forms and in all settings," the American Israel Public Affairs Committee said.

The Conference of Presidents, an umbrella group of more than 50 Jewish organisations, said: "It was clear from the preparatory meetings that this conference was again being hijacked by those who want to have a repetition of the first Durban conference, which focused almost singularly on Israel and was the occasion for vile and bigoted declarations and manifestations.

"It is our hope that the European countries will follow suit and announce that they will not participate."

US officials said they are pressing European nations to boycott the conference unless there are revisions to the final statement.

The Netherlands and France have already expressed concern about the contents.

 Source: Agencies
Feedback Number of comments : 29
 
Calum Coburn
Australia
28/02/2009
Shameful
The people of Canada and America should let their Governments know the shame that they are bringing to their people. As a South African from Durban I'm proud that such conferences tackle racism around the world. That any country or people think they are above discussion is arrogant and shows they have something to hide from the world.

Mike Beck
Canada
28/02/2009
I for one will!
Mr Coburn should be relieved to know that I, for one, will definately be letting our government know that I am disappointed in them. I expect, however, little to come of it, as the Canadian government has been more right-wing and pro-Israel than even the Bush administration.

Marjan N.
United Kingdom
28/02/2009
anti-Racism conference
I completely agree with u Calum. The mere fact that the Israelis are scared of this conference is that they know they are doing something wrong, and feel intimidated by the anger that most people feel towards Zionism. I am very disappointed in Obama's decision to boycott this conference. This only feeds into the disparities in the political arena.

Jim
Canada
01/03/2009
Will countries like Malaysia, Burma which have racism built into their laws, also attend? Will there be resolution requesting them to reduce racism? How about the racial policies of the Sudanese in Dafur? Aboriginals in North America? Will the conference be encompassing or narrow minded?

V.T.
Austria
01/03/2009
article incomplete
I'm disappointed that the article did not go into whether the UN conference singles out other countries' issues with minorities or racism, too. After all, if Israel is the only country specifically named, than I could understand U.S., Israel, Canada, the Netherlands, and France's objection. But to Ahmad from Malaysia, I think your comment is a rather simplistic view of the situation. To liken the Obama administration to Bush because of a single conference is a far too hasty rush to judgment.

Noliving
United States
02/03/2009
Oh please people
The US wants all references to any nation too be droped, this isn't an Israel only issue, sudan has racism issues betweens its arabs and blacks and nothing is mentioned, then there is the zimbabwe and the white farmers. The other reason why is because its wants to make criticism of religions a "crime", the US along with Canada sees that is a freedom of speech issue. The US also wants the slavery reparatuibs too be droped. So no this isn't a Israel support issue.

Ken
United States
04/03/2009
US to boycott UN racism conference
So, this is to Matt, your concerned what other folks around the world think of you, as a Canadain. Dude, what does it matter. Your country is correct in denouncing this forum, and here you wither and head to Iceland, which has no opinion, so you will be loved by the rest of the world. Wow, dink dink. You gotta stand up sometimes Matt for what's right. This conferience is wrong, simple. I am an American and have felt the rath of other country's peoples when I travel outside the US. Woopy do.

John
Canada
04/03/2009
US to boycott UN racism conference
Of course muslim nations want single out Israel it's classic sleight of hand. They're by far the worst persecutors. This is just ANOTHER example of Islam trying to force the rest of the (free) world to accomodate their oppressive, anachronistic views. The irony! They have the most with deplorable records on human rights, social services, personal freedoms and racial/religious discrimination. Natually they want to take this opportunity to point fingers. It keep the attention off themselves!

Gim
Yemen
04/03/2009
Arabs are also Semites
I don’t see anything wrong in declaring that Zionism is racism, Israel is an apartheid state, and Israel has committed genocide, either in a conference or outside the conference. The excuse ‘anti Semitic’ is outdated and doesn’t apply anymore. Arabs are also Semites and they are attending the conference.

Stephen
United States
04/03/2009
UN Racism coonference looses
The insistence on using the UN Racism conference as another forum to attack Israel,does nothing more than make the conference irrelevant when these are so many issues of racism around the world that could be discussed.How sad.

Ronnie
United States
04/03/2009
U.N. Racisim
Wow, The arab collition wants to put an end to racisim... I wanna know what they consider racisim, last I heard woman don't vote,non muslims are infidels, and they are above criticism...Smells a little racist to me!

smith
United States
04/03/2009
Zionism
This issue always reminds me of something a Palestinian friend of mine said a few years ago regarding Israel's becoming a state after WWII. He said,"Why didn't they give the Jews Germany?" The answer is complicated I suppose. Though I have found myself wondering the same thing. My friend fasts on Ramadan the same way I go to church at Christmas. He likes to think that is why both of us wonder about such things.

Elly
Sudan
04/03/2009
The Racism Conference
The denial of a nation of people to exist or have an identity has been the cause of many wars including those in the Middle East, Sudan, Bosnia, South Africa and Rwanda. The failure of the UN to comprehend Racism is a betrayal of the children and women who victims of the monster Racism. We in Sudan know what it means to be segregated within our own country and even when we seek refuge outside Sudan. Shame to the UN.

raffey
United States
05/03/2009
U.s boycotts confrense?
Love the coment from alan in U.S on boycott,we shouldnt read to much into this as the U.S does have a black pres.and we know how antisemetic many arab nations are real racism is cowardis and not that obvious as a boycott of a meeting doesnt tell the whole story.

Ahmad
Malaysia
28/02/2009
Obama, another Israeli puppet...
Mr Barack Obama has yet again proven that he is nothing different from George Bush, save that his skin colour and language skills are different from the "Dubya"... Well done, Obama, at least you stopped fooling people early on...

Matt
Canada
01/03/2009
Out of Hand
I don't think that a lot of Canadians realized what they were getting into when they elected a hard-right government in the Fall. The foreign policies it has implemented are bringing Canada nothing but shame abroad, and nobody is even aware! If the government does not change soon, Canadians travelling overseas may soon begin to receive treatment similar to what Americans get. I, for one, might just move to Iceland and naturalize...

Randall
Canada
01/03/2009
Boycott of racism conference
Give me a break here people. This is not a conference on racism - it is a conference to bash Israel. Why is it that Israel is the only country named? Is there no racism in the Muslim world? In Europe? In North America? In Africa? I would have been disappointed if Canada had participated in this farce. Oh, and for the record. Steven Harper's government is not 'hard right' - it is just not as left as some would like.

alan
United States
04/03/2009
racism comference
are you guys serious? you think Israel is one of earth's great racist societies? Many races, including Arabs live in Israel as full citizens. If Durban I focused on Israel it IS antisemitic. Isn't that racist? It's hypocritical. Read "what's worng with Isalm today" by manji. She's a muslim, and talks about her travels in Israel. BTW Clinton just said the US wants a Palestinian state. Stop simply repeating your old hate-the-US rhetoric. Be a true world citizen and think.

Jyle Dupuis
Canada
04/03/2009
Is there a point to having a United Nations. If we are going to continually disagree with the mandates they are putting forth the UN might as well dissolve just like the League of Nations. It's a harsh reality to come to terms with but the Zionists are just as racist as the Nazi.

Paul Chislett
Afghanistan
04/03/2009
Zionism
The issue here is that Zionism is one more racist policy in a world full of them, past and present. Israel is getting all the attention just now because they have just committed war crimes as an expression of Zionist intentions to eliminate the Palestinians - which is genocide. Many Canadians are distraught over the Harper regime's anti-democratic stance both domestically and internationally. Canadian political and economic elites have control right now.

Dr Bob/ BELIZE CITY
Afghanistan
04/03/2009
US to boycott UN racism conference
Why is anyone surprised.. The USA, Israel, Canada et al are perhaps the worst countries to admit their racist attitudes. They do not want anyone to call them on their genocide actions whether it be in Palestine, Iraq or Afganistan. They have a simple belief, if they keep denying these actions often enough, they will soon believe their own lies. Let them boycott, doesn't matter because the world knows who they are and what they have done. We will soon see Israel in court for war crimes.

Jerseygirl
Afghanistan
04/03/2009
racism conference
Funny how a conference set up to presumably combat racism is only serving to magnify and exacerbate the problem. How ironic!

monirul islam
Bangladesh
04/03/2009
feedback
It is realy a shame for america not to participate in the conference on eradicating racism.US again prove that they do not want to eradicate racism from world and a great ally of Israel.It will reflect a negative image in the world.

Dr Reality Check
Israel
05/03/2009
US not going to UN conference
A UN conference on racism should address racism. Israel is a racist apartheid dictatorship and is beginning to strongly resemble Nazi Germany in the 1930s. The US should deal with reality and recognize who it's allies actually are.

Emmad
Afghanistan
05/03/2009
US to boycott UN Conference on Racism
The article doesn't talk about other countries because they haven't boycotted the conference, at least for the time being. Certainly we can expect that issues related to problems of racism in their countries will be addressed in this conference rather than just assume that this is only going to be a get together to bash Israel. United Nations if I recall correctly, means all member nations.

Yasir
Malaysia
05/03/2009
UN.........
UN who cares what UN do or think ....UN is nothing but a leagal and safe way to fullfill the illegal desires of rich and powerfull countries like US........ we

Jenkins
New Zealand (Aotearoa)
05/03/2009
Zionists
Why the public outcry against apartheid is South Africa, but not here, how can apartheid not be racist? Zionists always refer to anti-Zionists as Anti-Semites. Its their get out of jihad free card.

Benmimoun
Australia
05/03/2009
what do you expect? we all know that Israel and USA are the same thing when it relates to racism and other things

Steve
United States
31/03/2009
Racism
It's incredible and very sad that anyone can honestly believe that the most racist Nation in the World is Israel. A country of 7 million people in a world of 6.75 billion receives 99% of the criticism and the harshest condemnation. Israel does have its problems but, they pale to the overtly racist regimes in many other countries. The worst thing about this is that the real issues of racism, reflected in the suffering of hundreds of millions of people, are masked and suffocated by this tire

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article