UPDATED ON:
Saturday, March 21, 2009
23:32 Mecca time, 20:32 GMT
 
News Americas
Iran's leader dismisses Obama offer

As the supreme leader, Khamenei is believed to hold the last word on major Iranian policy decisions [EPA]

Iran's supreme leader has dismissed overtures from the US president, saying Tehran does not see any change in US policy under Barack Obama's administration.

Ayatollah Ali Khamenei said in a speech on Saturday that there could be no change in US-Iran relations unless Obama puts an end to US hostility towards Iran and brings "real changes" in US foreign policy.

He made the remarks in a televised speech in the city of Mashhad to mark the Iranian New Year.

Commenting on Obama's videotaped offer of a "new beginning" in relations between the two countries, Khamenei said Iran has yet to see any change in Washington's attitude towards it.

"They chant the slogan of change but no change is seen in practice. We haven't seen any change," he said.

Khamenei criticised US behaviour towards Iran since its 1979 Islamic revolution, saying that the US was "hated in the world" and should stop interfering in other countries' internal affairs.

He asked how Obama could congratulate Iranians on the new year while the US continues to accuse the country of supporting terrorism and seeking nuclear weapons.

Saying that a change of US words was not enough, Khamenei said:  "We will watch and we will judge ... You change, our behaviour will change."

Nuclear disagreement

The US is at odds with Iran over its nuclear programme, which Washington says is aimed at building atomic weapons, while Tehran insists it is for the peaceful generation of electricity.

It is also concerned over Iran's missile-development efforts.

The US cut off diplomatic ties with Iran during the 1979-1981 hostage crisis, in which a group of Iranian students held 52 US diplomats hostage at the American embassy for 444 days.

Your views

Will Obama's new approach towards Iran improve relations, or will animosity continue?

Send us your views

Khamenei said that tests at the Bushehr nuclear plant in the south of the country had convinced other nations that its nuclear plans would not be abandoned.

"This is the results of the progress of our scientists ... which persuaded the whole world that the path of Iran's nuclear progress could not be blocked," he said.

Obama released a video message on Nowruz, the traditional Persian New Year, offering to resolve past conflicts.

"My administration is now committed to diplomacy that addresses the full range of issues before us, and to pursuing constructive ties," he said in the message.

Obama's administration earlier expressed an openness to face-to-face diplomatic contacts with Tehran.

It marks a major shift from the policy pursued by George Bush, Obama's predecessor, towards Iran, which he once branded as part of an "axis of evil".

'Rightful place'

In his video appeal, Obama said the US wanted Iran to take its "rightful place in the community of nations".

"This process will not be advanced by threats," he said. "We seek instead engagement that is honest and grounded in mutual respect."

Obama said US wants Iran to take its rightful place in the community of nations [Reuters]

But Obama also insisted that Tehran do its part to achieve reconciliation.

"You have that right - but it comes with real responsibilities, and that place cannot be reached through terror or arms, but rather through peaceful actions that demonstrate the true greatness of the Iranian people and civilisation," he said.

"The measure of that greatness is not the capacity to destroy, it is your demonstrated ability to build and create."

Commenting on Khamenei's rejection of Obama's offer, Mohammad Marandi, a Tehran university professor, told Al Jazeera: "It was expected. Iran has many grievances. A change in tone is not really enough.

"He [Khamenei] said if the US changes its policy ... especially towards Israel and the Palestinian people, the Iranians can move forward.

"I think if the Americans do make a significant move the Iranians will be willing to look towards better relations".

 Source: Al Jazeera and agencies
Feedback Number of comments : 7
 
Cody
United States
21/03/2009
Dismissing Obama offer
Ayatollah Ali Khamenei is correct. To me Obama is all talk, talk and talk. Yes, he is doing a lot for Americans... but Americans are not the only people in this world. I am talking about foreign affairs. Obama has the position to be a great President, but so far he has not been doing the right thing in foreign affairs. He wants Iran-America relations to change, Ayatollah Khamenei is right to say he must support his words with actions... he can start by cleaning up Israel's mess.

Karen
United States
21/03/2009
Irans leader dismisses Obama offer
obama is a fake, a phony, a wimp. Why didn't he just twitter Iran's leader? It's ridiculous that the president of the united states actually thought that sending a video is the right thing to do. obama doesn't offer change, he offers the same as the bush regime. The american people have been duped and I'm happy to see that Iran hasn't been duped.

glen roberts
United States
21/03/2009
US arrogance
Obama's lecture to Iran sounds as arrogant as ever. The US has missiles. Pakistan has missiles. Israel has missiles. Why can't Iran have missiles? And who is Obama to say? He clearly believes he is really the "leader of the free world," and the place Iran must take among nations is at his feet. That's not a position of "mutual respect." It's too bad Iran, like the US and Israel, is a dangerously religious state. But it's the UN's place to deal with that. Glen Roberts, nottalkradio.com

Alabama John
United States
21/03/2009
Obama asks for change Iran agrees Now ball in Obamas court
Surely, for example President Obama could offer to take all our A-bombs out of Israel in exchange for open inspection. An impossible thing for him to do, as a teller of fiction would he appear what with all his false claims that Iran was building nuclear weapons. And so, how can our President make any change, when it would establish that he has absolutely no intention to change?

Matthew Houston
United States
21/03/2009
Not a Dismissal
Newspapers are so dramatic. It's not a rejection at all. What do they expect, that Iran just starts sending flowers and skywriting Obama's name? I don't think Obama expected that, but the press loves drama, so it's either a breakthrough or utter failure.

Jackie
United States
21/03/2009
WHO CAN BLAME HIM AFTER WHAT THE US HAS DONE
Obama will have to earn the trust of the Supreme Leader. I remember who the President of Iran offered an Olive Branch to Bush and was slapped twice. Now the US knows how it feels. Obama's actions will have to speak as then I think the wise Supreme Leader will take the step forward. I would be carefull too as Bush was a slick evil crimiinal who used the respect the US had to hurt others. I'm still keeping an eye on Obama/Biden as they have to earn our trust also. 8 years of a President's lies

J.
United States
21/03/2009
cant say we didnt try
Obama opens his hand to Iran and Khamenei only clenches his fist tighter. There is really no dealing with these people. Iran is in no position to be making demands.

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article