UPDATED ON:
Wednesday, November 19, 2008
12:21 Mecca time, 09:21 GMT
News CENTRAL/S. ASIA
Tribal role urged in Afghanistan
There has been widespread acknowledgement military efforts alone will not defeat the Taliban [AFP]

The senior commander of international forces in Afghanistan has said supporting local leaders could be the key to halting the growing violence across the country.

General David McKiernan of the US army on Tuesday laid out a strategy that advocated engaging with what he called "small-t" Taliban fighters and bringing together tribal leaders.

He said he was talking to Afghan ministers about bringing district leaders into a tribal council backed by international development aid. 

"Reconciliation at the local level, of local fighters, of local influencers, potentially is a very, very powerful metric," McKiernan told the Washington-based Atlantic Council of the United States.

"This is a country that historically has had very little central government. But it's a country with a history of local autonomy and local tribal authority systems."

Taliban talks

Some Afghan and international officials have backed direct talks with the Taliban movement, which was forced from power by a US-led invasion in 2001.

On Tuesday, Mullah Omar, the fugitive leader of the group, rejected an offer from Hamid Karzai, the Afghan president, of protection and said foreign troops must leave before negotiations can begin.

McKiernan acknowledged that the 70,000-strong force in Afghanistan could not succeed in tackling the rising Taliban violence without support from local leaders and ordinary people.

"We're not going to run out of bad people in Afghanistan that have bad intentions and we're not going to kill and capture so many of these bad people that it's going to break the will of all the insurgent groups," he said.

However, McKiernan did not go as far as suggesting working with the Taliban leadership to restore order.

He likened his plan to workening with the so-called Awakening movements fighting al-Qaeda in Iraq, but warned against arming tribes to fight against the Taliban.

The general has asked for four additional combat brigades and support forces - about 20,000 troops - to join the fight in Afghanistan and said that international forces could still be successful. 

Barack Obama, the US president-elect, has promised to transfer troops from Iraq to Afghnaistan once he takes power in January, but Jaap de Hoop Scheffer, the Nato chief, has urged other nations to support the mission.

"No strategy will work if it is not matched by the right resources," he said on Tuesday.

"All of us, all the Nato allies, need to make greater efforts to the military, economic and civilian development [of Afghanistan]."

 Source: Agencies
 
Topics in this article
People

Country

Organisation

Feedback Number of comments : 10
 
Jim Fraser
United Kingdom
19/11/2008
TOO LITTLE TOO LATE
It's not as though the United States does not has people who understand tribal society. Their country has its own tribal lands under independent administration. Maybe they should have deployed only senior US officers who had been brought up on an Indian Reservation.

Ayub
Afghanistan
20/11/2008
Tribal role essential.
Tribal role is essential in order to bring stability in Afghanistan.But the int'l forces need to leave these affairs to the Afghans.They can handle this on their own.I disagree with Tariq on this issue.The US & NATO have murdered and pillaged Afghanistan,their interests lie in oil pipeline and maybe Heroin as well.I don't think they are there to help the Afghans get the country in order.Get out and let the Afghans sort out their own affairs,if they kill each other so be it.Let them handle it....

Mirwais
Afghanistan
20/11/2008
It is not Iraq
No way, this is not going to work, surge of troops can never eleminate a nation, as unjustified US/Coalition policies already converted the big segment of nation to thier enemies. This is proved in History, and this is not a rational and applicable one for Afghanistan. Afghanistan is not Iraq, over there you worked to gain minority's support in Iraq and in Afghanistan you lost the support of prevailing Majority ( Pashtoons ). No success in this formula.

Allison
United States
21/11/2008
Tribal role in Afghanistan
Back in 2001 I was talking to a military commander in a store about this. I explained that when dealing with tribal peoples there were protocols one had to follow to ensure successful engagement and alliance. As a Native American of Cherokee descent, I grew up in a tribal culture. I gave this Army officer several examples of such protocols and why they were so important- proper respect for the people of the land must be given. The cowboy diplomacy of the past 7 years hasn't worked, has it?

Bigmel1981
Malaysia
19/11/2008
Tribal role urged in Afghanistan
There is no war in Afghan. pull out and end the occupation.

Tariqf Faisal
Afghanistan
19/11/2008
Tribal role urged in Afghanistan
We'll we always support US strategy for brining peace in Afghanistan. But it's none Pakistanis' business to give comments . We know what to do. I am telling this to PK go and bring peace to your country and stopp bagging in order to support the so called Taliban ,otherwise you will be deepened to Shiittt. Like Russia

George Washington
Afghanistan
20/11/2008
Bigmel1981....
I don't even know what to say....No war? You must have an interesting definition. But really, you need to stop spewing your ideas on every single AJ article. They are always stereotypical and rarely accurate or even relevent. I hope they're posting you because they think it's funny.

yJaved
Pakistan
20/11/2008
Tribal role urged in Afghanistan
Tariqf Faisal i mean you should feel shame that u talking abt country whose people always support you during ur hard times and give refugee and jobs to over 5 million of ur people and still have 3 milion afghan refugee...fight ur war with soviet and scrafice with there life and wealth.. just shame on people like u who never count what pakistanies have done for you and still are doing... and also note this that reason for unrest in paksitan is none but afghanistan and afghanies.

Ahmed
Afghanistan
20/11/2008
Tribal Support
this is to relate some of the comments opined by Tariq and Javed in response to Tariq. I totally agree with every single word uttered by Javed on this particular subject. I understand Afghans history and the nature of the nation, very dissappointingly afghans are the most unthankful nation ever lived, yet so arrogant and derogative over other nations. Come on, can one of you ever appreciate.Never I guess.

abdullah
Afghanistan
23/11/2008
Tribal role urged in Afghanistan
i dont think thats the way to solve this crisis, we know from where the problem comes, (tribal areas Pakistan). you cant cure disease with disease, the interantional community and the Government worked hard for 7 years to disarm people and now they want to rearm a specific ethnic, about Tariq and Javed , we do appreciate what Pakistani people did for Afghans but what we dont appreciate is what ISI and Army did to Us, ( creating Taleban and helping Hekmatyar), you guys benifited from Afghan prese

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article
Aljazeera.net/english 2003 - 2010 ©
Designed & Developed by Aljazeera IT