UPDATED ON:
Wednesday, October 01, 2008
19:07 Mecca time, 16:07 GMT
 
News Europe
The ugly side of resurgent Russia?

A column of Russian tanks on the march to Tskhinvali, the capital of South Ossetia [EPA]

Tbilisi has desperately sought international support since Russian forces moved into Georgia after the Georgian army launched an offensive to bring separatist South Ossetia, which broke away in the early 1990s, back under government control.

Mark Seddon, Al Jazeera's diplomatic correspondent, says Georgia's actions had clearly been anticipated by Moscow and that the Russian response may be an ominous portent of its future foreign policy.

There should be an iron rule for all journalists, commentators and politicians when discussing the crisis in Georgia, especially when in the United States, where I am now.

It is this, make it absolutely clear that you know which Georgia you are talking about.

The looks of horror that have crossed peoples faces here when I have told them that Russia 'has invaded Georgia' is something to behold.

Seddon's Diplomatic diary

Part 1: Spain finds her voice in victory

Part 2: Sarkozy reaches for the stars

Part 3: Beijing: Nothing left to chance

This is not to trivialise the conflict that has erupted, but simply to remind ourselves of what was once said about Czechoslovakia as the Nazis prepared to invade the country after Neville Chamberlain, the British prime minister, had given his blessing. 

Namely, that it was 'a faraway country of which we know little'.

Brutally, the same may be said about Georgia and, more so, of the two breakaway provinces of South Ossetia and Abkhazia. 

For Zbigniew Brzezinski, a former national security adviser to Jimmy Carter, the former US president, and now a foreign policy adviser to presidential hopeful Barak Obama, has apparently compared Vladimir Putin to Adolf Hitler.

Now Russia is, of course, in breach of international law, and having invaded a sovereign state, albeit one with sizeable pro-Russian enclaves, it is bound to expect a furious response from the West.

But Brzezinski, as a product of the Cold War, is unwise to make such sweeping claims, not least because Georgia is not Czechoslovakia and Russia is not the old Soviet Union.

Nato encirclement 

Whether or not Western leaders like it, the increasingly autocratic political leadership in Moscow is reacting to what it sees as a gradual encirclement by Nato.

The military alliance is moving steadily eastwards, and a new generation of long- range missiles are being prepared for deployment in what were Warsaw Pact member states.

Russia feels increasingly encircled by Nato's eastward expansion [AP]
Moscow is not of course going to send the tanks into Prague or Budapest again.

But recent history in the Caucasus suggests that on the inner fringes of the old Soviet bloc, where there are substantial Russian minorities, Moscow is not going to surrender them, and may use them to weaken what it sees as pro-Western governments.

To which should be added something else; in those disputed areas with Russian minorities, those who stand in the way may be forced to leave.

The untold story of both South Ossetia and Abkhazia is how those breakaway provinces have been emptied of their pro-Georgian populations, and how Russia has distributed passports for those who remain.

Olympic blunder

In retrospect, the move by Mikhail Saakashvili, the Georgian leader, to reign in South Ossetia when he thought that the rest of the world would be distracted by the opening of the Olympics in Beijing, was one of the least smart moves he could have made - particularly as it had clearly been anticipated by Moscow.

A sensible policy of co-existence may not have assuaged nationalists in both Georgia and Russia, but it has to be a better way ahead than the vicious conflict that has now probably led to the informal, but permanent annexation of Georgian territory by Russia.

This is not to excuse, but to try and understand.

It may also be timely for Georgia, which, like Ukraine, wants membership of Nato.

Had Georgia actually been a member, Nato members could have been called upon to come to the country's aid.

Worrying foretaste

A nightmare scenario of a Nato conflict with Russia over breakaway provinces in Georgia should at the very least make Nato planners think very carefully about further expansion.

Russia is saying 'so far and no further' [EPA]
It may be one thing to occasionally poke the Russian bear when it is weak, quite another to get into its cage when it is beginning to feel stronger and more confident.

Historians may look back at this period, and describe something that we may like to call the 'Kosovo Doctrine'.

Moscow was opposed to the independence of Kosovo, despite the fact that most Kosovans wanted it, for Moscow was determined to stand by its old Slav ally Serbia, and wanted to send a warning to others in the former Soviet Union.
 
The new Russia is not the plural democracy that many of its founders had hoped for.

If Boris Yeltsin clumsily allowed the Perestroika and reform of Mikhail Gorbachev to disintegrate on his watch, as Gorbachev had himself allowed the Soviet Union to disintegrate without a proper plan for dealing with the fallout from that process, the new bosses in the Kremlin, appear to be saying 'so far and no further'.

This is not a pleasant sight, and Russia's raw and ugly power displayed by its iron-fist policy in Georgia, may be a foretaste of much to come.

 Source: Al Jazeera
Feedback Number of comments : 19
 
George Ihlefeldt
United States
15/08/2008
Did the U.S. provoke the whole thing?
We`ve got 5 more months of Bush. Let`s hope we get through the weekend without a nuclear war. Somehow, it`s that "self-righteous"U.S. tone that leads to ones worst fear that little men with a pre-WWI mentality are playing power games, again.

Paul M
Ukraine
15/08/2008
The ugly side of resurgent Russia
Mr. Bhattacharya should recall that it was the United Nations that intervened in Korea, not simply the United States there was an international mandate in that case as there was for Kuwait during the first Gulf war. That being said, the US really has no leg to stand on in the Russo-Georgian conflict given the pretexts it gave for its invasion and occupation of Iraq in 2003. On the other hand, Russia's actions must be condemned given they are far out of proportion in response to the situation.

robrthernandez
Afghanistan
15/08/2008
ugly side,russian spin of tyrants
And the USA has no regrets and would do it again help the oppressed ,and again. Heaven forbid if we would have not. Russia offers no pretense, but the Russian boot. The Talaban as an example offers total slavery of free men and women. N Korea, give me a break! We choose Freedom, not tyranny

Lee Brewer
United States
16/08/2008
aggression
South Korea would say they are better off for having the UN (not only the USA) assist. Vietnam is seeking the tourist dollar because they are in a state of peace. MidEast is the victim of broken promises and treachery from European, Turkish, and MidEastern countries. Americans are newcomers to 2 centuries of bad faith actions. Does our Afghanistani really believe that Americans killed innocent millions like Stalin did? Never..

M Schubert
United States
16/08/2008
Good Article... Comment is Baloney
D.B. needs a history lesson. While not spotless, review your history on the listed "attacks". Russian dominated Soviet Union encouraged N Korea to attack S Korea for ex. There's also a dramatic difference between the treatment by the occupier. Take any country occupied by the US vs the Soviet Union post WW2 as an example. Russians built walls to keep citizens of member states in. They had to send tanks in to crush uprisings. Whereas West Germany, & Japan became free, economic powerhouses.

frank villa
United States
17/08/2008
russia resurgence
ever since the Spanish and the English set a sail it has always been about natural resources either controlling or extracting from another country to meet a supply and demand. the english did it in india, the US took over the republic of hawaii and along with william Randolph hearst falsified his media machine to wage war with spain. we the US need to keep to our selves and make out country a better place internally! stop worrying about other people!

Mike
Afghanistan
18/08/2008
The Ugly Side of Resurgent Russia
"...recent history in the Caucasus suggests that on the inner fringes of the old Soviet bloc, where there are substantial Russian minorities, Moscow is not going to surrender them" While their are some transplanted Russians in many parts of the former Eastern Bloc, Ossetians are not Russians any more than Tibetans would be US citizens if the US gave out passorts like Candy in Western China. Ossentians speak a language close to Farsi (yes, Farsi!) and are not Russian no matter what the Russians s

Debashis Bhattacharya
Afghanistan
13/08/2008
Amazing double standard
If Russia has broken international law by attacking Georgia, and Putin is comparable to Adolf Hitler, exactly how many hundreds of international law have been broken by every NATO country, especially USA, by attacking: 1. Korea, 2. Vietnam, 3. Cambodia, 4. Nicaragua, 5. Chile, 6. Grenada, 7. Panama, 8. Lebanon, 9. Iraq, 10. Afganisthan, just to name a few among the dozens of countries that have been attacked by USA & NATO, overtly and covertly, over past 50+ years? Is Mark Seddon that naive?

Alexander Harper
Australia
15/08/2008
Georgia
Debashis makes an excellent point,while the language used to describe the Russian actions, especially amongst western media, creates an atmosphere sympathetic to Georgia,one has to look at the situation in context.The fact that there are even small pro-Russian populations in South Ossetia and Abkhazia provides far more justification for the Russian response than seen in many American or Nato wars. The Georgian actions were foolish,and show people have forgotten that there are limits to US power.

Max S
United States
15/08/2008
Political Stunt
It looks like the Bush Administration is trying to keep the republicans in power by antagonizing the relationship between Georgia and Russia. As soon as Georgia attacked S Ossetia and Russia responded, the news started coming in about "Russian tanks breaking into Georgia", which resulted in the media hysteria, involving topics such as "Return of the Soviet Union" and "The beginning of the New Cold War". Now McCain has an upper hand, because Americans see republicans as better wartime leaders.

Dan Breen
United Kingdom
15/08/2008
The ugly side of resurgent Russia?
To Debashis Bhattacharya, You examples of US "attacks" are flawed as Korea & Lebanon were UN mandated while Nicaragua and Chile did not involve direct action by US troops. Vietnam and Grenada were at the request of the recognised government of the country. Cambodia, Panama and Afghanistan were attacked, (Cambodia unofficially), for providing material support to groups or nations directly responsible for attacking America or America's physical interests, leaving you with Iraq. Nice try.

Ferhat
Germany
15/08/2008
US war preparation
The building up of missle shield systems in eastern europe (its not pointed at arab world, look at the map) and the exaggerated threats to "help" georgia against Russia look like the US seeking military confrontation with its historically greatest enemy. It is typical for the Bush Administration to think that such a war is doable with the possibility of eliminating all the risks for the US due to technical advancement. They are wrong....

Snijder
Netherlands
15/08/2008
Russian boots
The last thing the world needs is the return the Russian "liberating" armies and their wonderful political system. Russia has put oil on the fire in the world by denying any solution to the world problems, unrelentless support for ethnic cleansing, cluster bombs, racism, seperatists, (war)criminals, the corrupt and dictators. Russia's friends are the outcasts and the autocrats. I would rather have the US as a friend than Russia as my neighbour

Arup Mukherjee
India
15/08/2008
It is not Russia but Gerogia who violated the international law in south ossetia. Actually Tblisi thought when washington is backing them them have nobody to care on the Earth. As a result, It got the the due punishment.

Peters Vecrumba
United States
16/08/2008
Re: Debashis Bhattacharyas comment
The U.S. started the Korean conflict? Amazingly uninformed. Furthermore, by refusing to negotiate with the legitimate head of Georgia's government, Russia is pushing to install a malleable regime answerable to Moscow. Classic Stalinist technique.

Sally Anne Hamath
United Kingdom
17/08/2008
Bushs nod and a wink
Just like Bush senior gave a nod and a wink to the pitiful Kurds to rise against Saddam Hussein and did nothing when they did and suffered mercilessly, Bush junior too gave the nod and a wink to Tskhinvaali to confront Russia and once again US is powerless to do anything. Bush is all talk and no deed.

Gail L
United States
17/08/2008
The inaccurate Kosovo analogy
The author needs to be reminded that the UN engaged in protracted mediation of the conflict, and produced a detailed plan for "conditional independence" and guarantees for the Serbian minority, which was rejected by Serbia. Only then did Kosovo declare independence, and the Serb minority is treated rather decently and protected by NATO/KFOR forces.

richard columbare
United States
17/08/2008
resurgent russia
when russia saw the united states invade afganistan and then iraq over the objections of the U.N. and the Pope,and then say the Geneva convention does'nt apply. Then why would they or should they listen to anything the west has to say? There is a saying, that sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander.

Dave
Netherlands
17/08/2008
Nato did never attack
Debashis Bhattacharya should first learn about history before writing a comment. "The first NATO military operation caused by the conflict in the former Yugoslavia was Operation Sharp Guard, which ran from June 1993–October 1996. All the other conflicts you are mentioning, NATO was not involved. In Afganistan Nato is present as a peace keeping force. I hope you appriciate our soldiers are dying for your freedom. So do not talk nonsence and learn about history !!

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article