UPDATED ON:
Sunday, August 17, 2008
13:53 Mecca time, 10:53 GMT
 
News Europe
Confusion over Russian 'withdrawal'

Russian troops have the right to patrol "a few kilometres" inside Georgia [AFP]

There is confusion over the Russian deployment inside Georgia after an army commander said that troops had been ordered to withdraw following a ceasefire deal. 

"The columns are moving from Tskhinvali to Russia," Major-General Vyachislav Borisov, a Russian commander, said on Sunday.

"[President Dmitry] Medvedev has said we are to withdraw," he told the Reuters news agency near the Georgian town of Gori.

However, Al Jazeera's Nazanine Moshiri, reporting from North Ossetia, said that when she headed out of the region late on Saturday Russian columns could be seen heading towards Tskhinvali.

A witness in the South Ossetian capital Tskhinvali also told Al Jazeera that the only troop movements on Sunday appeared to be heading south rather than north back into Russia.

Irina Gagloyeva, a spokesman for the South Ossetian defence ministry, told Russia's Itar-Tass news agency that she had no information about any withdrawal but that South Ossetian police were replacing Russian peacekeepers in Tskhinvali.

Two of Russia's state-controlled news agencies also issued conflicting reports about plans to withdraw.

Itar-Tass quoted an unidentified Russian defence ministry official as saying non-essential Russian military units were departing, but Interfax quoted an unidentified official from the same ministry as saying there had been no withdrawal.

Russian peacekeepers

In the Georgian town of Gori, about 30km from the breakaway region of South Ossetia, Borisov said that Russian regular forces were being replaced by Russian peacekeepers. 

Map

 

Key locations in the conflict

But tanks and armoured personnel carriers were still in place around the town and on the road south towards the Georgian capital Tbilisi.

"We are hearing from Russian military contacts around the town that the troops in Georgia are considered to be last in, so they will be the last out," Al Jazeera's Alan Fisher, reporting from inside Gori, said.

"In Gori itself there is still a very high Russian presence ... you can still see many Russian troops, they are digging trenches, their armoured personnel carriers, their tanks are now well hidden under camouflage."

The six-point peace pact, signed by Medvedev on Saturday, requires all forces in Georgia to withdraw to positions held prior to the conflict, which began on August 7 after Georgian forces began a bombardment of the breakaway region of South Ossetia.

Under the deal, Russian troops, which entered the conflict to support the South Ossetian separatists, have the right to patrol "a few kilometres" deeper inside Georgia beyond the South Ossetia conflict zone, Georgian and French officials said on Saturday.

Troop deployment

Kakha Lomaia, secretary of the Georgian security council, told the Reuters news agency that some of the Russian force in Gori had been redeployed to Khashuri and Akhalgori, effectively widening their presence in Georgia.

Russian troops were reported to effectively control the city and air base of Senaki, which which sits on a key intersection controlling access to the Black Sea port city of Poti and the road north to Abkhazia.

Russia also confirmed on Sunday that troops had taken over a major power plant in western Georgia.

"What we see on the ground clearly shows that Russia is not abiding by the ceasefire that its president has signed ... as of today we are not seeing any reversal of this threat, we are not seeing any withdrawal at all," Shota Utiashvili, Georgia's interior ministry spokesman, told Al Jazeera

The French-drafted ceasefire agreement signed on Saturday calls for an end to all military action, free access to humanitarian aid. It also calls for a demilitarised border zone.

Security measures

Sergei Lavrov, the Russian foreign minister, confirmed that Medvedev signed and ordered the implementation of the ceasefire deal, but said Russian troops would not withdraw until Moscow was satisfied that security measures it forces are allowed to take under the agreement are effective.

Russian troops were seen heading to Tskhinvali despite ceasefire reports [AFP]
"As these additional security measures are taken, the units of the Russian armed forces that were sent into the zone of the South Ossetian conflict ... will be withdrawn," he said.

"We are constantly encountering problems from the Georgian side, and everything will depend on how effectively and quickly these problems are resolved."

Even if Russian forces do withdraw from the rest of Georgia, Moscow appears likely to maintain strong control over the provinces.

Lavrov said on Thursday that Georgia can "forget about" South Ossetia and Abkhazia, which broke away from Georgian government control during wars in the early 1990s.

Moscow, which firmly backs South Ossetia and Abkhazia, has issued Russian passports to most people in the two territories.

 Source: Al Jazeera and agencies
Feedback Number of comments : 1
 
Borksy
Canada
17/08/2008
The Confusion belongs to Aljazeera
A certain amount of Aljazeera's reporting on Russia's presence in Georgia has been obviously speculatory recently. It has not been Aljazeera's finest moment in selecting the best reporters. Choosing the best available in the area is not always a better choice than choosing none at all. Clearly, Russia would want a timely consolidation of its power in the area, but would have no interest in prolonging its military image there. That is not confusing at all.

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article