UPDATED ON:
Thursday, August 21, 2008
21:02 Mecca time, 18:02 GMT
 
News Europe
Nato denies 'friendly fire' deaths

Sarkozy, right, says he has "no regrets" about sending 700 more troops to Afghanistan [AFP]

Nato has denied a newspaper report that allied planes killed 10 French soldiers during a Taliban ambush in Afghanistan.

Carmen Romero, a Nato spokeswoman, said on Thursday: "As far as Nato and Isaf [International Security Assistance Force] are concerned, the allegations in Le Monde are completely unfounded."

"We deny the report ... we have no information whatsoever that would indicate that the French soldiers were killed by Nato planes."

France's Le Monde newspaper on Wednesday quoted French soldiers who had survived the ambush earlier in the week near Kabul, saying they were hit in a "friendly fire" incident.

The soldiers told the newspaper they waited for four hours for backup after being ambushed.

When Nato aircraft finally arrived, they hit French troops after missing their target, the newspaper quoted the soldiers as saying.

Charges denied

Bryan Whitman, a Pentagon spokesman, on Wednesday said: "We have no reports of any casualties caused by close air support."

Asked whether French soldiers had been killed or wounded by friendly fire, he said there were "no reports of that".

Romero, a Nato spokeswoman, on Thursday said: "None of the wounds sustained by those killed or wounded were consistent with air delivery ordnance".

"No French soldier, at any time during the incident, came on the radio to say that they were taking friendly fire and no French soldier after the event has mentioned to the chain of command that this might have been the case," she said.

Herve Morin, France's defence minister, on Thursday also denied the soldiers had to wait four hours for backup.

"Fifteen to 20 minutes after the engagement of our forces, a support section left the base camp and took around 40 to 50 minutes to get to the scene," he told French radio station RTL.

'No regrets'

The comments came a day after Nicolas Sarkozy, the French president, visited survivors of the incident - the deadliest attack on French troops in 25 years - at a military base on the outskirts of Kabul.

Speaking from Kabul, where he met Hamid Karzai, Afghanistan' president, Sarkozy said he had no regrets about sending 700 reinforcements to the French contingent, adding: "If it had to be done again, I would do it.

"This is where the fight against terrorism is being waged."

Sarkozy's decision in April, after heavy pressure from Nato allies, to send an extra 700 French troops to Afghanistan, to bring their number to about 3,000, was
hugely unpopular in his country.

Opinion polls showed a large majority of French opposed the move, with many fearing that France would get bogged down in an unending war whose aims were unclear or unattainable.

About 70,000 international troops are fighting alongside Afghan security forces against Taliban fighters whose government was removed in a US-led invasion in 2001.

 Source: Al Jazeera and agencies
Feedback Number of comments : 8
 
Vera Gottlieb
Germany
22/08/2008
NATO denies friendly fire deaths
The more a story is denied, the more we know it is true. Rather shameful that this people don't have what it takes to stand up and admit. Lies and deceptions...the hallmarks of the 21st century.

go sweden
Sweden
22/08/2008
Vera Gottlieb
true true i am sorry to say thats how tha world works.

Karma Kunga Dondrub Trulnang Gyalpo OR Sherpa
Canada
22/08/2008
Friendly Fire Fibbing
NO KIDDING VERA !!

madushanthi
India
22/08/2008
Nato,s friendly file
It is good to denie - as it provides a good opertunity to bomb and kill more inocent people including small children. That is the reason for the deniel.

Terry
Canada
23/08/2008
friendly fire
During WW II there was a saying, When the Germans flew over the British would duck for cover. When the British flew over the Germans would duck for cover. When the USA flew over everyone would duck for cover. It looks the things have not changed very much.

Quinn
Canada
22/08/2008
Vera, how do you expect to get through life being so distrustful? People with your mindset already have their minds made up, which is supremely dishonest. In your opinion, if NATO confirms these claims, they are guilty, and if they deny these claims, they're still guilty? I am from Canada, and Canadian troops have been attacked [misidentified] by US aircraft twice now, and we have suffered heavy casualties as a result. NATO never denied these friendly fire incidents.

sameen
India
23/08/2008
French relief
French should feel relieved. Dying at the hands of backward,underfed Afghans would be insulting. Whereas dying at the hand of the Americans is a blessing- a blessing that bestows 'enduring freedom' as they say.

chuck
Afghanistan
24/08/2008
NATO/French deaths
So why is this even a story? Not even the French government thinks that this rumor is true! Does the Arab world think that there is some American conspiracy to kill its NATO allies? No . . . sadly this is just more propaganda from the Middle East meant to maintain an anti-US attitude in the region.

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article