UPDATED ON:
Tuesday, October 21, 2008
00:01 Mecca time, 21:01 GMT
 
News Europe
Chaos at Turkey coup plot trial
The trial is being held in a special hall at the
Silivri Prison complex near Istanbul [AFP]

The trial of 86 people accused of conspiring to overthrow Turkey's government has been adjourned until October 23 after chaotic scenes at the first hearing.

Within minutes of opening on Monday, lawyers and defendants complained that they could not hear in the overcrowded courtroom at a prison complex in Silivri, near Istanbul.

Judge Koksal Sengun asked spectators to vacate the room and, following an adjournment, proceedings started again in the afternoon.

Those on trial include a retired general, the leader of a small leftist and nationalist party, a newspaper editor, a best-selling author and a former university dean.

They are accused of being part of a nationalist network called Ergenekon - which takes its name from a legendary valley in central Asia believed to be the ancestral homeland of Turks - or of plotting an armed uprising.

The courtroom can accommodate about 280 people, but an accreditation system appeared to have failed.

"The trial is being held in a courtroom too small and inappropriate for a fair trial," Sahin Mengu, an opposition politician, said outside the court. "This is the Turkish republic's shame."

The court will now first hear the testimonies of the 46 suspects that have been remanded in custody, before the remaining 40 other give testimony in separate hearings

"I have been doing this job for 30 years and never saw such conditions," one lawyer said.

Fierce opponents

Hundreds of people had gathered outside the courthouse in support of the defendants, holding Turkish flags and portraits of the suspects.

Many of the suspects are known as fierce opponents of the government of Recep Tayyip Erdogan, the prime minister.

"I don't deny the existence of Ergenekon or other criminal organisations. But the trial has lumped real criminals with innocent people..."

Tafan Turance, columnist with the Hurriyet newspaper

They organised anti-government rallies attended by hundreds of thousands of secular Turks.

Mohamed Vall, Al Jazeera's correspondent in Istanbul, said the case had caused great intrigue and many consider it as the biggest trial in Turkey's modern history.

"The plotters are accused of attempting to create a state of chaos through rumours, explosions and assassinations, all in order to instigate a military coup," Vall said.

"The gang's action manual included a list of non-Islamist politicians and intellectuals slated for assassination, among them the Nobel laureate Orhan Pamuk.

"They have been charged with some of Turkey's most notorious murders.

"But the biggest shock came in July, when some former high ranking military officials were arrested for possible links to the secret organisation, including Sener Eruygur, a former force commander, and general Hursit Tolon, a former commander of the 1st Army Corps."

Vall said many people believed the trial would take months, if not years to complete.

Stoking tensions

The trial has stoked rivalries between supporters of Erdogan and secularists, who say the inquiry is occurring to intimidate and silence opponents.

Once the hearing got under way on Monday, defence lawyers demanded that judges be replaced, or that the entire case be dismissed, saying that it was politically motivated.

"This trial is not a legal trial, it is a political trial led for the alliance between Erdogan and [US President] George W. Bush," Nevzat Erdemir told the court.

Kemal Kerincsiz, a lawyer who is one of the defendants, said that the trial was launched "against patriots" by those "who want to install a moderate Islamist regime and a federation in Turkey".

The military has ended the rule of four governments in four decades in Turkey. Many secularists suspect Erdogan's Justice and Development Party (AKP) of pushing a secret plan to install Islamic rule in the country.

Tafan Turance, a columnist with the Hurriyet newspaper, told Al Jazeera: "This has become a politicised case, which destroys its legal value.

"I don't deny the existence of Ergenekon or other criminal organisations. But the trial has lumped real criminals with innocent people who are opposed to the government in this case"

Erhan Celik, a presenter with Channel 7 TV station, said that it was time that renegade members of the army and security forces - known as the ‘Deep State' in Turkey - were brought to account.

He said: "This case is not a debate between seculars and anti-seculars. In fact it's an instance of the battle between supporters of democracy and those who oppose it."

The suspects were arrested after an investigation into the discovery of hand grenades in Istanbul in June 2007.

 Source: Al Jazeera and agencies
Feedback Number of comments : 5
 
Bigmel1981
Malaysia
20/10/2008
Turkey coup trial set to open
In every scenario there is a channel to be followed and if public security is put at risk not only in this scenario in turkey ... but anywhere else action must be taken.

Kent
Sweden
21/10/2008
Its not a question of headscarfs, islamic beliefs or clashes between anti-islamists and muslims. Its a question of obtaining the same laws,by gratitude, which were implemented by the very man who created turkey,mustafal kemal ataturk, who was positive to the european community and wanted to integrate turkey into that system.He therefore created a legal system which prohibited any religious intevention in ways that would affect the beauracracy and legal systems,this includes all religions

Ishmael
United Arab Emirates
20/10/2008
Turkey
I can not really understand the so-called "secular people" of Turkey. They hated Islam so much but many of them claims that they are Muslims. Their acts are not acts of true Muslims. Why ban headscarfs in Universities for example where it is basic rule in Islam that women are obliged to wear veils. They really belongs to those who gone astray.

Ali Mertem
Turkey
21/10/2008
Secularism in Turkey
People in so called Muslim Countries of Middle East do not understand Turkey's Secularist principles as some comments have shown. When Ataturk founded Turkish Republic in 1923 he had an incredible vision for Turkey to become part of the Civilized World and not part of the dogmatic, undemocratic and backward Muslim world. Even though Turkey sustains a 95% muslim population, majority of people do not subscribe to the principles of Islam by choice. Secularism is the basis of the constitution.

alper
Canada
21/10/2008
secular turkey
The tone and lack of emphaty in Ali Mertem's comments show how Turkey's secular elite feels and what they are capable of doing. Mentioning democracy and westernized civilization shouldn't have reflected itself as dictatorship and tyranizm. People thinking in a similar way should note how all the faiths are respected in real democraticies.

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article