UPDATED ON:
Thursday, October 30, 2008
19:56 Mecca time, 16:56 GMT
 
News Europe
Has the US overcome its racism?

Does the candidacy of Obama indicate the US is now at peace with its traumatic racial past?[AFP]

The success of Barack Obama's presidential campaign shows just how far the US has moved on the issue of race since the end of the "Jim Crow" era - when laws permitting the segregation and oppression of the nation's blacks were passed.

In focus

In-depth coverage of the
US presidential election
The Democratic candidate is not the president yet, but four decades after the US voting and civil rights acts were passed - effectively scrapping the last of the Jim Crow laws - a black man of mixed race finds himself on the brink of entering the highest office - not just in the land -but arguably in the world.

International polls suggest that Obama has overwhelming global support over his Republican opponent, John McCain.

If he wins, Obama will be hailed and feted the world over.

The most recent Harris Interactive/France 24/International Herald Tribune survey conducted online shows majorities of adults in Germany, France and Spain, as well as lesser but still large numbers of Britons and Italians, believe that electing a person of colour as president would have a positive effect on the US.

And they feel Obama would have the best relationship with Europe if elected.

A thorny issue

What the polls do not reveal is how Obama's race would play out in countries where race is neither properly discussed nor integrated into mainstream politics.

Would those nations currently lauding Obama's candidacy themselves vote his like into office?

It has only been in the latter stages of the campaign that race has become a real talking point in the US itself.

Small wonder.

It's a thorny issue across the multi-racial, developed world. The elephant in the global room.

The ghost of a past that the privileged half want to believe has been miraculously overcome in the modern world with its progressive and egalitarian values.

Talking about it too much just reminds everyone that race is still there, buried, sometimes not so deep. No-one wants that.

Global progress?

In depth

Map: US & the World

Video: Battling over North Carolina

Focus: Overhauling the US voting system

Send us Your Views on the election campaign

Take Britain, the cradle of the 1980s anti-apartheid movement.

Of the four corners of the planet which poured scorn on the leaders of apartheid South Africa, some of the loudest, most indignant voices came from here.

Yet, as South Africa now muddles along – a deeply imperfect muddle, albeit - with its 14-year-old, multi-race, multi-party democracy, can Britain claim similar progress in its hundreds of years of mixed-race history?

Here, the first non-white members of parliament were elected following urban race riots in 1987.

Parliament today would only be truly representative of Britain's 10 per cent minority population with 50 to 60 minority MPs.

But there are currently 15 - none of them in the cabinet - and the fact they are there is largely due to their black and Asian constituents.

Nevertheless, the Obama effect is already being felt.

One organisation looking at the black democratic deficit in the UK is Operation Black Vote.

Its director, Simon Wooley, described his excitement at what he called the "Barack Obama generation" now coming out of the shadows and looking to emulate Obama's success.

"There are talented [black] individuals in British politics who could resonate across the racial divide," he says.

"What we need is someone with Obama's audacity of hope."

A divisive reality

Hillary Clinton could have been the US's
first female president [AFP]
That probably will not happen in the near future, and Britain is not alone.

In France, a country with a minority population in the several millions, mostly from its former colonies, there is not a single minority face representing a local constituency among the 577 members of the National Assembly.

Riots along race lines remain a deeply divisive reality.

Across the EU, migrant policies are being tightened, immigrants labelled outsiders and national identity promoted and protected.

The world can be forgiven for its astonishment that a black man stands at the threshold of greatness in the US. Americans might simply be proud.

After all, they have already had two black secretaries of state to prepare them in recent years, one of them a woman.

And they have also watched Obama defeat a woman to reach the Democratic ticket.

Hillary Clinton, don't forget, could have been the US's first female president. Sarah Palin may yet be.

Pure instinct?

Will US voters rely on pure instinct
come election day? [GALLO/GETTY]

This is an election that has already broken the mould.

Would, or could, Britain dare to be so bold? A woman, yes, but a man or woman of colour? Not right now, thanks.

Does that mean the US alone is at peace with its sensitive extremities?

Obama is living the American dream.

He has run the equal opportunity gauntlet and succeeded so far.

But history proves that, come next Tuesday, many people will cast their votes not on issues or the merits of the campaigns, but on pure instinct.

And the instincts of American voters may yet show that the mixed-race Barack Obama is simply too black for many whites, and too white for many blacks.

 Source: Al Jazeera
 
Feedback Number of comments : 24
 
Nanson Hwa
United States
01/11/2008
Has the U.S. overcome racism?
Racism in America is as American as apple pie. It is buried deep in its history and tradition. In some private organizations, it is respectable to be racist. Although it is not against the law for a person to hold racist view, it is against the law to exercise discrimination particularly in the areas of employment, education, the military, housing and separate public restroom facilities and public drinking fountains. To say the United States of America has overcome racism is premature.

isa
Bangladesh
01/11/2008
Racism in Us
It's shame for the so called voice of democracy that it could not overcome racism problem

RAFFEY
United States
01/11/2008
the truth is in the making
the answer to this question will be known nov.5th as its clear hwo the better leader would be,the onlything holding OBAMA back is his nationality.

Alefe
Ethiopia
01/11/2008
Has the US overcome its racism?
I don't think so. racism, i think, is not only a moral category but also the pillar of american state

Amal
Sudan
02/11/2008
Obama
I find it strange that Obama is being categorised simply as 'black', given that his mother was white and he was raised mostly by her and her parents. He, rather than 'that' white supremacist McCain, embodies the essense of America - it's multiethnicity and multiculturalism. If Obama gets elected, it would prove that Americans have finally progressed beyond empty rhetoric about democracy, liberty and equal rights to the real thing.

Terrell
United States
03/11/2008
Racism still lives in the US
Racism still exists but with a much smaller influence. It's pretty ridiculous to hate someone just because they are different. If people still believe in a god or gods in 2008, it's no surprise that they would believe in other nonsense like racism. Knowledge is power!

Yaqub
United Kingdom
03/11/2008
The Election is Not About Race
McCain supporters would have been perfectly happy to support Condoleeza Rice if she had run. The republican party is not racist, and an American should not have to support Obama in order to prove he/she is not racist. This article is peculiar in suggesting American 'instinct' is racist. Interestingly, most of my US friends instinctually favour Obama first and foremost because he is NOT white! Is this not a visceral sign of racism among Obama supporters? Anti-white racism is still racism.

yusuf
United States
05/11/2008
Amal you said, "I find it strange that Obama is being categorised simply as 'black', given that his mother was white and he was raised mostly by her and her parents." This is not at all strange for America. There is a long standing rule in America that anyone with black ancestry is considered black regardless of any other factors.

Paul
United States
05/11/2008
I have hope!
After seeing the reactions during this election of my fellow Americans, it is sad to see that fear, hate, and racism still rules in the hearts of many. But beyond this, my heart fills with hope that maybe much of this is coming to an end! Hate does not rule my heart and I will hope that people throughout this nation and the world will see that the election of Obama is a great day for this world! To all of my brothers and sisters throughout the world, I bid you peace!

Chris
United States
05/11/2008
Racism
I think you should credit USA for the progress that has been made. Consider countries in Europe like France and Great Britain. Are they ready to elect a minority as president An Indian or Moroccan. Change has been made

mzmarlena
United States
05/11/2008
US and Race
To those of you who still want to blame the US for our racial past, have you overcome your own countries? Have you looked deep and openly into your own hearts and do you give opportunity to ALL races, ethnicities and religions? We were on our way before Obama and he is a validation of our own internal promises to freedom and justice for all our good citizens. He took advantage of opportunity we give to all and showed the World how true commitment to our freedom brings opportunity.

Vikram Rao
United States
05/11/2008
Has the US OVERCOME RACISM ?
Far from it, but this is certainly a step in the right direction. The US is by far the most tolerant country in the world.

Noa
United States
05/11/2008
Racism?
Has the Arab world overcome its racism? It is ridiculous for peoples across the world to question American racism, while overlooking their own racism towards black people. Racism is not eliminated by the election of Barack Obama, but racism has not won this time, and black people not just in America, but all over the world. America has offered its challenge to racism rest of the world? Where is YOUR attempt?

Dr. J. S. Reed
United States
01/11/2008
US Overcome Racism?
The US has not overcome it's racism but it is facing it - in a fashion not seen since the 60's. Though white, I have given up having any contact with more than a half-dozen "friends" who hid the racist, discriminating, hate-based core of their Republicanism. Many American whites are discovering that their racial kindred are their ideological enemies.

PepsiJoe
United States
01/11/2008
Has the US overcome its racism?
"mixed-race "??? We are all part of the human race are we not? So now I guess Sen Obama is now part alien and human? Give the guy a break. As a white male in the US, I find it offensive that people are either voting for or against simply due to color, how about voting for the most qualified candidate (which I personally believe Sen Obama is)??

Adam
United States
02/11/2008
USA
All of these negative comments from all over the world, and yet not a single one of these countries has even considered electing a black candidate. The USA is by far the most tolerant country on the earth. By far !!!!!!

Chris
United States
02/11/2008
Hearing what is said about Obama publicly should be proof enough that the U.S. is still very racist. The "I am not ready for one of those" comments that people say openly on the radio & TV. As a white American male, I hear much worse privately... Did some campaign work 6 miles from Ann Arbor, MI. Wow... some real racists out there! The economy is horrible. McCain is running a poor campaign and he is still only about 5 points behind in the polls. I just hope O' survives his first term! Honestly.

Mike V
New Zealand (Aotearoa)
03/11/2008
Has US overcome racism?
I think it is the first developed country in the world that is on the verge of overcoming its racism. Say what we want about the United States,but there isn't any other first world country that supports a person of mixed ethnicity for President or Prime Minister at this scale. America is far from perfect, but there is a chance for it to be a great role model to other countries to get rid off their unspoken racism.Kudos to you USA.

Abdul Hakeem
Brazil
04/11/2008
Has the US overcome its racism?
Surely, not yet. Racism is an everywhere social-economic-psichological phenomenon, an heritage of a slavery system that survived five centuries here in the American continent. So, it wil not be extinguished within a couple of decades. It will take a long time ahead. May Allah permits human being to find out a solution to this mankind oldest trouble and start seeing to self as one only race, not diferent races.

felice
Ghana
05/11/2008
this is the first step
overcoming racism is not going to be an overnight job. it is going to be a long struggle and with Obama as president elect means that America is ready to undertake the task. i am glad Americans have chosen Obama. democracy in America is really maturing and it will hopefully spread to the rest of the world.

Chantal Walters
United Kingdom
05/11/2008
Has the US overcome its racism?
While a person continues to be described in terms of his skin colour, I cannot help but think that not much has changed.Barack Obama is, after all, just as white as he is black. He is 50% caucasian, just as a huge nbr of other americans are. I mean, if his father were polish or amerindian or costa rican, or even moroccan, what then? Would he be less special? The man is american, not black, not white. Just american. We should look at what he stands for not his colour. Can we all grow up pls?

Paul
United States
05/11/2008
Has the US overcome its racism?
The article isn't asking if the US has eliminated racism, because every nation has its racists and they will likely never go away. I think the US went a long way today towards putting a nail in the coffin of Jim Crow laws and similar shameful policies. No one should forget them, but they should not be considered a valid point of contention any longer.

René Rivera
United States
05/11/2008
Have we overcome racism?
Absolutely not. But please, believe me when I say, there are those of us standing outside of the CNN / Aljazeera spotlights who are seriously working at it. Not all Arabs are terrorists. Not every American is a racist. God bless.

ecas
United States
06/11/2008
Has the US overcome its racism?
It seems ironic that ppl from countries such as Sudan, Ghana, Bangladesh, and other countries with recent histories of ethnic violence are commenting on and denouncing the US racism issues.Isnt it like the pot calling the kettle black? May be the Sudanese commentator forgot about Dafur!

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article