UPDATED ON:
Saturday, January 31, 2009
21:40 Mecca time, 18:40 GMT
News Europe
Erdogan hailed after Davos walkout

Erdogan, right, was angered by the moderator not giving him a chance to counter Peres' argument [AFP]

Turkey's prime minister has returned home from the World Economic Forum in Davos to a warm welcome after he stormed out of a debate over Israel's war on the Gaza Strip.

More than 5,000 people, many waving Palestinian and Turkish flags, greeted Recep Tayyip Erdogan after his aeroplane touched down early on Friday.

Erdogan walked out of a televised debate on Thursday with Shimon Peres, the Israeli president, after the moderator refused to allow him to rebut Peres' justification about the war.

Before storming out, Erdogan told Shimon Peres, the Israeli president: "You are killing people."

At least 1,300 Palestinians were killed during Israel's 22-day aerial, naval and ground assault on Gaza. Thirteen Israeli citizens died over the same period.

Speaking to Al Jazeera at the Swiss resort, Tony Blair, the Middle East envoy for the quartet of the European Union, Russia, the United Nations and the United States, said: "Given what's happened in Gaza it would be surprising if people didn't feel really strongly about it.

"Prime minister Erdogan, I know, because I spoke to him earlier in the day, feels passionately and really sad about what has happened to the people of Gaza.

"And it's inevitable that you get this kind of incident". 

'No return'

During the heated panel discussion, Peres told Erdogan that Turkey would have acted in the same manner as Israel if rockets had been falling on Istanbul.

In depth
Focus

Reporter's diary: Savouring Davos
Reporter's diary: New era in Davos?

Latam leaders join Brazil forum


Videos
Blair on Erdogan walkout and Gaza
Messages to Davos leaders
Gaza crisis stirs heated debate
Davos marred by grim outlook

World views on the summit

Moderator David Ignatius, a Washington Post columnist, then told Erdogan that he had "only a minute" to respond to a lengthy monologue by Peres.

Erdogan said: "I find it very sad that people applaud what you said. There have been many people killed. And I think that it is very wrong and it is not humanitarian."

Ignatius twice attempted to finish the debate, saying, "We really do need to get people to dinner."

Erdogan then said: "Thank you very much. Thank you very much. Thank you very much. I don't think I will come back to Davos after this."

Peres told reporters after the incident that Israel is not in conflict with Turkey.

"I don't see this as a personal or national problem. The relations can remain as they are. My respect [for him] hasn't changed. It was an exchange of views and views are views," he said.

Hamas, which has de facto control of the Gaza Strip after pushing Fatah fighters out of the territory in June 2007, commended Erdogan for his action.

"Hamas pays tribute to the courageous stand of Turkey's prime minister ... who in Davos directly defended the victims of the criminal Zionist war against our children and women in Gaza," Fawzi Barhoum, a Hamas spokesman, said on Friday.

"We consider his departure from the room an expression of support for the victims of the holocaust carried out by the Zionists."

'Understandable'

Amr Moussa, the secretary-general of the Arab League and former Egyptian foreign minister, who was also in the debate, said Erdogan's action was understandable.

"Mr Erdogan said what he wanted to say and then he left. That's all. He was right," he said, adding that Israel "doesn't listen".

"Turkey was Israel's best friend in the Muslim world. I think Israel has to come to grips with the fact that it has alienated a very large proportion of the world's population"

Gareth Evans,
International Crisis Group

Turkey has in recent months brokered indirect talks between Israel and Syria over the Golan Heights region, which Israel captured from Syria in 1967.  

The exchange between Erdogan and Peres took place on the second day of the summit, where business and political leaders have been discussing trade, financial regulation and global security.

Gareth Evans, the president of the International Crisis Group think-tank, told Al Jazeera that Erdogan's walk-out was "deeply depressing".

"I thought the tone of the debate had been reasonably moderate up until Shimon Peres laid some heavy-duty stuff on the line, in a very uncompromising and rather un-Peres like fashion," he said.

"In particular, what was depressing was Peres' utter unwillingness to acknowledge the real significance of the Arab peace initiative and to respond to Erdogan and Amr Moussa, saying how important it is that Israel formally say that the plan is a major step towards peace.

"Turkey was Israel's best friend in the Muslim world. I think Israel has to come to grips with the fact that it has alienated a very large proportion of the world's population."

Peres said his outburst was in response to repeated criticism of Israel for its Gaza operation.

He said: "They try to make the Israeli policy an ugly story. Israel is a democracy. It is fighting one of the most dangerous, terroristic, dictatorial groups.

"All of a sudden to be a humanitarian is to support dictators, to support terror, to support killing innocent people".

Gore plea

Meanwhile, the Davos forum continued into its third day on Friday, with Al Gore, the former US vice-president and Nobel Peace prize winner, participating in a discussion on the environment.

Referring to a UN meeting in Copenhagen later this year aimed at concluding a global agreement on reducing emissions, Gore said Barack Obama, the new US president, and other world leaders should seal a quick deal despite the pervasive global financial crisis.

He said: "The new administration is very serious about this. We need an agreement this year, not next year or some other time."

Gore called Obama "the greenest person in the room" for making environmental funding a large part of the $819bn economic stimulus bill passed by US politicians this week.

"I think it's important for the world leaders gathered here to fully appreciate the magnitude of the change in US leadership," he said.

 Source: Al Jazeera and agencies
 
Topics in this article
People

Country

City

Organisation

Feedback Number of comments : 12
 
zamir ahmed
Afghanistan
30/01/2009
Erdogan hailed after Davos walkout
This is natural who has heart to accept the justice who ever no matter will condemned the inhuman act of Israel killing innocent women and childeren and massacre to capture Paletine land and this is not acceptable to any body who is still human heart

Truthslinger
Thailand
30/01/2009
David Ignatius
It is interesting that the so-called "moderator", David Ignatius, is also Jewish, as well as being a major player in US print media (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Ignatius).

mike j
Canada
30/01/2009
Palestine and Arab world
Well bravo to Mr.Erdogan ! It is very sad to see how Non Arab nations like Turkey, Venezuela, Bolivia, Iran , ... have been so vocal in their opposition to Israels actions and yet the Arab world has been mostly silent , thanks to their corrupt regimes... Very sad indeed... no wonder why west walks all over them ...

Linda Wenrick
United States
31/01/2009
Bravissimo for Erdogan walk-out
It's good to see Turkish warm welcome to their Prime Minister, who refused to be cut off by Washington Post moderator in Davos. His action called attention to his message: let's talk about the "killings" and "humanitarian" issue, not hear the 'justification' for such atrocities.

john e. kondonelis
United States
31/01/2009
Davos walkout
Erdogan was correct to critisize Peres, but I find it truely ironic considering Turkeys record of genocide and bloody human rights history.

Bob Wilson
United States
31/01/2009
Israeli/Hamas Conflict
Hamas hides behind the skirts of women and babies to shoot their rockets at Israel. Israel has two choice, either (1) allow Hamas to keep sending rockets into Israel or (2) attack Hamas wherever they hide. What would you do?

Bob
Canada
01/02/2009
Erdogan is a bad loser
Citizen of Gasa deserve what they got. They elected and supported Hamas and now paid for it a heavy price. Erdogan is not a position to criticise Israel as any country has a right to defend. Erdogan turned out to be a bad loser who was only whining and complaining as a bad loser.

sac
Afghanistan
01/02/2009
wel done erdogun
bravo erdugan . u r right. all of us r with u .

ally
Mauritius
30/01/2009
traitor
erdogan can fool people like him to pretend against israel ,he is the best allies of dajjal time will show you.

Norberto
Argentina
31/01/2009
Empty gesture
This is a completely empty gesture. The fact that is hailed as 'courageous' tells the whole story. Palestine needed the world to stop the Jewish criminals located in both Israel AND overseas but none dared doing it, neither the UN nor so called Palestinian friends. We witnessed on TV how a bunch of mad dogs massacred civilians at will, systematically and with total impunity using the most sophisticated weapons provided by the US. A real ignominy to the whole free world.

Norberto
Argentina
31/01/2009
Blair declares that he believes it is pour la gallerie
Listening carefully what the UK envoy to the region, Blair, says on behalf of his masters it impossible not to conclude that he dismisses Erodgan stunt as an empty gesture, namely 'pour la gallerie', in particular his domestic “gallerie”, and that Turkey will be lobbying his Muslim brothers for the interest of Israel in the future as he consistently did in the past since Turkey will do whatever is necessary to enter the EU, including a Faustian deal with the devil. I do agree with Blair’s assmt.

s
United States
01/02/2009
Erdogan hailed after Davos walkout
imagine. Israel Hamas war. Jews have created Muslim Holocaust. What they would do with Christians and rest of the "pagan"world whom they don't consider human being as per decree of a Rabi.

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article
Aljazeera.net/english 2003 - 2010 ©
Designed & Developed by Aljazeera IT