UPDATED ON:
Sunday, September 21, 2008
15:02 Mecca time, 12:02 GMT
News Middle East
Doubts over Syria 'nuclear' claim
Israeli aircraft bombed the Syrian site, suspecting it was hosting a nuclear reactor [Reuters]

Partial analysis of samples from a Syrian site bombed by Israel do not back up US claims that the target was a secret nuclear facility, diplomats have said.

While the results of tests carried out by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) are preliminary, two diplomats have said that the agency does not expect other samples to contradict initial results.

Washington has said that the Al Kibar site, which Israel destroyed last September, was a near-complete plutonium-producing reactor built with the assistance of North Korea.

Syria denies claims by the Bush administration that it is seeking to develop a covert weapons programme.

Complicated survey

A team of investigators from the IAEA visited the bombed site earlier this year, but Damascus has rejected subsequent requests from the inspectorate to revisit the country.

The US allegations could founder if there is no evidence of a Syrian nuclear programme from the rest of the samples collected by the IAEA.

The IAEA's investigation has been complicated by the fact that the alleged reactor was not complete at the time Israeli aircraft bombed it, meaning no nuclear fuel would have been on site.

Instead of testing the site for radioactivity, the IAEA team looked for graphite, which features in the North Korean prototype that was allegedly being built.

Any major explosion, such as the Israeli bombing, would have scattered graphite over the entire site.

Months before the IAEA visit to the Syrian desert site in June, it had been covered in concrete as part of a foundation of a new building.

'North Korea link'

David Albright, a former UN nuclear inspector, said it was possible that the Israeli missiles did not disturb the tons of graphite buried in the alleged reactor.

He said judgment should be reserved until the release of results from the second batch of tests, "are more sensitive and can pick up smaller quantities".

The agency is also trying to visit three other locations suspected of hosting secret nuclear facilities, but Damascus has not granted access, citing concerns over its security.

The nuclear watchdog also wants to question Syrian officials about intelligence which appears to show years of extensive co-operation between the Syrians and North Korea.

North Korea, which exploded its first nuclear bomb in 2006, is believed by analysts to have made as many as 10 nuclear weapons before agreeing to dismantle its weapons programme last year.

Syrian officials insist that meetings between nuclear officials from Pyongyang and their Syrian counterparts are occasional and informal, diplomats say.

 Source: Agencies
 
Topics in this article
Country

Organisation

Feedback Number of comments : 7
 
c jackson
United States
21/09/2008
Syrian nuclear facility
Its amazing Israel can still fool countires after all its false claims about Syria and Iran. How can countries without a navy, with a limited 1970's era air force, and with no nuclear weapons be so dangerous to the world? Or are they really just a danger to Israel?

Ian Robertson
United Kingdom
22/09/2008
What a joke!
The facility was bulldozed by the Syrians who did not want the world to know that the facility was nuclear. Of course there was no sign of anything.

richard columbare
United States
22/09/2008
preemptive strikes
What gives the Israelis or any other nation the right to strike another sovereign nation just on the assumption that they might do harm. If I did that to any of my neighbors the police would come and arrest me for assault. If Israel gets attacked it's going to be because they have brought it on themselves!

Karl Smtih
United States
22/09/2008
It's amazing that Israel and the U.S. consider themselves the moral compass of the world. Israel is a terrorist state founded on the blood and bones of innocent Palestinians. The Israel's have, as a matter of blind arrogance and the belief that they are above God's law. They bombed the U.S. Liberty, they violate soverign country's, they spy on the U.S. and assassinate at will. This type of arrogance is destined to fail and if history tells us anything, their time is coming.

Abdallah
Somalia
22/09/2008
@ c jackson It's because those countries like Iran and Syria do not recognize the existence of the jewish state called Israel.

Johnny
Australia
22/09/2008
Mate, the wolves have been wearing sheeps clothing for too long. The only countries that pose a threat to the world from nuclear weapons are Israel and the US OF A. Saying that, this is all a prelude to attack Syria, in which Israel and the USA have been planning for many years now. This attack will occur soon and will include Lebanon. It's not IF this will happen, but WHEN.

Justin Case
United States
22/09/2008
Israel bombing Syria
The day will come when the USA tires of propping up the apartheid Jewish state and then it will be pay back time. I look forward to that day.

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article
Aljazeera.net/english 2003 - 2010 ©
Designed & Developed by Aljazeera IT