UPDATED ON:
Sunday, September 07, 2008
21:39 Mecca time, 18:39 GMT
 
News Middle East
Israel mulls settler compensation
Israel evicted 8,500 settlers from the Gaza Strip and West Bank settlements in 2005 [AFP]

The government of Israel is to discuss compensating West Bank settlers who agree to relocate as part of a future peace agreement with the Palestinians.

The "compensation evacuation" plan could be a peaceful way to hand land back to Palestinians, Ehud Olmert said at his weekly cabinet meeting on Sunday.

The country's prime minister said the cabinet would discuss the matter next week.

Olmert told his cabinet that it was likely that Israel would have to move West Bank settlers.

In light of Israel's talks with the Palestinians, he said "it would be proper" to think about providing cash incentives for settlers to leave voluntarily.

Israel has continued to expand illegal settlements in the occupied West Bank, despite a freeze on growth being key to peace agreements.

Olmert said voluntary relocation of some of the estimated 260,000 Jewish settlers was part of US-backed final status talks relaunched last year.

"We will not bring the issue to a decision today," Olmert said. "But at a time when serious and continuing diplomatic negotiations are being held, it should be clear to everyone that they will likely at some [point] lead also to the need to make decisions that will entail the relocation of residents from the places in which they live.

"I think that it is good to begin thinking about these issues and to see how we can prepare for them properly."

Israel evicted 8,500 settlers from the Gaza Strip and four small West Bank
settlements in 2005. Many refused to plan for or co-operate with the operation.

Symbolic step

Jacky Rowland, Al Jazeera's correspondent in Jerusalem, said the discussion of compensation packages was "still at a very early stage".

"It refers, only at the moment, to the settlers living to the east of Israel's separation barrier.

"The plan looks at how to encourage people living in isolated settlements ... to leave peacefully and quietly rather than kicking and screaming as was the case with some of the settlers in Gaza three years ago.

"The number of people [that would be affected] is about 60,000 and there are about 250,000 Israeli settlers in the West Bank."

Under internatiionl law, settlers living west of the separation barrier are illegally living on occupied Palestinian land.

"Israel is making no attempt at all to hide its plans to hang on to those big settlement blocks under any peace deal," Rowland said.

Under the proposed bill, settlers willing to leave territory to be transferred to the Palestinians would receive payment from the government.

The bill is aimed at minimising friction and paving the way for a large pullback from the West Bank, which the Palestinians claim as part of a future independent state.

Proponents of the package say that up to half of the 70,000 residents of settlements expected to be evacuated would leave if they had the financial means.

Israel and the Palestinians have been holding formal US-backed peace talks since November 2007, aimed at resolving their decades-old conflict by the time George Bush, US president, leaves office in January 2009.

Mahmoud Abbas, the Palestinian president, who has been meeting Olmert on a fortnightly basis since the talks were relaunched, has repeatedly said the settlements are the greatest obstacle to reaching a deal.

The Jewish settlements in the occupied West Bank, including east Jerusalem, are illegal under international law.

 Source: Agencies
Feedback Number of comments : 17
 
Aaron
Canada
08/09/2008
ok
now before the huge slew of comments get added here (most of them with poor english grammar) I must applaud this decision. But it should go further... for it is no small fact that many israelis living in the bigger settlements to the west of the separation barrier would also leave if they were compensated.

Andrew
United States
08/09/2008
Nothing is Occupied
There is no "West Bank' - there is Judea and Samaria - and Israels not leaving - they are natives - idiginous Nothing is occupied In "hebron" there is the tomb of the patriarchs - Rachel, Issac, Jacob...etc They bleong to Israel These do not belong to Islam !!!

Dan
United States
08/09/2008
West Bank
First of all, Aaron was right about the bad English grammar. Secondly, in this age, countries need to be held accountable for the things they do. That's why the Geneva Convention came about. Taking over the land that some call Judea and Samaria is illegal by international law. It has been since 1967, and it always will be. Not only that, religious settlers should think long and hard if God would approve of their taking water and land from other people.

Dani
United States
08/09/2008
Why give back?
Oh please. When the Jordanians controlled half of Jerusalem, they would shell down at Jewish mothers trying to shop for their families, and throw garbage on the visitors to the Western wall. Syria did the exact same with the Golan Heights, as did Egypt in the Gaza Strip with Fedayin militants. We tried giving Gaza back, and it turned into Hamas controlled, dozens of rockets fired into Israel daily. Israel should not give up anything more. Go live in the 8 surrounding arab countries, Palestinians

Willy Van Damme
Belgium
08/09/2008
Israel mulls settler compensation
Andrew, looking at your posting it seems you want to expell al the Palestinians from this territory you call Jewish. Why not otherwise?

Gary
United Kingdom
08/09/2008
The illegal settlers will always have the option to stay where they are, in the West Bank: Under a two state solution they could simply opt to become Palestinian citizens (unlikely as settlers in remote regions tend to be religious extremists). Or, under a more-just single-state solution they could simply learn to share the land they now occupy with the people they once expelled. No-one has to move anywhere. A shift in mind-set is all that is required.

Shaun
United States
09/09/2008
response: settler compensation
In light of Israel's geostrategic importance, domestic political economic climate, and 2 disparate ethnic/political collectivities -both groups deeply influenced by dogmatic differences and the consequences of protracted conflict -this is promising

Ayub
Afghanistan
10/09/2008
Settlements ignored.
Dan and Aaron:The commenters here might be fluent in English because they speak on or two more languages.I speak 5 languages myself.I read and write two.How many languages do you two speak besides English?English being your mother tongue your comments are inept and biased.Stick to CNN where your [profanity removed] might be read with the rest of the CNN [profanity removed].As far as the settlement is concerned, Palestinians will have their day.What goes around,comes around.

Sameer
India
08/09/2008
What about the land you are living on?
Andrew, The Indians in America are natives - "Idiginous". (Aaron was tight about the poor English part) Substantial portions of the United states once belong to the indigenous people. Why don't you start vacating too, as the land you are living on, clearly 'bleong'ed to the Natives, not to white European colonizers.

John
United Kingdom
08/09/2008
Andrew
What nonsense ! The fact that the majority Jews originated from Europe and forcibly took over land of the indigenoue people kinda knocks your assertions into a cocked hat !

Sunny
Canada
08/09/2008
Israel mulls settler compensation
Palestinians have generously allowed Israel to remain in the state created in 1948 by forcibly removing ethnic Palestinians who were continuous indigenous inhabitants of Palestine for millennia. The government of Israel must vacate all West Bank and East Jerusalem dwellings and pay reparations to the Palestinians and tender a formal and abject apology.

darren
United Kingdom
08/09/2008
religious nut!
Andrew, That's the kind of talk that inflames people like you! live with your brother Arabs IN PEACE, NOT RELIGIOUS HATE. Wake up and grow up!

Gaƫlle
Belgium
08/09/2008
The Nakba is a fact
If Palestine and the Palestinians do not exist, who is Israel fighting with?! If Jews have a right of return after 2000 years why can't the Palestinians have the same right after 60 years?! Creating one multicultural state with equal rights for every citizen would be a real challenge to give true democracy a chance. Stop hiding behind religion and face reality!

john auger
Australia
09/09/2008
occupied west bank
be careful andrew, if your argument that the judea and sumaria in the west bank are historicaly jewish and so should now be jewish prevails, the indigenous indians might want all of the USA back

Chris
United States
09/09/2008
Thanks Israel
I'd just like to say i am glad to hear that the Israeli government is starting to learn that the only way to decrease tension is to give back some of the land peacefully. Andrew, please be more considerate to actual history over what the Bible says. You are also a US citizen and should act more off equality and factual history through non-bias sources over religion.

Nico
Italy
10/09/2008
Occupation of Palestine
It is about time that these illegal settlements will diminish. It is amazing how the whole world can turn their cheek when it comes to the Palestinian conflict and how they can let a country such as Israel to suppress people and to build an illegal wall closing them in completely and destroying an economy. It is utterly ridiculous and it is intollerable. Israel speaks avidly about what goes on in Muslim countries yet in its own country which happens to be a country based on a religion it is ok.

Bakar
Switzerland
11/09/2008
Occupied Teritories !!!!!!!!!!!
Some ask why give back!! Give it back because it is not yours simple!Also the earliar the better ,because if you believe in dooms-day technology that is in your hands,you will be decieving your own selves because doomsday technology is almost evenly distributed all around you.DO NOT FORGET that hitler was not a palestinian so it is unjust to make them pay for a crime the never did.For those who say THE LAND IS OURS, well not all catholics are citizens of the vatican state.DAI ISRAEL FAI BRAVO !

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article