UPDATED ON:
Monday, October 27, 2008
23:30 Mecca time, 20:30 GMT
 
News Middle East
Syria says raid is 'terrorist' act

The alleged US raid targeted a Syrian village close to the country's porous border with Iraq [AFP] 

The Syrian foreign minister has described a deadly raid on a village near the border with Iraq, allegedly carried out by the US, as a planned act of "terrorist aggression".

Speaking in London on Monday, Walid Muallem also raised questions about how a pact between the US and Iraq over troop deployment next year could impact on neighbouring countries.

Muallem said the eight people killed in Sunday's helicopter attack in the border village of Sukariya were civilians.

"All of them were unarmed and they are on the Syrian territories," he said. "This killing of civilians in international law means a terrorist aggression.

"The Americans do it in the daylight, this means it is not a mistake it is by determination, by planned determination."

'Al-Qaeda lieutenant killed'

The US has not officially responded to Syria's accusations, but an unnamed US official said on Monday that Abu Ghadiya, a former lieutenant to Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, the late leader of al-Qaeda in Iraq, had been killed in the raid.

"It was a successful operation ... He [Abu Ghadiya] is believed to be dead," the official said.

"He had knowledge of many of the so-called 'rat lines' or smuggling routes [into Iraq] ... This undoubtedly will have a debilitating effect on this foreign fighter smuggling network."

Muallem also said that Syria would be holding the US responsible and that the government needed to investigate and report back to them with an explanation as to why the raid had been carried out.

"Also, the question arises here: Is this the production of the agreement between the administration and Iraq, the defensive agreement, where many Iraqis are saying that the sovereignty of Iraq is at stake and the American will use the Iraqi's territories to launch aggression against neighbouring countries? These are question marks," he said.

'Terrorist groups'

The families of those killed in the raid on Sukariya, which lies close to the town of Abu Kamal, buried their loved ones on Monday.

Syrian state television said four US military helicopters had been involved in Sunday's raid on the village.

"Four American helicopters violated Syrian airspace around 4:45pm local time [13:45 GMT] on Sunday," state television reported.

Two of the helicopters landed and dropped off eight US soldiers, who then entered a house, Syrian media reported.

"American soldiers ... attacked a civilian building under construction and fired at workmen inside, causing eight deaths," state television said.

The government said that those killed were workers.

Akram Hameed, a man in his 40s who said he was injured in the attack while fishing in the Euphrates river, told Syrian television he saw four helicopters coming from the border area under a heavy blanket of fire.

"One of the helicopters landed in an agricultural area and eight members disembarked," Hameed said.

"The firing lasted about 15 minutes and when I tried to leave the area on my motorcycle, I was hit by a bullet in the right arm about 20 metres away."

Syrian television showed what it said was the injured wife of the building's guard, in bed in hospital with a tube in her nose, saying that two helicopters landed and two remained in the air during the attack.

Iraq allegations

The raid targeted an area used by fighters responsible for cross-border attacks into Iraq, Ali al-Dabbagh, the Iraqi government spokesman, said on Monday.

Syria says that innocent civilians were the only victims of the alleged raid [AFP]
"The attacked area was the scene of activities of terrorist groups operating from Syria against Iraq," he told the Reuters news agency.

"The latest of these groups ... killed 13 police recruits in an [Iraqi] border village. Iraq had asked Syria to hand over this group which uses Syria as a base for its terrorist activities."

Al-Dabbagh would not say who had carried out the attack.

"Iraq is always seeking distinguished relations with its sister Syria," he said.

"The presence of some anti-Iraq groups in Syria, which are supporting and participating in activities against Iraqis, would hinder improvement of these relations".

The US and the US-backed Iraqi government have on several occasions accused Damascus of not doing enough to stop anti-US fighters, including those from al-Qaeda, crossing the border into Iraq.

Syrian anger

After news of Sunday's attack emerged, the Syrian government summoned the senior US and Iraqi envoys to Damascus to protest against the raid, the Syrian Arab news agency (Sana) reported.

A Syrian government statement said: "Syria condemns this aggression and holds the American forces responsible for this aggression and all its repercussions."

The statement also called for the Iraqi government to launch an investigation into the attack.

Reem Haddad, the Syrian information ministry spokesperson, sais that the raid breached a recent accord between Iraq and the US.

"This is a flagrant violation of the new [security] agreement between Iraq and the US," she told Al Jazeera.

"One of the points of that agreement is that they do not attack bordering countries."

Hoda Abdel Hamid, Al Jazeera's correspondent in the northern Iraqi city of Irbil, said the alleged US raid seemed to be in contradiction to comments by US officials that Syria had improved its border security.

"What is quite puzzling for many people here is that the Americans had actually praised the role of Syria over the last year," she said.

"Earlier this year, I had conversations with General David Petraeus [then commander of US forces in Iraq] and Ryan Crocker, the US ambassador to Iraq; they both said that Damascus had made [security] efforts at its main airport and along the Syria-Iraq border, and that the flow of fighters coming into Iraq had diminished considerably over the previous year.

"They both said the number of people infiltrating Iraq from Syria had dropped by 50 per cent [in the last year]. Actually, Petraeus told me that it was impossible for any country to fully control its borders, specifically when it is in a porous desert area."  

Lieutenant-Colonel Chris Hughes, a spokesman for US forces in western Iraq, said that the US division that operates on the Iraqi side of the border was not involved in Sunday's incident.

The area targeted lies close to the Iraqi border city of Qaim, which in the past has been a crossing point for fighters, weapons and money used to fuel the armed Sunni opposition against Iraq's government.

 Source: Al Jazeera and agencies
Feedback Number of comments : 26
 
John Wiseman
Canada
27/10/2008
A Horrible People a Failure of a Nation
I grew up in Canada, where we were taught the Americans were our best friends. I had an American uncle. I had an American girlfriend. But over the years, all my love for Americans has vanished. At 60, I see them as a despicable people. They think they own the world, and they are ignorant about all others. They are fiendishly vicious. I would never ever consider Americans friends again not of myself not of anybody. They are not even friends of themselves.

Jay
United States
27/10/2008
availability
I was thinking it would be great if there was more penetration by your news service of the US Market.

Deborah Lilly
United States
27/10/2008
Syrian Attacks
Another excuse for the American government to bomb wherever they want. The US government is giving us americans a bad name and reputation. america is continually comitting its own attrocities in the middle east and giving continued support to Isreal whom is murdering innocent Palestinians.

Jennifer
New Zealand (Aotearoa)
28/10/2008
Poor Excuses
I wish more Americans could live outside the US (as I do) and see the effect the US government is having on the world - US media is usually one-sided. Bush's Government is throwing it's weight around with its own 'terrorism' excuse. There is NO excuse for killing civilians, and Bush needs to answer for his own terrorist actions. I am ashamed of the US's current government which allows and supports its own terrorist activities against civilians.

Murray of Montreal
Canada
28/10/2008
God bless America!
Its about time that they went after the staging areas for the insurgency in Iraq, The Syrians have no right whatsoever to complain. They protect terrorists and that is what the American's killed. More power to the US!

Tere
United States
28/10/2008
Syria
To John Wiseman, You forget to separate our government from the common people. Many of us do not agree with the decisions of our leaders, just as I'm sure many peace-loving Muslims do not agree with extremists Muslims and do not like being stereotyped with them. Also, Aljazeera, I find it interesting that you only ever post the negative things that are said about the U.S. and rarely the positive. Shame on you for being as biased as our media.

Lily
China
28/10/2008
mourning the victims
I was so surprised as I read the news.I even hardly contrloed my tears.How could the Americans have done such cruel activity to those innocent and unarmed Syrian civilians? How anguished the families of those victims are!I wonder why human beings have invented cannonballs to kill their congeners. God bless the kind people, Amen!

Jon
United States
28/10/2008
Put the blame where it belongs
This is a response to Wiseman. Even though you may have had a bad experience with a COUPLE of Americans, there are 300 million of us, and you don't know the first things about Americans. DO you really mean to suggest that we condone such things as this?! I mean get real!! I was to say such a blanket statement about Canadians, Syrians, Iraqi's or anyone else, maybe 10's of hundreds of people would respond. BUT everyone "hates" Americans. Well, that is stupid and wrong, and YOU are ignorant!

DKL
United States
28/10/2008
Syria Raid
I want you guys to read this.. below. The U.S. is a permanent member of the U.N. Security Council, so this is an outrageous crime for a country who is responsible for maintaining peace and security in the whole world to act this way," Jihad Makdissi, a spokesman for the Syrian Embassy in London, told the BBC. It seems to me that if we are the peacekeepers of the world that we should have an obligation, but. I dont like us being refered to that. Also not every damn american is violent.

Jeff Fogltance
United States
28/10/2008
Syria says raid is terrorist act
Do you only publish anti American traitor comments?

secretslave
United States
28/10/2008
Monkeys with weapons
salaam, and they hear and follows instruction of carelessness

beng
United Kingdom
28/10/2008
Attack on Syria - A New October Surprise?
There is a theory that in 1980, a US Republican presidential candidate who was behind in the opinion polls consipired with the Iranian government to delay the release of American hostages in order to boost his popularity. Google "October Surprise Iran" and you will see. Perhaps this attack on Syria is a similar attempt to stir up trouble as McCain is thought to have a more hawkish stance on foreign policy and it would help him to make Americans feel that they have more enemies threatening them.

Blake
United States
28/10/2008
I think the thoughts of the Canadian are just as bad of the thoughts of many Americans toward people of Arab descent as of late. Saying that Americans are despicable because of their government would be like calling Afghans fascists because they were oppressed by the Taliban.

Pat Rauch
Syria
28/10/2008
Syria Attack
America bitches about terrorism well we did it we started now I am an American living in NYC remember 9/11 full well. Bush deserves to tried for war crimes he killed innocent not just now but on 9/11 too by not acting continuing to school whiles thousands. Don't American's "fearless leader". I am truly sorry and horrified that Bush could stoop to this level.

Najeeb
United States
28/10/2008
Why this raid at this time
This raid is all about politics n Bush - Bush wants to help McCain on Nov 4, the current administration wants to divert people attention from domestic issues - economy and unemployment. McCain is lagging behind because of economy - Wants to create panic in the oil market and which will help oil producing countries like Saudi, Kuwait and so called other allies, right now the oil prices are getting hammered. - also wants to take personal vendetta against Syria, the way he took against Saddam.

Smith
Cambodia
28/10/2008
yes
Good job USA.

Adam Van Sickle
United States
28/10/2008
I read this article, and many articles like it and it makes me ashamed and embarrassed to be from this country. John Wiseman, I understand why your love for America has vanished. Our foreign and domestic policies show little respect for humankind as we continue to flagrantly mistreat others as well as ourselves. I only hope that we will, as a country, wake up and realize that we have blood on our hands, and hopefully its not too late to ask for forgiveness.

Sharmad
United States
28/10/2008
Terrorist leader killed
Of course, due to the irrational bias against the US, people ignore the fact that a high-ranking Al Qaeda figure was killed in this operation. That proves that if Al Qaeda didn't fight like cowards and surround themselves with women and children, there probably wouldn't have been civilian deaths. And of course, Al Qaeda is entirely absent from criticism in this issue. It's easier and more convenient to just say it's all America's fault. Pathetic.

Ryan
United States
28/10/2008
acts of govt or military do not reflect on people
In response to Mr. Wiseman's comments about the American people: I've never understood these wildly general assertions that seek to charge an entire nation with the guilt and pathos of its leaders. Calling us a "horrible people" seems so unnecessary that it strikes me oddly, and displays a stunning lack of wisdom, logic, and compassion. We're on the verge of an historic election in which poll numbers suggest we'll elect a president with values that are certainly more progressive than your pres's

Joe
United States
28/10/2008
California Student
Who thinks they own the world, all Americans? I disagree with that statement for obvious reasons. You would never have American friends again? Are you that shallow to ban a culture of people from your life? "They think they own the world, and they are ignorant about all others. They are fiendishly vicious. I would never ever consider Americans friends again not of myself not of anybody. They are not even friends of themselves."

Patriot
United States
28/10/2008
Amazing
Ignorant liberal americans fail to realize this was not a blind attack, but a surgival strike to kill a terrorist. Notice there is no problem for you if this guy is responsible for the deaths of many Iraqis. You are a bunch of self hating hypocrites, you should move to Canada if you do not like us defeding ourselves and others.

Momo
United Kingdom
28/10/2008
Diversion: A Closing Act
Time and again we see American presidents fall back to the classic external diversion trick whenever deemed convenient for the domestic scene for a variety of reasons. Therefore, it is no surprise that Bush’s regime is deploying the same tactic as its final closing act to further the (neo-) republican cause comes election time. The new American unipolarism and the pitiful pan-Arabic leverage on the contemporary political landscape are only making the troubled Mid East the ideal ground for this.

lmtd
Canada
28/10/2008
ya
cant wait till obama. someone with good judgement

Jeff Fogltance
United States
28/10/2008
Syria says raid is terrorist act
If Syria would clean up it's own mess we wouldn't have to do it for them. They bring shame to their own citizens by harboring terrorists and turning a blind eye to those that travel through their borders to attack Iraqi's.

ICE MAN
United States
28/10/2008
Dispicable comments
Funny how the raid actually killed an Al-Qaeda lieutenant and these ridiculous comments with regards to US behavior. This is the same Al-Qaeda that beheaded a man on video just because of his nationality. The same Al-Qaeda that lost it's foothold in Iraq because of it's extreme views and extreme measures against fellow Muslims. Syrian officials were warned and they did nothing, the opportunity to take-out a high ranking Al-Qaeda official presented itself and we reacted swiftly. No regrets.

Max Gross
Australia
28/10/2008
US terrorism
Until the world unites to oppose US intransigence, militarism and its sickening sense of special exceptionalism this sort of cold, calculated violence will continue to go unpunished.

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article