UPDATED ON:
Monday, November 10, 2008
06:51 Mecca time, 03:51 GMT
 
News Middle East
Faithful fight at Jerusalem church
 Worshippers kicked and punched each other until Israeli police eventually restored order [AFP]

Israeil police have made two arrests after fighting erupted between Armenian and Greek Orthodox clergymen at one of Christianity's most sacred sites - the Church of the Holy Sepulchre.

An Armenian and a Greek Orthodox monk were arrested after the brawl, police said on Sunday.

Dozens of worshippers, dressed in traditional vestments of their sects, kicked and punched each other, knocking down tapestries and overturning decorations at the site in east Jerusalem.

Police officers eventually restored order at the church, which followers believe is both the traditional site of the crucifixion and contains Jesus's tomb.

Both sides blamed each other for the violence, with one Armenian monk saying that Greek Orthodox worshippers attempted to place their monk inside the tomb - which he said is not permitted.

'Violation'

"What is happening here is a violation of [the] status quo, the Greek [sic] have tried so many times to put their monk inside the tomb but they don't have the right to put their monk inside the tomb when the Armenians are celebrating the feast," he said.

The fight broke out during the Feast of the Cross, during which the Armenian community marks what they believe was the fourth-century discovery of the cross upon which Jesus was crucified.

However, Greek Orthodox clergy denied they were responsible for the brawl.

"We protested peacefully, we stood here in the middle and we claimed that we shall not leave the procession ... unless they leave our guardian inside. This didn't happen and in that moment the police interfered," he said.

"We tried our best not to use violence against the police or against the Armenians because this is our attitude - peaceful, co-access on the holy sites."

Fights are not uncommon in the Church of the Holy Supulchre between representatives of the various Christian sects who jealously guard their sections of and rights of access to the site.

 Source: Al Jazeera and agencies
Feedback Number of comments : 16
 
True Truthseeker
Afghanistan
10/11/2008
Whilst it is commendable to quote scriptures, particularly to highlight the matter of accountability, it is most important to direct honest-hearted ones on the straight and narrow path as revealed in the Holy Writings [Bible]. It is not for naught that the scriptures mention that the entire world is being deceived by a malevolent force spearheaded by Satan, this is borne out at Revelation 12:9, 13:4, 8 1 John 2:17, 1 John 5:19 etc. All honest- hearted persons need to be aware that certai

Richard
United States
11/11/2008
Hilarious
Some people think religious violence is always sad, but sometimes it is funny!

April
Afghanistan
12/11/2008
The Brawl
Who needs enemies when rival Orthodox Christians create chaos and destruction in their own church? Astonishing, really.

Steve In Texas
United States
12/11/2008
Fighting In Church
Arabs fighting Jews, Jews fighting Jews, Sunnis fighting Shiites, Hamas fighting Fatah, and now Christians fighting Christians. What is this world coming to? Things were so much better in the Middle East before 1947. I wish I had been around back then. Nothing is ever perfect, but the whole world seems cockeyed now. I've always wanted to visit the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, but I'm afraid it will be destroyed by the time I can afford to get over there.

G
United States
12/11/2008
Church Fight
I think that fighting over religion is wrong. If you look at any religion there is always a belief about religious tolerance. There is never a good reason to fight over religion for religion was created so that we WOULD NOT FIGHT!

Jim
United Kingdom
13/11/2008
A fallacy
How typical of "moral" men. Disgraceful hypocrites! ".....What a piece of work is a man, how noble in reason, how infinite in faculties, how like an angel in apprehension, how like a God! The beauty of the world, paragon of animals and yet to me, what is this quintessence of dusk. Man delights not me, no, nor women neither, nor women neither."

John
United States
15/11/2008
Idiots
This is totally ridiculious.

cindy lou
United States
13/11/2008
Fighting at the Church
This is bad and unreasonable. But it is what happens when people use middle age religion as a basis for what is happening now and since the holy books were written. Meanwhile neither religion is going to other countries and bombing them because of this belief. Meanwhile this site is in Israel and they are protecting it and not shutting it down.

Bird
United States
13/11/2008
The result of christianity
This is a perfect example of what happens when people follow the image of a man rather than the spirit of God. the prophet Jesus said: "A good man out of the good treasure of the heart bringeth forth good things: and an evil man out of the evil treasure bringeth forth evil things."

tesfatadelle
United States
13/11/2008
Unbecoming
I hope the leaders of each denomination discipline the transgressors. Like all humans the monks had a temporary relapse of their true calling. Christ is the author of peace He did not even revile the ones that crucified Him. So should his followers.

john saah
Afghanistan
14/11/2008
Orthodox priests fight
I am the son of Orthodox Christian parents from Palestine. If you ask me, the Palestinian Christians should immediately kick out both the Greek and Armenian organisations from Palestine and replace them with Palestinian Arab Christian leaders instead. Jerusalem is Palestinian Arab land, not Greek land or Armenian land. Do you ever see a Palestinian priest bossing people around in any church in Athens or Yerevan? I doubt it.

Richard
United States
14/11/2008
Ignorance of saah
So the Holy Sepulchre should be 100% Palestinian even though it was orignally designed, built and rebuilt several times by foreign Christians? Your insistence that this Church is exclusively an Arab place is a typical example of ignorant and overzealous nationalism. Athens and Yerevan do not have Arab clergy because Arabs didn't build and maintain churches there. Also, your lack of sympathy for Palestinian Armenians who fled a genocide in their homeland is commendable.

Tom
Afghanistan
14/11/2008
son of a gun
Hey – did you know there are more PAGANS on earth than there are JEWS?? And “non-religious” are almost equal to the number of Muslims??? (check it yourself) So much for "great" religions.

ming
United States
15/11/2008
Christians battle each other
This is not so surprising really. All 3 monotheistic religions are born in and have centuries of history of violence.

rezasantorini
United States
16/11/2008
fighting the Church
I'm a Christian Palestinian, born in Bethlehem. Now a US citizen. I visit this Church often and the Israelis take good care of it, trying to keep these sects from killing each other, because they can't respect another thought, but their own. Israel can be fair in this as they have no animosity toward either group.

Ibrahim
Cyprus
20/11/2008
Politics and religion
Well, as long as the power structures intervene the faiths, so long the beautiful religions and religious spheres become the playground of politic affairs, the blind-heart of the political competition will get any religion travestied. This is how the "faithful fight" entertains the audience!! Thats how the politics will keep gaining ground. It was no surprise. In deed, it goes without saying that, all this "mess" caused in the Holy Land spring from the politics...

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article