UPDATED ON:
Thursday, February 19, 2009
07:45 Mecca time, 04:45 GMT
 
News Middle East
Free Bush shoe-thrower, Iraqis urge

The two shoes narrowly missed the US president as he gave a news conference in Baghdad

Thousands of Iraqis have demonstrated in Baghdad's Sadr City in support of a journalist being held in custody after throwing his shoes at George Bush, the US president.

Muntazer al-Zeidi was detained for what the Iraqi government on Monday said was a "barbaric and ignominious act" during a news conference the previous day.

The outgoing US leader, who was making a surprise visit to Baghdad, had just told reporters that while the war in Iraq was not over "it is decisively on its way to being won," when al-Zeidi got to his feet and hurled abuse - and his footwear - at Bush.

Bush, who had been giving a joint press statement with Nuri al-Maliki, the Iraqi prime minister, ducked behind a podium as the shoes narrowly missed his head.

"Millions of Iraqis or rather millions of the people of the world wish to do what Muntadhar did," Uday al-Zeidi, Mundathar's brother, said on Monday.

"Thank God he had the guts to do it and avenge the Iraqi people and the country from those who plunder it and have killed its people."

Al-Baghdadiya television, his employer, has demanded his release after Yasin Majeed, the prime minister's media adviser, said al-Zeidi would be tried on charges of insulting the state.

An Iraqi lawyer told the AFP news agency that Zeidi risked a miminum of two years in prison if he is prosecuted for insulting a visiting head of state.

Freedom of expression 

On Monday, al-Baghdadiya suspended its normal programming and played messages of support from across the Arab world. 

A presenter read out a statement calling for his release, "in accordance with the democratic era and the freedom of expression that Iraqis were promised by US authorities".
   

Iraqis have hailed
Zeidi's actions [AFP]
It said that any harsh measures taken against the reporter would be reminders of the "dictatorial era" that Washington said its forces had invaded Iraq to end.

Demonstrations also took place in the southern city of Basra and Najaf, where some people threw shoes at a US convoy.

Khalil al-Dulaimi, Saddam Hussein's former lawyer, said he was forming a team to defend al-Zeidi and that around 200 lawyers, including Americans, had offered their services for free.

"It was the least thing for an Iraqi to do to Bush, the tyrant criminal who has killed two million people in Iraq and Afghanistan," he said.

"Our defence of Zeidi will be based on the fact that the United States is occupying Iraq, and resistance is legitimate by all means, including shoes."

In Iraqi culture, throwing shoes at someone is a sign of contempt and the incident is likely to serve as a lasting reminder of the widespread opposition to the US-led invasion of Iraq - the conflict which has come to define Bush's presidency.
 
"Throwing the shoes at Bush was the best goodbye kiss ever ... it expresses how Iraqis and other Arabs hate Bush," Musa Barhoumeh, editor of Jordan's independent Al-Gahd newspaper, wrote.

But support has not been entirely universal and some Iraqis believe al-Zeidi crossed the line.

 "I deem it unnecessary. This thing is unjustifiable. It is an incorrect style. We are not violent. One can voice his opinion in other ways," one Baghdad resident said.

Robert Wood, a US state department spokesman, dismissed the incident saying that al-Zeidi was "trying to get attention for himself" and had ignored Washington's successes in Iraq.

"This was one incident and one individual's views, but if you look at the direction we are heading in Iraq now, it's a very, very positive direction and we hope to see that continue," he said.

Bush's visit to the Iraqi capital came just 37 days before he hands the presidency over to Barack Obama, who has vowed to withdraw troops from Iraq.

 Source: Agencies
Feedback Number of comments : 53
 
Cliff
United States
15/12/2008
Iraqis demand shoe-thrower be freed
Americans wish we had the chance to do something similar to Bush...

Neil Hoskins
United Kingdom
15/12/2008
Not Just Iraqis
I agree with his brother: it's not just Iraqis, not just Muslims, but people all over the world hold the man in utter contempt and will never forget or forgive the millions of lives lost.

Nur Al-din Tobutt-Somers
Sweden
15/12/2008
Free Bush shoe-thrower, Iraqis urge
Well done Muntazer Al-zaidi! Millions around the world would love to have been able to do what you did and are proud of you for doing it. The man on the receiving end of your shoes promised freedom and democracy instead of which he has reaked death and destruction. He, along with another famous "B" lied to the world not only about their motives for attacking Irag but also about what would happen if they didn't. The same applies to Afghanistan. In view of that be glad it was only a shoe!!!

Mark
Canada
15/12/2008
Made my morning
That may be the funniest thing I have ever seen in my life.

James Freeman
United States
15/12/2008
Shoe thrower
I'm sure if someone through a shoe at Saddam Huesan people would be marching in the streets demanding his release. Of course the man would have been hung at the nearest public square before anyone had a chance to form a protest.

Jon
United States
15/12/2008
Lets us hope
I hope this "reporter" get 2 years or more, if you want to protest go out in the street with the other savages

Allen King
Canada
15/12/2008
Free Bush Shoe-thrower, Iraqis urge
Al-zaidi's act will long be remembered in history, same as when an unarmed student stood before a tank in Tianaman Square in Bejing. Hopefully it will send a strong message to Obama too. Long live freedom of expression.

Skulz Fontaine
United States
15/12/2008
Mr. Muntazir al-Zaidi
Let the brave man go free! What a world class hero. Would that all journalists be as bold and courageous as Mr. al-Zaidi. It's kind of sad that Mr. al-Zaidi didn't toss a horseshoe at the Bushco. Bush is a genocidal monster and should face a guillotine. However, Mr. al-Zaidi spoke for simple folk all around our planet and good on him. Free Mr. al-Zaidi and then give the man a medal. Or a Nobel Prize for courage!

Dan Perdomo
United States
15/12/2008
Free Bush shoe-thrower
It was well deserved, and the best thing any Irak citizen could do, I just regret it did not hit his mark and others should join him in approval.

Harry Kuheim
United States
15/12/2008
Shoe throwing
Al Queda and civil war between Shia and Sunni extremists have killed the most people in Iraq not the US. This is why your country is a mess inspite of being an oil rich nation which could be a model society.Look in the mirror and throw shoes.

grace
United States
15/12/2008
Congratulaltions to Mr. al-Zeidi. He did something that many of us here in the U.S. would like to do, but he only allows his supporters to be near him. How can american citizens show their support for Mr. al-Zeidi?

Peter
United States
15/12/2008
Shoe Throw at Bush
It is understood that many in the world do not like Bush but when he threw the shoe, he insulted a whole nation. Can you imagine how many people would have been killed if a shoe was thrown at Malaki? Show some class Iraq and make the shoe thrower clean the streets for a few weeks with a sign on his back stating he has "no class"

T
Canada
15/12/2008
"Free Bush shoe-thrower, Iraqis urge"
This was one of the main topics of discussion on my commuter train this morning. And if my fellow travellers are indicative of Canadian sentiment, then this journalist is to be applauded not sanctioned. Most Canadians dislike Bush as much as Iraqis do, and were in no way offended by the shoe-throwing. We were only disappointed that he was able to duck so quickly! DO NOT punish this man for expressing years of frustration. This was clearly an expression of disgust - well deserved!

JOHN
United States
15/12/2008
SHOE THROWER
I WOULD HAVE LIKED TO KNOW WHETHER THE VALIANT SHOE THROWER WOULD HAVE DARED TO DO THE SAME UNDER SADDAM HUSSEINS RULE. DONT FORGET, IT WAS BUSH WHO WAS INSTRUMENTAL IN GETTING RID OF SADDAM. BUT, NO WORRIES, SOONER OR LATER THE U.S.WILL BE OUT OF IRAQ AND THEN YOU WILL ENJOY THE PLEASURES OF SECTARIAN VIOLENCE WITH NO END IN SIGHT. LETS HOPE THAT WE DONT SEE ANOTHER GENOCIDE IN THE MAKING BETWEEN THE SECTS. THE SCENARIO IS ALMOST READY. THROW AS MANY SHOES AS YOU WANT, GET READY TO HANG....

John T. Marohn
United States
15/12/2008
Bush Shoe-Thrower
Throwing shoes at Mr Bush was the least an Iraqi could do to vent the anger against a man who was so reckless in attacking a sovereign country and causing the loss of over 100,000 Iraqis, not to mention the four million displaced in and out of the country. Mr Bush continues to use Iraq as his only icon of success, an illusory one at that. He hides behind the raw enthusiasm of the US troops who desperately want to be assured they haven't fought in vain. Two shoes? Al-Zeidi was kind.

PA
Afghanistan
15/12/2008
Bush Shoe Thrower
It seems to me that most of the posters are missing the point that there is no other country in the Middle East where throwing a shoe, or protesting after, would be allowed. Had the shoe been thrown at any other middle eastern leader this man would be dead.

Michael
United States
15/12/2008
BRAVO MR. AL ZEIDI
I applaud and thank Mr. Al Zeidi for his brave protest this morning. You are my new hero and I wish you the best in escaping any unneccessary punishment. Now its time for my fellow Americans to make sure our new President puts the Bush regime in jail for war crimes. Best Wishes from a white Christian American from New York City

mark
United States
15/12/2008
Muslim On Muslim Killing
The brit mentions the millions who have died since the US attack. My response is everyday we read of muslim on muslim killing. Shite/Sunni, etc. The Arab world can not accept that a non-arab country would come into both countries to establish democracy with no other intentions. Readers of my post please tell me in what other muslim country is there democracy?,womens rights, minority rights,e What would happen in Egypt, Iran, etc if a newsperson threw a shoe at the leaders of those countri

Nick
Afghanistan
15/12/2008
When will you learn
Those of you asking for the immediate release of the journalist are a disgrace to the civilized world. In no country are you granted the right to throw a shoe at a president of a foreign country, especially the leader of the free world that freed you from a vicious dictator. The thought that this man should be freed confirms my suspicions of why you were ruled by a dictator in the first place. Iraqi's should be insisting that charges be brought against this man, not that he be freed! Sad...

Sandra
Germany
15/12/2008
Very good
Bush trampled the the right of all Iraqis under his feet. He should be brought to Den Haag!

Sandra
Germany
15/12/2008
Free him...
Iraq has now the chance to change habits. After getting rid of Sadam, the man must be freed, otherwise nothing has changed. It's not a crime to throw a shoe in the direction of a true criminal.

stalin
United States
15/12/2008
wow, who does that
If the reporter wanted to protest he should of yelled something, but do not throw a shoe. The man is lucky he was not shot by the Secret Service. I may not like bush but throwing a shoe... come on.

A person
Afghanistan
17/12/2008
Free Bush shoe-thrower, Iraqis urge
There is a scale that I have not seen used yet. To this date if Saddam was still in power how many people would be dead because of him? Since George Bush's influence in Iraq with the war and other actions how many people to date, American and Iraqi's, are dead because of him? Unless I am mistaken, Bush win's as a war criminal.

TheFuzz
United States
15/12/2008
Bush shoe-thrower
Most americans want Zaidi freed, because we too wish to throw things at Bush.

John
Afghanistan
15/12/2008
shoes
While throwing something inkindergarden is fun. Adults don't normally do this. Freedom to speak is expected. If you throw rock, bottle, cemeicals or shoes.....then you become a criminal.

tjm308
Afghanistan
15/12/2008
ahhh...
Fine him $20, tell him not to do it again, and let him go. sorta of in poor taste, but what the hey ...

Richard
Iraq
15/12/2008
Shoe Throwing
i don't know which one was the biggest stupid idiot, the show thrower of that doofus Al Maliki who just stood there maybe when the numbskull Maliki comes to the US we shoudl return the courtesy.

Roy B
Iraq
15/12/2008
Free Bush shoe-thrower, Iraqis urge
I agree. free him. What he did was show his true feelings. Its just too bad it didn't hit Bush in the head. May-be he might have woken-up

Ben
United States
15/12/2008
Final "footnote" to Bush legacy in Iraq
I don't see how Mr. Zeidi could get into serious trouble for this. After all, he only did what millions of Iraqis and Americans have been wanting to do for about the last 6 years. Seems like he's well on his way to becoming a national hero, actually. On a side note I think it would be even worse for Bush's legacy (and the Iraqi government) if anything bad were to happen to Mr Zeidi.

Grant
Afghanistan
15/12/2008
Shoe-throwing Iraqi
It is one thing to demonstrate and demand human rights ... it is quite another to assault someone, no matter his stature or office. The rule of law is the rule of law and he should be charged accordingly!

amir m
United Kingdom
15/12/2008
shoe thrower
i want to shake this shoe-thrower's hand. well done. other so-called "leaders of the free world" watch out - a shoe is coming your way. seriously - this man should be released immediately. for all the misery and suffering cast upon the iraqi people by bush and his thugs a shoe throw is nothing. peace in palestine and iraq and afghanistan.........

keshet
Brazil
15/12/2008
shoes
Well done!!!! It is all the Bush deserves for all the innocent people that died on his war. I dont think it was an insult for a nation. It was just the way to show how bad Bush is.

Eddie Bumpus
Bahamas
15/12/2008
Shoe Thrower
This man is a journalist. Now in countries that actually have a free press, a journalist is supposed to be neutral. That means to report not resort to violence. So while the always angry masses of the middle east scream support for this man, ask yourself, had someone done this to an Imam, what would you say then?

LostintheUS
United States
15/12/2008
Free Shoe Thrower
Too bad he missed. Hooray for this brave young reporter! Release him and give him garlands of roses. Interesting that the only thing we've seen Bush do well is duck. He, Cheney and Rumsfeld should be tried for crimes against humanity. To the suffering people of Iraq: We elected Barack Obama largely because of what these monsters did to your country. Our prayers are with you and the families here who lost their beloved children in this war for oil.

Steve
United States
15/12/2008
Shoe Toss.
I wish his aim had been better. He is only expressing what so many Americans wish they could do if they had the chance to get so close. I apologize for having such a man represent Americans around the world. The next four years will be spent trying to repair old alliances and forging new ones. We look forward to Jan. 20th when Obama takes office. Hopefully the world will work together to build peace.

Jon
United States
15/12/2008
Shoe Thrower
I agree that President Bush deserves what he got. But not for killing innocent Iraqs, but for thinking he could help a country such as this.

Mike McGrath
United States
17/12/2008
Shoe Thrower
I guess this guy had to throw his shoes at Bush, because he was too inept a journalist to get his point across.

OT
Finland
17/12/2008
shoe-throwing
The politics of M. Bush in the Middle East is bad without doubt, but isn't this shoe-throwing a bit childish? For those who don't believe in superstitions about the impurity of shoes (!), this act ressembles more of a tantrum of an immature child than a serious expression of one's opinion.

ifay
United Kingdom
18/12/2008
stupid shoe thrower
im ashamed that this are the kind of people that arabs and muslims calls heros,lunatics.this arabs and muslims will never learn,no wonder they flocks to western borders every day seeking for asylum and refugees,because lunatics are their heros.arabs and muslims leaders are the worst dictators,why dont they throw shoe on them?if this lunatic journalist tries this on any arab leaders,he would have been 6fit below by now.may Godbless bush

Ryan M. Haque
Bangladesh
18/12/2008
The television picture showed at after two shoes were hurled to President Bush, he just shrugged and made light of it! meaning it was just a pun!! So, why charging someone and sending him to jail for 2 years or more while to the victim it is simply a pun??!!

rakesh
India
18/12/2008
Free Bush Shoe-thrower,
He should be hanged not freed how dare he throwing the shoes to the president. He is totaly shame for iraqis showing they are still need somebody to teach how to behave.

abbar
Brunei Darussalam
20/12/2008
Show Throwing Inciddent
Bush was lucky that the Journalist was just throwing his shoes not bombs to express his dissisfiction at Bush unlike Bush who killed hundred of thousands of Iraqis to express his disatisfaction of Saddam's rule.

M.Nassar
Saudi Arabia
21/12/2008
Shoe throwing a blessing or a curse ?
They do say you reap what you sow !! the Bush Admin watched shoes thrown on Saddams pictures, years later the Bush admin had a taste of the same medicine. The thing is was that correct ? history tells us the freedom does not come at an easy cost hundreds of thousands of Americans died in there war for independence against the English , people died maybe shoes were thrown if not worse but a hundred years later America ruled the world. so again i ask was the shoe a blessing or curse?

Glen
United States
21/12/2008
Shoe Toss
Whether it was a President or a pauper, he still committed an assault. Accordingly, he should be punished. However, in recognition that there was no real physical danger to either the President or the Prime Minister he should receive no more than a small fine and a probated sentence.

Dan
United States
17/12/2008
As much as I have to hand it to this guy for standing up for himself - I have to feel bad for his supporters. We've been demanding the president's immediate release for 8 years now, and no luck!

Tony
United States
18/12/2008
Free him!
This man did not try to physically hurt President Bush. This was a symbolic act. Regardless of Bush's intentions for going into Iraq, the fact is that the US-led war has been an absolute disaster. Iraqis have endured the unspeakable, and thus the only appropriate response must be an act more than mere words. This has more meaning than any question a reporter could ask. Given the circumstances, this was a very civil and appropriate act. Not a bomb, a shoe! Free this man!

SHN
Maldives
18/12/2008
I envy that i was'nt the one who thew it. Free him!!!!

Misganaw
Ethiopia
18/12/2008
It is not acceptable!
I couldnt agree with the Iraqis demonistrator for asking "the reporter to be freed" this is not the right way to express feelings.ofcourse bush did wrong thing by invading others teretory for what ever reason forewarded.Any ways the reporter should get punished accordingly! May God bless every Nation!!!

sage
United States
20/12/2008
ha!
if the government is going to detain someone for a "barbaric and ignominious act," they should have detained bush a long time ago. bush deserves so much worse than having shoes thrown at him, he needs to seriously be tried for war crimes and human rights violations, and spend the rest of his life in direct service to the wounded and disabled soldiers and civilians. the punishment must fit the crime!

Mary
United States
20/12/2008
Shoe Thrower
Free him at once! al-Zeidi is the hero of the world. What a dark, dark day in our US history when Bush invaded a sovereign nation and had their leader assassinated. Bush must be brought to the world court and charged with war crimes. I can't wait to get rid of him!

s.f.
United States
21/12/2008
the Bush Shoe
My first reaction was to laugh, then clap, followed by "Whoa, thanks for not killing him. President Chaney would not be good." The angry shoe tossing reporter doesn't deserve marks to his face from rough treatment, and doesn't deserve jail time. He apologized in an adult manner, and that should be good enough.

David
Iraq
21/12/2008
Why he is detained
PM Maliki, of the Dawa Party, is not a U.S. Puppet. Dawa Party was around before Iraq Iran war. US soldiers think he should get a slap on the wrist and released. The Iraqis are keeping him detained because he disrespected their guest. No matter who your guess is, even Hitler, by disrespecting them you disrespect the host. A small majority of Shias in Sadr city do not speak for the entire country, no matter how Al-Jazeera phrases their headings.

HAKIM A
Afghanistan
21/12/2008
REACTION ABOUT BUSH SHOE-THROWER
what else could Iraqis who have suffered for long under this unpopular war do? it wasnot good for ahead of state but this showed their disgust for the war which has costed their lives and property!

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article