UPDATED ON:
Monday, January 12, 2009
12:00 Mecca time, 09:00 GMT
News Middle East
Gazans fear Israel using phosphorus

Human Rights Watch said it was clear Israel had fired shells containing white phopshorus[GALLO/GETTY] 

Doctors in Gaza City have told Al Jazeera that people have been admitted suffering burns consistent with the use of the controversial chemical white phosphorus.

Human rights campaigners say that Israeli forces have used the munition, which can burn away human flesh to the bone, over Gaza City and Jabaliya in recent days.

Al Jazeera's Ayman Mohyeldin, reporting from the Shifa hospital in Gaza City, said: "Doctors here say they are seeing unprecedented levels of deep burns.

"They cannot categorically say that white phosphorus is being used, they are saying that the munitions being dropped are unprecendented."

Residents in densely-packed Jabaliya have described Israeli forces exploding shells that drop scores of burning fragments and spread suffocating smoke.

"Its the first time we see this type of weapon, it must be new and its seems like its phosphorous," one resident told Al Jazeera.

"Its suffocating and has a deadly poisonous smell that I am sure will cause a lot of sickness and disease on all of the civilians here," he said.

Another witness said she saw "... a bright flash and then all of these sparks fell on our area ... landing all around us and in our homes. Our mattresses caught on fire".

Law 'violated'

The use of the munition in densely-populated areas violates the requirement under international humanitarian law for all feasible precautions to be taken to avoid civilian injury and loss of life, Human Rights Watch said.

IN DEPTH

Analysis and features from Gaza and Israel

Track the war and submit your own reports

Send us your views and eyewitness videos

Watch our coverage of the war on Gaza

International law permits the use of white phosphorus in order to cover troop movements and prevent enemies from using certain guided weapons.

Marc Garlasco, a senior military analyst at the human rights group told Al Jazeera on Saturday that he had watched Israeli ground forces using white phosphorus. 

"Clearly it is [white phosphorus], we can tell by the explosions and the tendrils that go down [and] the fires that were burning," he said.

"Today there were massive attacks in Jabaliya when we were there. We saw that there were numerous fires once the white phosphorus had gone in.

"We went by Israeli artillery units that had white phosphorus rounds with the fuses in them."

Major Avital Leibovich, an Israeli military spokeswoman, told Al Jazeera that the Israeli army was "using munitions with accordance to international law".

"The policy of the IDF [Israeli Defence Force] is to not specify the types of munition, we have not done it before and we will not do it now."

Mark Regev, the Israeli government spokesman, said he was unable to confirm or deny whether the military was using the chemical, but that Israel did not use munitions that were banned under international law.

"I don't have the knowledge of the detail of what ammunition we are using. I can only know for a fact that Israel uses no ammunition that is outlawed under conventions and that Nato forces would not use in a similar combat situation," he told Al Jazeera.

Israel used white phosphorus during its 34-day war against Lebanon's Hezbollah movement in 2006, while the United States used it during the controversial siege of the Iraqi city of Fallujah in 2004.

 Source: Al Jazeera and agencies
 
Topics in this article
Country

City

Feedback Number of comments : 23
 
sabiha khan
Kenya
11/01/2009
are we not human?????
it is so sad to see poor little children and innocent civilians of gaza dying.i mean what have the little children done to deserve such painfull deaths,to see their own parents dying infront of them,to see their very own siblings dying.no human has the right to kill another human.to all those killing innocent people just remember God i watching you.

paul stevens
United States
11/01/2009
Phosphorus
Hamas now wants rules of engagement? Sounds to me they kinda wish they had followed the rules all along . Maybe Iran should take a real good look at what is going on. They are next. One thing on Iran's side is they have an educated population of people that will get rid of the nut job ruining they're country.

Naim
United Kingdom
11/01/2009
Israel Uses Phosporous
Murderers! purely and simply , thats what isaraelis are. Israel cowardly using chemical warfare, when they know they cannot defeat the spirit of conviction of the hamas and palestinian people.

Robert
Netherlands Antilles
11/01/2009
Damage
There is a HUGE difference between the use of phosphorus against terrorists and Grads loaded with nails and bearing balls to maim innocent children

faisa
United Kingdom
11/01/2009
phosphorus
why do the un just watch this cruelty they know what damage it causes they should be ashamed of them selves i would give up my life to save my brothers and sister

Naeema
United States
11/01/2009
No one cares
It's amusing how anything hamas does is put out of proportion when they are protcting their country and the jews are using WP because they know that no one can charge them with anything since they are above the law. how come no one is talking about the fact that isreal violated the truce way before hamas threw the rockets by not reducing millitary blockage of Gaza and killing 6 civilians on Nov 4th 2008 among everything they do and hide

d_anthony
United States
11/01/2009
White phosphorus
I'm a firm believer that Israel has a sovereign right to defend itself. I also firmly believe the Hamas are using the people in Palestine as human shields to wage their war. However I do think the use of white phosphorus is clearly not called for by Israel. The innocent people in Palestine deserve better than this. At least air drops of aid from the US.

Dharmeehan
Sri Lanka
11/01/2009
Please Stop...
Please stop the war. Dont kill innocent children, women. Israel's fault or Hama's fault, first start to a peace talk. And dont violate WAR RULES. From Tamil Eelam

han
United States
11/01/2009
Phosphorus
Since when has Israel obeyed international laws or UN resolutions. These are for all others to obey.

Darach
Ireland
11/01/2009
The first casualty of war is the truth as shown in the heartless reactions of those who blame the victims in Gaza for this genocidal attack. Why is it that the first to condemn are those who know nothing apart from the lies they are fed? Instead of believing those preventing foreign journalists entering the prison created for Palestine, Americans and others should pay heed to the UN observers, Red Cross, doctors and others who have seen the horror at first hand. No more lies, and no more death.

Tom
Afghanistan
11/01/2009
To the occupiers of the stolen lands
To the occupiers of the stolen lands and those who support them. No longer can your glossy veil hide or change the shape of what’s underneath, No longer can you draw sympathy for your cause by the events of the past. No longer can your conscience bathe in the river of peace.

Anna Shane
United States
11/01/2009
Phosphorus ...
I share in this shame, the US did the same thing, where is Princess Di when we need her. This needs to be addressed by an enormous public outcry. I think they use these weapons to 'blind' snipers, and save individual soldiers. That should have been yet one more reason to refrain from waging war an an already 'defeated' people.

ricardom2009
Canada
11/01/2009
Gaza conflict
The conflict in Gaza is not about who is right or who is wrong, just or unjust, good or evil. It is not a conflict between equals. It is a conflict between the strong and the weak. The strong dominates and takes what it wants and the weak either yields or gets destroyed. It has always been, is and will be this way: the strong do what they can and the weak suffer what they must. Between the strong and the weak, might is right. Who is just or unjust, good or evil only apply between equals.

bOB
United States
11/01/2009
Israli war crime
The use of white phosporus against is a crime. The Israelis should be condemmed for thses actions. The worst part is my country supplies the weapons. The Israelis violate the arms aggrement. The congress turns around and supports them. They do not speak fior the American people. The Israelis are liable for the war crimes they are responsable for.

Shadia Al-Sabban
United States
11/01/2009
The Wrong of the Israelis
Watching the news from Aljazeera today it's not hard to see that what's going on in Gaza is wrong. What's worse is that the United States won't act on it. You would think that since the Jewish were tortured by Hitler, put in rooms filled with gas, they wouldn't enact the same concept upon others. When they told them "never forget" it seems that they never have, Hitler taught them well! The isolation of this country and bombing it with chemicals is the same thing, but on a larger scale.

Ryan
United States
11/01/2009
Civilian Knowledge
It is very interesting to me that civilians would know that much about phosphorous. "Its the first time we see this type of weapon, it must be new and its seems like its phosphorous," -Seriously? Is this the foundation of this article? Of course there are going to be victims with burns after shells are dropped into their houses, but that doesn't necessarily mean that its phosphorous. I feel like someone is trying to exaggerate the weapons Israel is using.

James
Canada
11/01/2009
Is the law good for one and not good for the other?
Hezballa used Bombs with Ball Bearings shelling Haifa and kiling and wounding many civilians and Hamas used Bombs exploading with nails and bolts in Restaurants. so is that legal? why is Hezballa and Hamas are allowed to used this type of bombs and Israel is not? Is the law good for one and not good for the other?

renita
United States
11/01/2009
the united states citizens should be outraged! the use of phosphorus is sub-human regardless of the rules of engagement.

matt
United States
11/01/2009
Gaza
Why is it that Israel is dropping white phosphorous? Think about this, in Sderot, they had to build a playground with a bomb shelter. You may say that Israel is being disproportionate, but as the mayor of New York said, "if there is a mad man at your door telling you that he will kill you, do you want one police officer, which is proportionate, or do you want as many resources as can be offered."

C. M. Ashley
United States
14/01/2009
white phosphorus
This article confirms that the Israelis are using White Phosphorus http://www.globalsecurityassociates.com/ http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/systems/munitions/wp.htm MILITARY White Phosphorus (WP) Israel used White Phosphorus against HAMAS targets in Gaza during Operation Cast Lead in January 2009. ...

Fred Tufie Thomas
United States
14/01/2009
Hamas Started It Israel Will End It!
Hams had plenty of chances of stopping the Rockets and seeking a Permanent Peace. They chose war and let the Palestinians down. No one is going to listen to Bully that cries about being beaten, when they demanded a beaten by their own behavior!

Jose MataMoros
Mexico
14/01/2009
Red Cross
The International Committee of the Red Cross urged Israel to exercise "extreme caution" in using the incendiary agent, which is used to eliminate targets at night or create a smoke screen for day attacks, said Peter Herby, the head of the organization's mines-arms unit. Herby told The Associated Press: "It's not very unusual to use phosphorus to create smoke or illuminate a target. We have no evidence to suggest white phosphorus' being used in any other way."

Sabonna
Ethiopia
14/01/2009
What brutallity instigated against innocent civilans of Gaza? The US is watching the death toll and sit idle and say nothing. Ironically, the US administration does not want any terrorists to plot crime against humanity. But, this one seems to them that the children are even member of the Hamas. You try to maintain peace in the world and you also mess up the global order. If the world keep silent and watch the genocide, Israel will never stop enjoying killing inocent gazans.

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article
Aljazeera.net/english 2003 - 2010 ©
Designed & Developed by Aljazeera IT