UPDATED ON:
Monday, July 21, 2008
06:33 Mecca time, 03:33 GMT
Programmes LISTENING POST
Arab media 'blind to Darfur'

 

The conflict in Darfur is a news story that has been widely and emotively covered by Western media but has attracted relatively little coverage within the Arab media.

The Listening Post's Salah Khadr finds out why.

There are many similarities between the violence in Iraq and Darfur from the estimate of the number of civilians killed to paramilitaries operating closely linked to the government forces, to victims who are targeted for membership of an ethnic group.

However, international media coverage generally reports one as a civil war or cycle of insurgency and the other as a genocide.

More than 200,000 people have died in the conflict in Darfur, with millions more turned into refugees and the situation becoming a picture of "hell on earth" according to the UN.

Sudan's population is 40 per cent Arab and Arabs are at the heart of the conflict, but for many in the Arab world, the humanitarian catastrophe may as well not exist.

The reason being the Arab media have largely ignored it.

Lawrence Pintak, a journalist and Arab media expert, says the problem with Darfur when it comes to the Arab media is that it does not fit the template of Arabs being the victims and other people the aggressors.

"Arabs here are good guys and bad guys," he says.

'State of denial'

"I think we are in a state of denial," Jehad Khazen, a former editor of the al-Hayat newspaper, says.

"People say 'the Arabs or Muslims – cannot do this – it did not happen' – but they did do this and it did happen - and they have to reconcile themselves to the fact."

Listening Post
Find out more about the programme
Just because the Arab media does not cover a lot of what happens in the Darfur crisis does not mean that Arab public opinion is not interested says Nadim Hasbani, an Arab media analyst from the International Crisis Group.

"A Zogby poll around March or April in 2007 showed there is a real eagerness in Arab public opinion to read more and learn more about what is happening in Darfur. But this is not reflected in the Arab media."

It could be argued that geography plays a role in the limited coverage given the conflict is in Africa, not the Middle East.

But whilst Darfur largely remains a non-event on the Arab media scene, European and North American media travel from greater distances to cover this story.

"There is always going to be some sort of reluctance to demonise their own, the Arabs as they will see themselves," Opheera McDoom, Reuters correspondent in Darfur, says.

"But I think while there has been coverage in the Arab media, there has been a reluctance in the Arab media to go to Darfur and check things out for themselves.

"I see a lot more western media going to Darfur and spending weeks in Darfur than I do Arab media and that is where you see the difference. You will get a much more in-depth coverage and a lot more interesting coverage if you actually go to Darfur, and that is where the Arab media has fallen down."

However, some Arab media analysts say that the implied rationale from the American media in particular is that the story in Darfur is Arabs killing Africans because they do not know anything other than violence.

US suspicion

"That's what the audience is left to conclude," says Mahmood Mahdani of Columbia University.

"So that's of course not acceptable if you are part of the Arab media. You can immediately sense that you are being caricatured and demonised at the same time."

 It is questionable, however, if such suspicions over the motivation and vigour of US media coverage account for the strategy of limited coverage from many Arab media outlets.

Arab media's coverage of Darfur is often more analysis than reporting [EPA]
"What is most striking to me is that the media coverage has a single focus and that's a focus on atrocities, on atrocity stories, there's no attempt to place them in context," Mahdani says.

"There's no attempt to explain, to locate it historically, to show that there's any change happening.

"I think it is about linking Darfur with the larger war on terror by portraying and framing the perpetrators of violence in Darfur as Arabs."

The 22 Arab states all have a distinctive media output and often it is not so much a question of following an agenda but deciding which agenda to follow.

"It is not one agenda – every Arab government has a different agenda from the other – Egypt is more interested in Darfur as Sudan is next door and doesn't want a spill over," Khazen says.

"But a country a like the UAE or Oman – find they are not directly involved and they can't influence events – so you find that the coverage is much more limited there."

Government hindrance

Covering Darfur is also hindered by the government of Sudan who have imposed strict access criteria and will often not issue visas or take journalists to government-controlled areas.

"They [the government] know that if more information comes out there will be added pressure on the Sudanese government," Hasbani says.

"It's not easy to cover Darfur – its not easy for Western Journalists and its not easy for Arab journalists," Lawrence Pintak says.

"I talked to an Al Jazeera correspondent who was based in Khartoum a while back – and he said to go and cover Darfur – you have to go to Khartoum – then to Nairobi – to West Africa up to Cameroon, across from Cameroon to Chad and then in through the back door to the refugee camps.

"If you don't do that then you are on a guided tour and you may as well go to Disneyland."

The result of these restrictions has been a move toward more analytical coverage and away from hard reporting.

"What's happened in Arab media is that we have so much coverage of the political issues related to Darfur like – what is the UK, France, US, UN reaction to Darfur – but what we really need actually is not the political coverage, but the coverage from the ground," Hasbani says.

"What are the facts, what are the stories, where are the images of the refugees of the people being killed? These are images we don't have but are the images we need – its not about the political process."


Listening Post special on the media coverage of Darfur can be seen on Al Jazeera from Friday July 12 at the following times GMT:

Friday 1230 and 2030; Satruday 0430; Sunday 0600; Monday 0530; Tuesday 0730 and 2330; Wednesday 0300 and 1930; Thursday 0630 and 1430

 Source: Al Jazeera
 
Topics in this article
People

Country

Organisation

Feedback Number of comments : 17
 
Chris
Sweden
12/07/2008
Darfur
Another conclusion would be that arab media is not interested if the killings can't be pinned on the US

Dhoruba Bin-Wahad
United States
12/07/2008
Arabs and Africa
Darfur is not covered by the Arab media or the Muslim ummah because of the history of the Arab presence in Africa, the history of Pan-Arabism as a secular movement to displace Ottoman rule and trump European imperial machinations in the region.

kj
Afghanistan
18/07/2008
lawlessness abounds
face the facts, the west wants the icc and un impotent to protect israel from war crimes and "nuclear ambitions". their same polices give rise to torture and thugs in burma or equatorial gunea. they invade other countries like hitler. they pick and choose when to apply laws and when to villify and that is why others behave the same - because the west is unprincipled and amoral. how can the west punnish daufar when bush/cheney killed 1.3M and displaced 4.5M all to control iraq's oil?

Mussa
Israel
18/07/2008
Darfur
Oh it is a great tragidy indeed.... I hope god willing, they will find a peacful end to this horrible situation. Many people dying, and for what? for nothing at all. I believe that since the arab media is still relitivly "young" it will take time before the population is ready to hear about internal conflicts. We always hear about the US and Iraq, Israel and the Palestinians, Lebanon and Israel, Iran and the rest of the world. This is important news, however, there is more happening.....

Ben
United States
19/07/2008
Darfur:"Arab Media" vs "Western Media"
And is the "Arab Media" expected to cover Darfur as "poorly in analysis" as Mamdani points out? Read The Guardian's Jonathan Steele's critique of "How the [Western] Media prolonged war in Darfur" http://tinyurl.com/42pxu3

ANDAR1000
Colombia
01/08/2008
Arab Media Blind to Darfur
I think Timo, Finland hit the spot. There is a complete lack of self-criticism in the Arab and muslim world. It's as if they are above everyone else and can do no wrong. Darfur is an example where they can go wrong and can't accept it. It's no better or worse than anybody else.

Dieter Klapschitz
Germany
12/07/2008
Darfur
I think if the combined forces of Paco and Beau were committed to this fight it would bring about a lasting resolution. Dieter

Casey Brennan
United States
13/07/2008
Darfur
I think it's pretty simple. Arab media tend not to want to highlight actions that show Arabs in a bad light. This is a human reaction. Especially with the negative image already portrayed about Arabs and Muslims in the some media outlets. Similarly, American media do not want to believe or write about atrocties committed by Americans. But they happen and should be fully exposed.

Norma
United States
13/07/2008
question
I heard an older university professor, expert on Sudan, explain the conflict roots in terms of drought and overpopulation causing tribal clashes. That the rest of the issues are political posturing on top, like icing, hiding the reality in fantacy, like the stereotypical image of fanatical Arabs and genocide. I would like to know if that is true. A few years ago it was the "slavery" markets that were hyped. That myth has been debunked. When will we hear the truth about Darfur?

Magnus
Sweden
14/07/2008
Its a shame
I think it is a shame that arab media won't report from Darfur. If our both cultures is to aquire a larger understanding for eachothers we also have to be aware of our own respective weaknessess. Regards Magnus

Karim
Egypt
14/07/2008
Norma I salute you
For gods sake has anyone ever bothered to study this?! In egypt, as slyly and briefly mentioned in the article the subject DOES have huge political coverage, but coverage on the ground nonetheless. For gods sake check out "Al Ahram" online newspaper in google, they have a whole page dedicated to africa which 99% features Sudan as well as the front page always featuring it. Norma you are precisley right, its all about the southern area of sudan where fertile soil and resources are plentiful.

ABU MUUSAA
United States
16/07/2008
arab media blind to darfur
as salaamu alaikum naam this is a shame first for us as muslims for Allaah told us to tell the truth even if its against of self or kinfolk.and we see this killing and raping and upsurping of property by arabs/muslims.didnt the prophet saws state that a muslims blood honour and property is sacred.mashaallaah and we dont find noone but the kuffar speaking out against this.no naseehah from the ulema of ahlu sunnah and this hurts will this be the case if it was bolack muslims doing this to arabs

Mazen El-Khairy
Afghanistan
16/07/2008
Darfur, Bashir, Bush et al
Norma's old professor is right. If you dig into it you'll find that Bush and the EU leadership have a big hand in what is happening in Darfur. Add to that the crimes against humanity in Iraq, Afghanistan, Palestine, Somalia, Congo etc and our dear 'Prosecutor' will be a very busy man indeed!

Brian
Thailand
17/07/2008
Muslims can do no wrong!
It is clear that the Arab media does not want to report this genocide because most of the Arab World is muslim. If the world knows that muslims are slaughtering Christians in Sudan, then the muslims will lose their political highground as being the "persecuted underdogs".

Timo
Finland
19/07/2008
hypocrite ?
USA is Killing arabs in Iraq (or preventing other muslims killing fellow arabs), Israel is opressing palestinian arabs (or giving them better oppurtunities than their brothers have in other Arab countries). But Arabs are silent when arabs are killing other muslims. If you read Israeli newspapers you will see a lot of articles condemning their own deeds but same sort of self-criticality is virtually absent in arab media. can arabs demand change from Israel without being hypocrite ?

idris hassan
United States
30/07/2008
war in somalia
i think its really funny whats going on . i mean i have never seen a country that speaks the same language , have the same religion, have the same culture but yet can't co-exist.

ANDAR1000
Colombia
01/08/2008
Arab media blind to Darfur
I disagree completely with the comparison between Iraq and Sudan. In Sudan, there is a systematic government sponsored ethnic cleasing of non-arab tribes. Arabs are trying to steal the land of black africans. This is genocide when a specific ethic group is targeted for extermination. In Iraq, it is a centuries old ethnic rivalries where there may be fighting, but no ethnic cleanising and most importantly, the government is not supporting it.

 
ARTICLE TOOLS
 Email Article  Email article
 Print Article  Print article
 Send Feedback  Send feedback
 Share article  Share article
Aljazeera.net/english 2003 - 2010 ©
Designed & Developed by Aljazeera IT